HARRISBURG -- Twenty-two states require their counties to reassess property values every year, so the property taxes that homeowners pay are as accurate and fair as possible.

Another 26 states require reassessments done at regular intervals, ranging from every other year to every nine years.

And in California, assessment increases are restricted to a maximum of two percent a year for as long as a person owns his home.

But only one state allows counties to use a base year for assessments indefinitely, without regular updating:

Advertise with us

Pennsylvania.

Whose job would it be to enact a state law mandating regular property reassessments?

In its ruling this week that Allegheny County should reassess its properties, the Supreme Court said it is not the court's job "to determine what may be the best system of assessment. ... The General Assembly is the appropriate place" to do it.

But, added Supreme Court Justice Max Baer, the prospect for prompt legislative action on reassessments is "unlikely."

He's right.

Advertise with us

"There certainly hasn't been a desire to order annual reassessments in the past," said Sen. David Argall, R-Schuylkill.

The state House's focus is on "improving the economy, increasing access to affordable health care, investing in education and alternative energy and finding innovative ways to plug a multi-billion-dollar deficit," said Brett Marcy, spokesman for House Democratic Leader Todd Eachus of Luzerne.

While property taxes are an important topic, he said, "these [other] issues are at the forefront for us."

If the Legislature were to tell counties to do regular reassessments, there would be a hefty pricetag. A full reassessment in Allegheny County alone could cost up to $40 million, Controller Mark Patrick Flaherty said this week. Douglas Hill, director of the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania, said the 67 counties would need financial aid from the state to do regular reassessments.

And with the state facing a $3 billion budget shortfall by June 30, now isn't the time to be asking for additional funds for any reason.

Advertise with us

Franklin & Marshall College political science professor G. Terry Madonna said periodic property reassessments should be required by law because changes in value always occur over time.

"It's appalling that regular reassessments aren't required in Pennsylvania," he said. "Since the 1970s, there have been repeated efforts to get the Legislature to modernize Pennsylvania's assessment law, but all of them have failed."

Mr. Madonna said there's "a big fear factor" among politicians when it comes to requiring reassessments, because citizens get angry about higher property taxes.

Mr. Argall is taking a small step. By June 30, he wants to have a bill passed setting up a nonbinding statewide referendum in November to get public opinion on three options for reducing property taxes. But he hasn't specified the three options yet.

"One approach that has considerable support is the complete elimination of at least school district property taxes," he said. That is the largest chunk of property taxes, with smaller amounts going to municipalities and counties.

Advertise with us

But eliminating just school property taxes isn't going far enough, contended retired KDKA radio talk show host Bob Logue, who heads a Western Pennsylvania group called Stop Taxing Our Properties.

He maintains there's no fair or accurate way to reassess residential properties and wants to completely eliminate all property taxes -- school, municipal and county -- on people's principal residences (the house they live in).

"We need to get rid of all three property taxes," he said. "Otherwise, you still have this reassessment mess, very costly and very inaccurate."

Doing so would cause the loss of a lot of revenue, estimated at between $7 billion and $10 billion statewide. Mr. Logue would raise replacement revenue by increasing the 6 percent state sales tax (to, perhaps, 7.7 percent) and the 3.07 percent personal income tax (to, perhaps, 4.07 percent). The $1 billion or so that will come annually through a 34 percent tax on slots revenue would also help make up for the elimination of property taxes, he said.

The tax debate aside, there's little doubt that Pennsylvania's base year system is about as antiquated as, oh, its state-run liquor store network.

Advertise with us

Guy Griscom, immediate past president of the International Association of Assessing Officers, said that outside of the northeast, most states require reassessments at regular intervals, usually annually to every three years.

States that rely heavily on property taxes want frequent reappraisals to keep values current and to fairly distribute the tax burden, he said. The problem with unchecked base year systems, Mr. Griscom said, is that they create uniformity problems.

"That's why you find schemes like that ruled invalid because they don't keep up with the market trend of what's happening in the marketplace," he said.

While county Executive Dan Onorato has accused some municipalities and school districts in the past of using reassessments for "back-door" tax increases, Mr. Griscom described such claims as a "political cop-out."

"In a true system working the way it should, valuation should be totally separate from taxing," he said. "If they aren't working in unison, you get those kind of problems."

Advertise with us

Most states that have reappraisals at regular intervals also have "truth in taxation" statutes to prevent municipalities from reaping tax windfalls when property values change.

For instance, in Harris County, Texas, where Mr. Griscom is assistant chief appraiser, and other parts of the state, tax rates can't go up more than 3 percent after a reassessment without a public hearing. If taxes go up more than 8 percent, voters have the power to force a referendum to roll back the rate.

"Truth in taxation" laws are "the only way you can safeguard against jurisdictions automatically taking advantage of increased values," he said.

On the reappraisal side of the equation, meanwhile, Texas school districts can lose state funding if values fall too far out of line.

"That's a considerable hammer," Mr. Griscom said.

Advertise with us

States that demand regular reassessments and establish the guidelines typically will share the cost for the valuation work. It's states where there's no or very little oversight, like Pennsylvania, that run into problems, Mr. Griscom said.

"When [regular reassessments] are left up to individual counties, some do, most don't," he said. "Over time, they get into trouble, usually with court intervention. Then they scramble around to find out what to do about it."