Mandy Messenger has lived beneath the 16th Street Bridge for almost 10 months. It’s colder now – the kind of temperatures that breed problems like frostbite. To keep warm, she shares her tent with two other people.

Ms. Messenger has been sitting on a housing voucher since the summer, but says she can’t find a landlord who will accept it. In the meantime, she finds ways to get by, though it’s not easy.

“People throw bottles at me, pennies, ask me to sleep with them for money,” she said. “Like I could be out there robbing people, whatever. No, I just stand up there [panhandling]. We can't even do that without getting harassed.”

On Nov. 21, posted notices informed Ms. Messenger and others that they must vacate their North Shore encampment along the Three Rivers Heritage Trail by Sunday. There are more than a dozen tents nearby, and 15 people have already moved to a shelter, officials said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Messenger doesn’t know where she’ll end up. Without a secure place to live in the long term, she plans to pack up her tent and relocate.

There are several factors to consider, like whether the location is visible enough to attract attention and be more susceptible to another forced move. Some areas are more prone to flooding, like the Mon Wharf, where an encampment was destroyed earlier this year.

Despite the frustrations, “There’s nothing we can do,” she said.

The city’s Public Safety Department cited issues similar to those noted at other encampments cleared in the past year, including suspected illegal activity and unsanitary conditions. The department terms the clear outs “decommissions.”

The notice for the Dec. 15 clear out, however, provided more specific details, including interference with city maintenance efforts, trespassing, flooding risks and fire hazards threatening nearby structures.

Advertise with us

A few days before the notices arrived, a woman who identified herself as Melissa said outreach teams were warning that a clearing was imminent. She questioned the timing, especially with temperatures consistently dropping below freezing.

Finding somewhere else to live has been a struggle. Some county homeless programs require people to experience chronic homelessness for at least a year — a threshold she won’t reach until February.

“I think it’s sad we can’t get more assistance,” she said. “It's cold out here, and there's a lot of us. It’s a bad time to be doing this. Real bad.”

Typically, encampment residents get five days notice before decommissions. This time, they had about a month to prepare and find alternative options. But officials at Light of Life, the closest provider to the encampment, said it hasn’t been part of the conversation with the county’s Department of Human Services or city officials.

Annie Cairns, Light of Life’s senior marketing and communications manager, said she believes she knows why. The 20 overflow beds opened for the winter season fill up nightly, as do regular shelter spaces – especially the men’s shelter

Advertise with us

“We already denied adding additional overflow space,” she said. “They know we’re full.”

Still, Light of Life regularly offers resources to people living at the encampment. Identifiable by their characteristic red backpacks, street outreach workers such as Lloyd Massie check in to try to ease the transition. He said he always tries to get them to come back to the shelter, even just for a few hours.

“We chat with them like, hey, we're willing to help you with case management, help you with a goal,” he said.

But the trust can take months, even years, to build, said Ms. Cairns,

“They've been burned before, even other agencies, so they're so reluctant to trust in general,” she said. “Lloyd will talk to the same person for a year, and, finally, they'll come into the mission.”

Advertise with us

Often seeing people bounce from one encampment to another, Mr. Massie said these decommissions don’t necessarily resolve the issues. Without more permanent housing and other supports, the clearings are only a temporary fix, he said.

“Whether there's illegal activity going on here or it's a public safety hazard, whatever it is” Mr. Massie said. “You've got to come up with better solutions that are going to work out in the long run for their safety, the public’s safety.”