HARRISBURG -- In a bitter and secret legal fight, state Attorney General Kathleen Kane has succeeded in ousting the judge who has long overseen corruption investigations in Pennsylvania, The Inquirer has learned.

After a conflict that had been roiling since she took office in January, Ms. Kane took the unusual step of asking the state Supreme Court to remove Judge Barry F. Feudale as the supervising grand jury judge in Harrisburg. Ms. Kane told the high court in April in sealed papers that the judge was no longer fit to run a grand jury.

Among other concerns, she cited an episode in which Judge Feudale, stopping at her offices, showed a secretary a 10-inch knife.

Judge Feudale, 67, has overseen grand juries in some of the Attorney General's Office's biggest cases, including the Bonusgate scandal in the Legislature and the Penn State University child sex-abuse case. Asked about Ms. Kane's allegations, he called them "a sneak attack" that twisted facts.

Advertise with us

"Kane is a politician first, second, and third, and perhaps an AG ... fourth and fifth," he said.

Ms. Kane's communications director, Joe Peters, rejected Judge Feudale's criticism. "She's attorney general, first and only," he said.

The dispute is part of a larger struggle, between the new attorney general and her office's old guard of career prosecutors, that has spilled over into how several high-stakes cases are being handled -- including a probe into political corruption in several counties, according to people familiar with the situation. The scope and specifics of that investigation could not be learned.

The battle between Ms. Kane and Judge Feudale could also have repercussions for the recent charges against eight people in a pay-to-play scandal at the Pennsylvania Turnpike.

The dispute features strong personalities. The judge is a hiker, climber and kayaker, fond of piloting his Cessna to county courthouses across the state, and blunt-spoken on and off the bench.

Advertise with us

Ms. Kane has been a thorn in the side to Republican Gov. Tom Corbett and garnered national headlines last week by declaring she would not defend the state ban on gay marriage.

In documents submitted to the high court, Ms. Kane argued that Judge Feudale should be removed because of behavior that included demeaning her and her predecessor, Linda Kelly, in an email to a prosecutor who had left Ms. Kane's staff.

'A cheap shot'

The email went to Frank G. Fina, a onetime top prosecutor in that office who built many of its most explosive cases. The judge emailed: "The Last General aka 'Private' Kelly, could not lead and was indecisive to the point that she was almost ineffective."

Asked about the remark, Judge Feudale said recently: "It was a cheap shot. I shouldn't have said that."

Advertise with us

In the email, the judge also disparaged a review Ms. Kane has launched into how the office pursued Penn State child molester Jerry Sandusky. Judge Feudale wrote that the review was "PATENT in its POLITICAL intent," but that Mr. Fina, who led the Sandusky investigation, should cooperate with it.

In May, the Supreme Court ruled in Ms. Kane's favor. The court's order did not bar him from serving as a judge, but removed him from the grand jury position. The order was sealed and has not been made public.

In an interview, Judge Feudale said he would not talk about any grand jury investigations. He acknowledged that his email ripping Ms. Kelly was a mistake, but said he stood by the criticism of Ms. Kane's Sandusky-related probe.

Judge Feudale shared a copy of the email with reporters. He also said the knife incident had been distorted. The knife was a Gurkha dagger that the judge said he had picked up in Nepal years ago and kept in his office as a conversation-starter.

"They made it seem like I had this knife and I was running around with it, crazy.

Advertise with us

"I did not brandish it," Judge Feudale said.

A Democrat, Judge Feudale was a Northumberland County judge from 1987 until 1997. He then worked as a "floating" senior judge, assigned by the Supreme Court to hear cases in 63 of the state's 67 counties.

Over the last 12 years, chief justices have appointed him to preside over a series of investigating grand juries.

A collision course?

Though it is rare for an attorney general to seek the ouster of a grand jury judge, a collision between Ms. Kane and Judge Feudale seemed almost inevitable. Ms. Kane campaigned on the promise that she would review how her predecessors had handled the Sandusky probe. She questioned why it took as long as it did, raising the specter that then-Attorney General Corbett might have dragged his feet in the case at a time when he was running for governor.

Advertise with us

As a career prosecutor, Mr. Fina led that probe and a string of others that helped make Mr. Corbett's reputation -- notably, the Bonusgate and Computergate investigations of Democrats and Republicans in the Legislature.

Ms. Kane's election meant a Democrat was taking over an office run in recent years by Republicans. Mr. Fina left, as did most of the office's corruption team. Ms. Kane named onetime Philadelphia federal prosecutor H. Geoffrey Moulton Jr. to head the internal review. Judge Feudale said he met with Mr. Moulton soon thereafter -- and, as part of the review, gave him a copy of the email sent to Mr. Fina. That is when Judge Feudale's problems began to intensify.

He was already clashing with Ms. Kane by then, questioning her charging decisions and even her hiring choices, as well as her handling of the case against Penn State administrators charged with covering up Sandusky's abuse.

In a May opinion -- one of his last before he was removed -- he chided Ms. Kane's office in the Penn State case, saying it needed to accelerate.

Mr. Fina, who now works for the Philadelphia District Attorney's Office in Philadelphia, declined to comment for this article.

Advertise with us

As Judge Feudale explains the knife incident, he was leaving his chambers one Friday afternoon this spring and decided to take the knife home. On the way to his car, he stopped at Ms. Kane's office to inquire about a new filing in the Penn State cases.

While there, he said, he did something he probably shouldn't have. He showed a secretary the knife, and began teasing her: If the Attorney General's Office was so worried about security, then "how did I get this in?" He said he can't recall whether he removed the knife from its sheath -- as Ms. Kane's office asserted.