HARRISBURG -- A hearing on pre-trial motions for two top Penn State administators ended this morning with no action being taken by the court and one of the major topics for debate not even addressed.
The hearing for former Penn State athletic director Tim Curley and former vice president for business and finance Gary Schultz was slated for oral arguments on motions to dismiss counts of perjury and failure to report suspected child abuse.
The parties discussed the perjury count, but did not address the failure to report because the prosecution filed a new motion Wednesday regarding a dispute over the issue of the statute of limitations in the cases.
On the perjury count, the defense argued that the alleged false statements from their clients are based on opinions and characterizations the men made at the grand jury.
For example, Mr. Curley told the grand jury he believed that conduct by Jerry Sandusky in Penn State football locker room showers with a yong boy in 2001 was "inappropriate."
However, when asked by prosecutors if he considered it to either be a crime or sexual, Mr. Curley answered no, said defense attorney Caroline Roberto.
"That's a conclusion or opinion," she said. "Are we talking about facts or are we talking about opinions or characterizations?"
But Deputy Attorney General Bruce Beemer said the defense arguments don't belong in a pre-trial hearing.
"What Ms. Roberto just said underscored what trials are for," he said. "We have reason to believe he lied."
Dauphin County Judge Todd Hoover, too, questioned whether the issue should be decided now.
Tom Farrell, who represents Mr. Schultz, insisted it should.
"The fear is we'll end up -- and what wiill happen at the civil trials -- this will be a trial about whether Mr. Curley and Mr. Schultz exercised proper judgment, and the jury will think 'we don't like how they responded, and we'll convict them.' And that's not what a perjury case is about."
On Wednesday, the prosecution filed a motion arguing that the charge of failing to report meets the statute of limitations -- which they originally claimed was 10 years -- because it was a continuing pattern of conduct and that each day the crime wasn't reported was part of the offense.
The attorney general's office initially claimed that the incident in the shower occurred in February 2002, however, in May, it amended the information to show the crime actually happened in February 2001.
Ms. Roberto said after the hearing that the count should be dismissed.
"Under these circumstances, I think the commonwealth has to bear the consequences of their choices," she said.
The defense has 10 days to file a brief on that issue.
Defense attorneys for Mr. Curley and Mr. Schultz argued that the counts should be dismissed based not only on a lack of corroboration, but also because they believe there was no false statement, but rather an opinion given by their clients.
The state attorney general's office argued that the question is one for a jury to decide.
Dauphin County Judge Todd A. Hoover will issue his decision at a later date.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.