SAO PAULO, Brazil -- For some members of the Pennsylvania trade mission, a chance to spend time in South America with Gov. Tom Corbett has drawn a degree of scrutiny at home.
The state Democratic Party has questioned the selection of participating businesspeople, noting that some have donated to Mr. Corbett's campaigns and suggesting that political influence helped book their tickets to Chile and Brazil.
But organizers of the mission said the application process followed the same path taken for the many lower-profile business development trips Pennsylvania runs each year. When the Department of Community and Economic Development plans a trip, it charges regional export networks throughout the state with spreading word to potential participants, said Wilfred Muskens, deputy secretary for international business development.
The mission with Mr. Corbett received additional publicity through Team Pennsylvania Foundation, the nonprofit economic development organization that has worked with DCED to coordinate the mission and which is paying for the trips of state officials.
Applicants are vetted for readiness to enter the export market and for compliance with state taxes. After that, those who applied by the winter deadline were in, said Mr. Muskens and Matt Zieger, president and CEO of Team PA.
PG graphic: South America
(Click image for larger version)
"It's the exact same process we do for every company," said Mr. Muskens, who was appointed by former Gov. Ed Rendell, a Democrat. "There's no political motivation whatsoever. It's just which businesses need assistance in this market."
The governor's office was not involved in the vetting process, Mr. Zieger said.
Companies pay their own way, and also a fee -- $3,000 for small companies and $5,000 for larger ones -- to pay costs of the mission. (A small fee is assessed for routine trade missions, without the luncheons and receptions featuring the governor.)
The Pennsylvania Democratic Party has pointed to several instances in which delegation members have also donated to Mr. Corbett.
"The companies on this trip have access that most people don't and it also happens to be the case that several participants are donors," Marc Eisenstein, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania Democratic Party, said in an email. "Like in the past, there's clearly a lot of interplay between Gov. Corbett and his donors. It, at the very least, creates an even greater appearance of impropriety at a time when Pennsylvanians are rightfully distrustful of Gov. Corbett."
One trip participant, John Moran Jr, is a personal friend of Mr. Corbett and a significant donor to his campaigns. Mr. Moran is also co-chairman, along with Mr. Corbett, of Team Pennsylvania Foundation, a volunteer position to which he was nominated by the group's board.
In an interview Tuesday at the delegation's hotel, Mr. Moran estimated that since meeting Mr. Corbett, before the then-attorney general announced a bid for governor, he has made in the range of the $200,000 in cash and in-kind donations.
Mr. Moran, president of a Central Pennsylvania logistics company, said he and Mr. Corbett, as well as their wives, have become close -- a yacht excursion the couple shared generated news stories -- and that he shares Mr. Corbett's view of how to build prosperity in the state.
But Mr. Moran said he has paid his own way on this trade mission as well as the governor's trip last year to France and Germany, when Mr. Moran said he also made a donation to assist participants.
"I don't do any business with the state. I don't intend to do any business with the state," he said. "I never intend ever, ever to ask the governor for anything. That's not the way I am. All I really want out of the governor is his friendship and to have him with his continued vision to rebuild Pennsylvania and provide family-sustaining jobs."
Another mission participant, Leo Holt, president of Holt Logistics Corp. at the Port of Philadelphia, said he donated both to Mr. Corbett and his Democratic opponent, Dan Onorato. But he said his support for the governor draws in large part from Mr. Corbett's advocacy for the dredging of the Delaware River to allow larger ships to use the port.
"We supported Rendell, and we support Gov. Corbett," he said. "We're interested in promoting leaders who support our neighborhood, which in our case happens to be the Port of Philadelphia."
In an interview Tuesday, between meetings with executives of the Brazilian petrochemical company Braskem, which is investing in the Marcus Hook area, Mr. Corbett said he had never seen most of the delegation members before the trip.
"It was a general solicitation," he said. "You've got the money and you get your application in on time, you're coming with us. I don't even know what their political persuasion is, other than being business people."
Another participant, Samantha Urban, said she learned of the mission from the honorary consul of Brazil in Philadelphia, with whom she had discussed her business. After a series of menu miscommunications on a trip to Rio de Janeiro, Ms. Urban came up with the idea for digital menu-ordering software, based on a tablet, to translate between guest and host.
She is now back in Brazil, pitching the product of Urban Translations to hotels and restaurants.
Ms. Urban, who said she has never contributed to the governor, said she applied for the mission on a Thursday in January and was accepted the following Monday.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.