As leaders of the Allegheny County Jail highlighted a year of reforms and new programs during a presentation to the jail’s oversight board last week, a new report from the Pennsylvania Prison Society captured complaints from people confined in the facility. 

The Philadelphia-based prison monitoring group visited the jail in November, touring several housing units and interviewing incarcerated people about daily conditions, access to services and their interactions with staff. 

The report, shared with jail staff in late January and released publicly last week, described the ACJ’s conditions as appearing to be improving. But complaints about the amount of food received, long wait times for medical care and tense relationships with staff remain common among those interviewed. 

“While the survey findings should not be read as a completely accurate depiction of what is happening … they nevertheless indicate there are issues,” the report stated. “As the saying goes, ‘where there is smoke, there is fire.’ Our interviews with incarcerated people indicate there is smoke, but are insufficient to determine the precise scope and heat of the fire.”

Advertise with us

Complaints from incarcerated people

The Prison Society’s published surveys offer one of the few opportunities for people incarcerated at the jail to have their concerns reflected in public discussions about conditions at the facility. 

The group typically schedules the visits twice a year, in May and November.

During their latest visit, representatives from the organization interviewed 72 incarcerated men. All interviews were voluntary and anonymous, and the men were randomly selected, according to the report. 

A note of caution in interpreting the findings was also included: “Any survey conducted in a corrections setting should be viewed with the understanding that people in custody are likely unhappy with their circumstances and that this may lead them to enlarge complaints.”

Interviewees reported improvement in out-of-cell time — 78% said they are let out of their cell every day, compared to 25% of the 70 people interviewed in May. 

Advertise with us

“Insufficient” food, delays in access to health care and “unprofessional” staff were all marked as recurring issues. Some also raised concerns about difficulty gaining access to their jail-provided tablets and being given tablets with low battery life.

More than 80% of interviewees told the Prison Society the jail does not provide them with enough food. 

“The portions are for kids, not grown men,” one man said, according to the report. 

Numerous incarcerated people said the only way to get enough food is to have money for commissary, and many expressed concerns of receiving food that was “rotten,” “cold” or inappropriate for their approved diets. 

Of the 56 people who reported attempting to access health care, more than half said they had a wait time of more than a week. Some reported wait times of more than a month.

Advertise with us

“People we spoke to report a lack of treatment for suspected MRSA [a type of staph infection], not receiving test results, lack of counseling services for mental health diagnoses, not getting pain management for broken bones, and no access to dental or vision services among other medical concerns,” the report added. 

More than 60% of those interviewed said staff members were unprofessional or disrespectful, an 8% decline from what Prison Society representatives were told during their May interviews. 

Successes and challenges

During Thursday’s monthly meeting of the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board, jail administrators presented their annual report outlining operational changes and new initiatives.

While the Prison Society’s report wasn’t brought up during the meeting, jail Warden Trevor Wingard acknowledged that the past year had brought challenges and “missteps.”  

“There's been issues in the last 13 to 14 months. And I think that every time that’s happened, we've told you when, and we were as transparent as we can be on those things,” Mr. Wingard said. “We’ll continue to do that. That’s our pledge to you, to continue to inform you of what's going on. Our successes and our missteps.”

Advertise with us

Among the positive changes highlighted during the presentation was the introduction of unit managers — new roles that allow for more localized leadership within housing units and greater flexibility in day-to-day management. 

The jail currently has seven managers who are referred to as “mini wardens” in the jail’s 2025 Annual Warden Report. 

Unit managers seemed to be “well-liked” and “respected” by the majority of those interviewed, according to the Prison Society report.

Jail officials said they’ve noticed positive outcomes from unit management, including enhanced communication among staff members and with those incarcerated.

“The incarcerated population has someone to turn to for any problems in the unit, and management will ensure that the issue is resolved where possible,” Lee Estock, the jail’s chief deputy warden, said during Thursday’s meeting. “The unit manager has an invested interest in the success of their level.”

Advertise with us

Health care administrators also outlined several developments over the past year, particularly in the expansion of mental health services. 

Among them was the launch of a diversionary treatment unit, where patients with serious mental health concerns can receive specialized care rather than be placed in restrictive housing. The units are managed by a team of mental health professionals, including a psychologist, a behavioral health consultant, a registered nurse and mental health specialists, jail administrators said. 

Officials described expanding programming and partnerships with community organizations aimed at supporting people when they leave the jail, including job training initiatives and therapy programs. An increased attention to promoting staff wellness was also mentioned.

Conflicting feelings

As members of the oversight board reflected on changes over the past year, some said the discussion left them with a complicated perspective. 

“It's kind of a conflicting feeling for me when you want to celebrate the services, the programs and all those kinds of things that are provided to incarcerated people, but we really don't want them there to begin with,” said Barbara Griffin, a citizen member of the board.

Advertise with us

Board member and County Councilwoman-at-large Bethany Hallam acknowledged the administration’s efforts to improve access for incarcerated people to charge their tablets.

“I know that was something talked about for a really long time, and I just want to say how much of a game-changer that's been,” she said. “Families have reported to me increased communication with their loved ones. Incarcerated people have said how nice it is to not have their tablet die in the middle of the day.”

But while praises were sung, tension also filled the room at one point during Thursday’s meeting when a motion to vote on a long-discussed issue was delayed. 

For several months, Ms. Hallam and several community members have emphasized the need for enhanced communication between family members and the jail when incarcerated people are hospitalized.

The board was set to vote Thursday on requiring the jail to develop a clear policy on medical notifications by June, but that was pushed back to next month’s meeting after the chair of the board, Allegheny County President Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente, proposed a new motion.

Advertise with us

“The reason is basically professional courtesy,” she said. “The jail administration was just given a copy of this motion. They would like some time to digest it, to review it and to meet with their stakeholders.”

The deadline for establishing the policy will still be set for June.

Board members Ms. Hallam and Muhammad Ali Nasir, who goes by MAN-E, said the lack of consistent notification can leave families searching for information about their loved ones and relying on rumors.

“The misinformation and the lack of communication is what causes the chaos,” Ms. Hallam said. “And I think delaying this even a little bit longer is just another excuse for, I don’t even know what reason.”