HARRISBURG -- After a morning of closed-courtroom testimony and recess consultations Wednesday, the judge in the challenge to the Pennsylvania voter ID law pushed closing arguments to today.

Commonwealth Court Judge Bernard McGinley has heard more than two weeks of statements and testimony on a petition to permanently stop the state from requiring one of several forms of photo identification at the polls. The Pennsylvania voter ID requirement became law in March 2012, but it was blocked from full enforcement at the elections that November.

Attorneys fighting the law have presented the findings of a statistician who said hundreds of thousands of Pennsylvania voters lack identification issued by the Department of Transportation and the testimony of elderly voters who say they would have difficulty traveling to a PennDOT licensing center to obtain an ID.

The Corbett administration maintains that acceptable identification is available to any voter who wants it.

Advertise with us

Throughout the hearing, the law's challengers have also said that information kept by the state shows some voters who sought a state-issued ID card before the November 2012 election received the document after Election Day or never received it.

The exact number of voters in that circumstance was unclear, as a witness from the Department of State testified that some people on the list had other acceptable identification. On Tuesday afternoon, the challengers presented the testimony of an analyst who used data from the state to determine how many voters, under different sets of assumptions, had trouble obtaining identification.

Attorneys for the state said the data included private information, and Judge McGinley closed the courtroom for the questioning Tuesday and cross-examination Wednesday morning. Closing arguments had been expected Wednesday, but the judge said they would take place Thursday morning.

Under the most conservative assumptions, according to a redacted version of the analyst's report, there were still voters who have not received an ID card or who applied before the November election, but received it afterward.

Had the voter ID requirement been in full effect last November, those people would have been kept from voting, said Witold Walczak, legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania.

Advertise with us

An attorney for the state rejected the analysis, saying it was based on a misunderstanding of how the databases work.

The attorney, Alicia Hickok, said some voters who sought ID before the election did not receive it until afterward because of discrepancies between their identifying information and how they are listed in the voter registration database.

She said state employees have since learned how to better search for matches.