A state appeals court heard a Presbyterian church property dispute from Washington County on Wednesday that could impact other Pennsylvania churches that have split.

In 2007, members of the Peters Creek United Presbyterian Church voted 207-26 to leave the Presbyterian Church (USA) for the more conservative Evangelical Presbyterian Church. The congregation had earlier dropped out of a Washington Presbytery process to decide whether and how the property could be taken into a different denomination.

Washington Presbytery later declared that a minority loyal to the Presbyterian Church (USA) was the "true church," with a right to the property. In 2009, however, Washington Common Pleas Judge Paul Pozonsky ruled that the majority owned the property because the deed, charter and other legal papers had no trust clause giving ownership to the denomination.

In church property disputes, Pennsylvania courts use "neutral principles," meaning that ownership is determined by civil documents rather than by theological tradition.

Advertise with us

Because such documents vary, different cases turn out differently. But since several denominations have rules saying that property is held in trust for that denomination, there is wide interest in what the Commonwealth Court may say about the Presbyterian trust clause.

A three-judge panel heard the case last year, but asked for this rehearing before all seven judges. Much of the questioning revolved around the constitution of the Presbyterian Church (USA), called the Book of Order, which includes a trust clause.

"The first issue we have to address is whether the Book of Order is binding on Peters Creek United Presbyterian Church," said attorney Stephen Marriner, representing Washington Presbytery and the minority.

"The Book of Order says that any time a church is separated from the denomination, it can only be done by a decision of the presbytery," he said, noting that Peters Creek didn't follow that process.

Judge Kevin Brobson honed in on whether the property belonged to the majority or the minority, saying that if the minority owns it "then there is no trust issue."

Advertise with us

But Judge Patricia McCullough cited the guiding case of St. James the Less in Philadelphia, which voted to leave the Episcopal Church. The state Supreme Court ruled for the denomination because the parish charter said the property was held in trust for the Episcopal Church. That case said "there must be clear and unambiguous language," which the Peters Creek documents lack, she said.

Andrea Geraghty, attorney for the majority who joined the Evangelical Presbyterian Church, argues that the Book of Order's trust clause was invalid. The congregation was founded in the 18th century and incorporated in 1931 as part of the former United Presbyterian Church. It never amended its charter through mergers that produced the Presbyterian Church USA in 1983, she said. Although its 2001 bylaws include a pledge to abide by the Book of Order, she said that was conditional upon the congregation choosing to remain in the Presbyterian Church (USA).

Under Pennsylvania law, she argued, the beneficiary can't unilaterally create a trust. It must be created in writing by the owner of the property, "and that didn't happen," she said.

"There isn't a document in the record indicating that anyone in the Presbyterian Church (USA) has a right to the property."

Judge Brobson suggested that the congregation agreed to the trust when it accepted the Book of Order.

Advertise with us

"This didn't come out of thin air," he said. "You adopted the Book of Order knowing there was a trust clause."

Ms. Geraghty responded that the congregation didn't know that. "I believe there was no intent to adopt the trust clause," she said.

The court is expected to rule later this year.