The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commissioners voted to unseal trip data provided by ride-sharing company Lyft while it was under a cease-and-desist order earlier this year.

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette had filed an emergency petition seeking to unseal the information, which was provided to two administrative law judges during hearings in Pittsburgh in August and September.  Lyft sought to protect information about the number of trips it provided customers while under the cease-and-desist order as proprietary.

While the commissioners disagreed with the portion of the Post-Gazette’s petition that sought to unseal the data on an emergency basis, it agreed that the information should be available to the public. The trip data will be publicly available in 10 days’ time. Lyft can still appeal the matter to Commonwealth Court.

“Transportation network companies are in the markeplace, however there are rules that need to be applied to these entities so that they operate properly,” said PUC chairman Robert Powelson. “The story has yet to be told how this could be used against Lyft by its competitors. But I should note that there is a tremendous transportation void in the Pittsburgh region. It’s important we note that here this morning.”

Advertise with us

Commissioner Pamela Witmer cast the sole dissenting vote. “I believe publicly disclosing the number of rides is confidential and will allow Lyft’s competitors to gain info it can and will use to harm Lyft in the future,” Ms. Witmer said. “It will allow Lyft’s competitors to assess and calcuate its market share, and to model and forecast Lyft’s activity. We need to err on the side of caution and properly protect this information Lyft seeks to treat as confidential.”

Lyft spokeswoman Paige Thelen said the company had shared the data with the PUC with the understanding it would remain confidential, and plans to appeal the decision.

“Releasing this data will not improve the safety of people in Pittsburgh or make it easier for them to access much-needed reliable and affordable transportation,” Ms. Thelen said in a statement. “Instead, it will harm Lyft and other businesses that have also shared confidential information with the PUC to help inform policy decisions. We will appeal this decision and urge the PUC to reconsider this action.”

Lyft and its rival ride share company Uber moved into the Pittsburgh area earlier this year, and have been struggling with state requirements for transportation companies since. The companies connect drivers in their own vehicles with customers via smartphone apps.

Several pieces of proposed legislation to create the new category of transportation network company, which would cover Lyft and Uber, have not progressed in the Legislature.

Advertise with us

The PUC commissioners also formally voted this morning to approve the petitions for Lyft and Uber to extend the temporary emergency authority for each to continue operating in Allegheny County. The commissioners have yet to decide on the companies’ applications for permanent licenses in Pittsburgh and other parts of the state. The PUC’s administrative law judges voted to deny both companies’ applications to operate on a permanent basis.

Kim Lyons: klyons@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1241. On Twitter: @SocialKimly