HARRISBURG -- Legislation to allow private sales of wine and liquor advanced through a Senate committee Monday without signs that Republicans are closer to a proposal that could clear the full chamber.

The Senate Law & Justice Committee gutted the privatization bill that passed the House in March, replacing its provisions with a package that the committee chairman, Sen. Chuck McIlhinney, R-Bucks, unveiled last week.

Instead of disbanding the state's wholesale purchasing operation, the amended bill would require studies to assess the wholesale value of the system. Where the House bill would use a formula to shutter the state wine and spirits stores, the Senate amendment would allow the Pennsylvania Liquor Control Board to decide when outlets would close.

But two of the senators whose support allowed the bill its narrow 6-5 passage said they reserved the right to vote against the final product, and a spokesman for Senate Majority Leader Dominic Pileggi, R-Delaware, said Republicans were still short of the 26 votes they expect to need -- from 27 Republican members -- to pass a privatization bill.

Advertise with us

Senate Democratic leaders have said their members are united against any proposal that would close the state liquor stores.

In addition to the four Democrats on the committee, Sen. Don White, R-Indiana, opposed the bill, saying it would reduce access to alcohol for people in his rural district. Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, voiced that concern about his own district. He said he would vote for the bill to let it advance but would not support sending it to the governor's desk without protections for rural areas.

"Rural areas, through almost any plan with complete closure of state stores, we get hurt," Mr. Scarnati said. "We get hurt on access, we get hurt on price and we get hurt on selection.

"I'm going to vote to move the process. But clearly, as this process moves on, sending a bill to the governor that doesn't meet the parameters of protecting rural areas throughout this, I can't support and I won't support."

Sen. John Rafferty, R-Montgomery, said he would like to offer further amendments but would vote for Mr. McIlhinney's plan so the bill could move forward.

Advertise with us

Erik Arneson, a spokesman for Mr. Pileggi, said further amendments are expected, with consideration by the full Senate no sooner than Thursday.

Liquor privatization is a priority of House Republicans as well as one of three policy initiatives that Gov. Tom Corbett asked lawmakers to send him by the state budget deadline Sunday.

Another of those proposals, a Senate measure to raise new annual funding for transportation infrastructure, is poised for significant amendment by a House committee.

If consensus emerges on private liquor sales, Mr. McIlhinney said after the meeting, more than enough time remains to send it to Mr. Corbett. If not, he said, work could continue on the issue.

"There is nothing tied to the budget itself here," he said. "This could easily be something that we could do in the fall."