HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court is “institutionally out of control,” and the judicial career of Justice Seamus McCaffery could be in peril, now that the state government’s pornographic email scandal has mushroomed into a case of alleged blackmail.
Justice J. Michael Eakin, a Republican, was identified Friday by the Philadelphia Daily News as the recipient of several lewd, pornographic and racist emails that were circulated in 2010. Within hours, Justice Eakin had responded to the report, saying in a statement sent to reporters and the Judicial Conduct Board that the emails in question were sent to a personal “John Smith” Yahoo account that he’d set up years ago.
And in the same letter, Justice Eakin pointed the finger at Justice McCaffery, accusing the Democratic jurist of “causing” the release of the emails.
Later in the day, Justice McCaffery denied threatening or attempting to coerce Justice Eakin, and denied leaking the contents of the emails, but it’s a denial that rang hollow to court observers.
“The behavior described by Justice Eakin is extortion under Pennsylvania law,” said Bruce Ledewitz, a professor at Duquesne University Law School. “It's a terrible thing that Justice McCaffery is suggested to have done, [and it demonstrates] an atmosphere of vindictiveness and corruption on that court.”
The court, led by Chief Justice Ronald Castille, a Republican, is “institutionally out of control,” Mr. Ledewitz said.
In the written statement issued Friday, Justice Eakin alleged: “Yesterday, Justice McCaffery caused certain material, sent to my private email account some years ago, to be given to the media. I have not seen the material, nor do I wish to, but insofar as receiving such may be seen as violative of the rules of conduct, I have referred the matter to the Judicial Conduct Board.”
He went on to say he received an early morning phone call Thursday from Justice McCaffery, who “[became] more agitated as the call progressed.”
“Justice McCaffery said he was receiving communications from ‘people,’ and that ‘they’ had in their possession inappropriate emails that involved me. He described the purported nature of the emails, which involved my private ‘John Smith’ Yahoo email account. Specifically, he named one person that was on the other end of the email exchange, to convince me that they did exist and that he had seen them personally. The subject of much recent publicity concerning the sending of salacious emails, Justice McCaffery next told me he ‘was not going down alone.’
“Justice McCaffery told me that I had to cause the Chief Justice to retract his media statements of the prior day. I told him I would not attempt to do so even if it were possible. He repeated that I had to, and that he 'needed an answer' by noon to prevent release of the emails involving my account.”
Justice Eakin said later that day at an event in Philadelphia, he was approached by reporters from The Philadelphia Inquirer and Daily News about the racy emails.
In his own response, Justice McCaffery said he had a Thursday phone conversation with Justice Eakin — but said it was to aid him, not threaten him.
“The purpose of my call was to inform him that I was hearing strong rumors that a personal email account that belonged to him contained not only hundreds of sexually explicit emails, but — even worse — racially offensive images. In light of my own recent experience, and given the way these emails have been leaking, I expressed my concern for him, especially because of the racially-charged emails, which, as I recall, I told him I feared could bring him down.”
And by Friday evening, Justice Eakin had responded once more.
“ I have read Justice McCaffery’s self-victimizing explanation. I find it incomplete, and inaccurate in many details and specifics ... I stand completely behind my statements about the call, every word.”
The unfolding, unseemly spectacle prompted the chancellor of the Philadelphia Bar Association to call for a special counsel to be appointed to assist the Supreme Court “and undertake a full and fair investigation of this matter.”
“Conduct of this nature, at a minimum, causes the appearance of impropriety and potentially questions Justice McCaffery’s impartiality having to do with any number of cases,” said William Fedullo, chancellor of the association, in a statement Friday, which also called for the matter to be referred to the Judicial Conduct Board “for immediate review.”
Earlier this week, Chief Justice Castille announced that data provided by state Attorney General Kathleen Kane showed that Justice McCaffery had sent or received 234 emails with sexually explicit images or videos. Hundreds of pornographic emails, released last month by the attorney general, have already led one cabinet secretary and a member of the state’s Board of Probation and Parole to resign, and were purportedly circulated among top state law enforcement officials and jurists.
Justice McCaffery on Thursday apologized for what he called a “lapse in judgment” regarding sending the emails, but also lashed out at Chief Justice Castille’s “vindictive pattern of attacks” against him. The two Philadelphia judges have a long-running personal feud, some of which Justice McCaffery detailed in his own statement to the media, claiming Chief Justice Castille has waged his vendetta since Justice McCaffery joined the high court in 2008.
Justice McCaffery said the chief justice is angry because of Justice McCaffery’s criticism over a controversial court construction project in Philadelphia, as well as the chief justice’s handling of a Luzerne County scandal over kickbacks to juvenile court judges from the owner of a private corrections facility.
“He has been on this mission because I had the guts to challenge him on the [Philadelphia] Family Court fiasco and on what the citizens of Pennsylvania got for the more than $3 million of First Judicial District funds that were funneled to one of his closest friends,” Justice McCaffery wrote. “And I had the guts to challenge him on his disastrous handling of Pennsylvania’s worst judicial scandal and a tragic injustice that will forever be known as the Kids for Cash” scandal.
The series of recent missteps — Kids for Cash, the arrest and conviction of former Justice Joan Orie Melvin on theft and criminal conspiracy charges, the blowback from the middle-of-the-night 2005 pay raise, and now this — cast a harsh light on the nation’s oldest Supreme Court, and threatens the public’s confidence in the institution, said Lynn A. Marks, executive director of Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts.
“I find it extremely troubling,” Ms. Marks said. “We want our judges to be qualified, fair and impartial [and] have good judgment. And I’m just wondering about the judgment at this point.”
Asked about the future of Justice McCaffery, Mr. Ledewitz and Ms. Marks said they doubted he would step down, despite some calls for him to do so.
“I don’t think it’s in him to resign,” Ms. Marks said. “He’s a Marine.”
He could also be suspended by his colleagues on the court, and Chief Justice Castille, in his own press statements, suggested that “the high court now needs to ponder possible action.” But Mr. Ledewitz believes Chief Justice Castille’s own starring role in the ongoing grudge match means it might be difficult to collect the four votes needed to remove Justice McCaffery from the court.
Chief Justice Castille’s court now “lacks credibility,” he said, and would be wise to allow the Judicial Conduct Board and the state Court of Judicial Discipline to handle the matter.
“The court cannot be fixed” from the inside, Mr. Ledewitz said. “This is Larsen and Zappala and Cappy all over again.”
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com. Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.