Families of people incarcerated at the Allegheny County Jail are no closer to being notified if their loved one is hospitalized after the jail’s oversight board rejected a proposal that would have required officials to draft a new notification policy.

The board voted Thursday not to advance the motion, which had already been pushed back a month during March’s meeting to allow the jail administration more time to review it. 

Common Pleas President Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente, Sheriff Kevin Kraus, Acting Controller Amy Weise Clements and citizen member Barbara Griffin all voted in opposition.

County Councilwoman and board member Bethany Hallam and board member Muhammad Ali Nasir, known as MAN-E, voted in favor of the motion. Citizen member Rob Perkins, who helped to draft it and voted virtually, also voted in favor, Ms. Hallam said after the meeting.

Advertise with us

The proposal called for “timely and expanded notifications” to families and specified people when someone in custody is hospitalized, according to the meeting agenda.

If passed, the draft would need to be presented during the board’s June meeting, when members would vote on its adoption.

“This is one of those things where we need to show that we can work together,” Ms. Hallam said before the vote. “We can craft a policy that works for all parties involved, and we can ensure that the first Thursday of June is the last time anyone will have to worry about where their loved one is when they’re in our care.”

But what Ms. Hallam described as a “noncontroversial” proposal before voting quickly exposed deeper divisions among board members.

Judge Evashavik DiLucente and Sheriff Kraus raised concerns about whether notifying families could create security risks at hospitals, where incarcerated people are transferred from the jail’s custody to the sheriff’s department if they are admitted.  

Advertise with us

Under the current policy, one deputy stays with an incarcerated person who has been admitted to a hospital. If more people are notified of the hospitalization, Sheriff Kraus said he would want an additional deputy present, which would further strain the county’s resources. 

“In a perfect world, it would be great to pass this policy,” Judge Evashavik DiLucente said. “But we don’t live in a perfect world. We’re broke. Allegheny County is broke.”

Judge Evashavik DiLucente and Sheriff Kraus left the meeting shortly after casting their votes. 

A yearslong debate

The issue of when the jail issues a notification regarding the hospitalization of an incarcerated person — and how and to whom — has triggered contentious discussions for years.

In 2018, under Warden Orlando Harper’s administration, the jail changed the notification policy to have jail medical personnel, rather than a jail chaplain, notify family members about an inmate’s hospitalization.

Advertise with us

The goal, officials said, was to provide timely updates on someone’s health status but avoid using terminology that could give away a diagnosis, specific medical condition or treatment.

Since then, Ms. Hallam and community members have pushed the jail administration to follow through on that goal.

“Families always have a right to know when a loved one has been hospitalized,” said Alan Guenther, a member of the Quaker Working Group Against Racism, at a 2023 meeting. “This is common decency. Please stop stalling and act.”

The current policy “does provide for notification to the emergency contact in the event of serious illness or serious injury,” according to  Judge Evashavik DiLucente.

But Ms. Hallam contends that isn’t always happening, “as is evidenced by the dozens and dozens of people who have come here over the years and gave comments about their loved ones going to hospital,” she said after Thursday’s meeting.

Advertise with us

She also said board members, including herself, frequently get calls from people inquiring about their loved ones.

A revised policy would require Jail Oversight Board members and attorneys or other representing parties to also be notified, in addition to an incarcerated person’s emergency contact. Warden Trevor Wingard has said the jail has been working on drafting a new policy.

Some board members struggled to see the benefits of the motion that was struck down Thursday, even after a few community members, during the public comment period of the meeting, passionately described the need for improved communication.

“To me, medical information is on a need-to-know basis. I don't need to know. I don't want to get notifications,” Ms. Weise Clements said. “I’m concerned about the sheer volume of all this notification, and the more people that know, the higher the risk to us.”

Some speakers described the emotional turmoil families experience when they haven’t heard from their loved one, especially as jailhouse rumors spread and make their way back to them.

Advertise with us

Tanisha Long shared the story of her mother, who was incarcerated and placed in solitary confinement in the Washington County Jail for three months. During that time, she was transported to a hospital at least seven times, Ms. Long said.

“Her condition deteriorated, and no one knew. They didn't notify us. We were never called,” she said. “Had we been able to intervene sooner, she wouldn't be in a permanent care facility. These are things that are preventable.”

She continued, “For as long as I've been coming to this Jail Oversight Board, we've been talking about how [families] deserve to know, and that's been going on at least four or five years … the board has had time to act.”

What the future holds

Several community members expressed outrage on the outcome of Thursday’s vote, including Sharon Bonavoglia, a member of the Pennsylvania Interfaith Impact Network who regularly uses the public comment period to read a list of people who have died in the jail’s custody. 

Advertise with us

“I'm really angry. This is shameful,” she said. “I am very disappointed that two of the newest members of this board chose to vote ‘no’ on the motion tonight. I am incensed that people left, that people aren't here. … You have a job to do, and your job is oversight.” 

Malikeya Khantrece, a criminal defense attorney, said she was going to bring up other issues, but was also “incensed” by the outcome.

“Instead of thinking with empathy, or feeling with empathy, that family members don’t know that their loved one is sick enough to be hospitalized, [you’re] looking past that to talk about the safety of a sheriff,” she said. “As though your emergency contact, when they find out you’re sick and in the hospital, is going to come and attack the sheriff, is wild.”

Ms. Hallam told the Post-Gazette that “there has been no evidence whatsoever that families who do find out about their loved ones in the jail create a safety or security risk.”

What happens now is what, she said, has already been happening for years: The loved ones of incarcerated people might wonder about their well-being and where they are; attorneys could show up for a visit and won’t be able to access their client; and the Jail Oversight Board might struggle to find out the status of an incarcerated person.

Advertise with us

"The Jail Oversight Board is just going to keep being blindsided ... by everyone who seems to not have the people in the jail as their first and foremost priority,” she said.

“Families, still to this day, are having their loved ones die or be seriously incapacitated, and they never even knew about it,” Ms. Hallam said.

Ms. Griffin, one of the citizen members of the board who voted against the motion, said she understood the concern Ms. Hallam and others expressed about better notification systems. But she said the “main drivers of those notifications has to be the incarcerated person."

“Sometimes people love them, but they don't love that person,” she said during the meeting. “They don't want so-and-so to know anything about their injury or what's going on in their medical condition.

“I just feel like there's a lot more work to be done on it, and I'm hoping that we at least share the concern about notifying families.”