With just a couple of weeks before shelters ramp up to full capacity for the colder weather, not all of them are aligned on the county's plans this winter.
Some providers say they still need clarification on aspects of Allegheny County’s shelter strategy, particularly the promise of 24/7 care.
On Oct. 21, the Department of Human Services unveiled its plan to temporarily expand shelter bed capacity and service hours from Nov. 15 to March 15. The agency announced that, “new” this winter, providers will be “open 24/7, ensuring residents have access to warmth and safety around the clock.”
The framing came as a surprise to some. Three shelters told the Post-Gazette that they only plan to operate overflow beds from 7 p.m. to 7 a.m. and are seeking clarification from DHS on what 24/7 shelter care actually entails.
DHS told the Post-Gazette that Director Erin Dalton was referring to the services offered by its regular year-round shelters, along with additional daytime capacity that will be available at Second Avenue Commons.
Sherry Rorison, director of the Salvation Army of Western Pennsylvania, hadn’t even realized the county was abandoning its temperature-dependent “Code Blue” protocols from last year. The county used to issue Code Blue alerts in the event of temperatures forecast to dip below 26 degrees, instead opting to keep shelters open overnight.
Read More
She said her last conversation with DHS focused on overflow beds, and she agreed to provide 20.
“Nothing was communicated to me beyond, ‘Yes, please do the overflow shelter, here’s the budget, and yes, it’s approved,’” Ms. Rorison said.
Ms. Rorison said she does appreciate the earlier rollout of the plans, as protocols weren’t finalized until December last year.
"It’s a lot better," she said. "I wasn't under the gun. But I don't know how well they communicated their plan out.”
In 2023, the county’s initial winter plan relied on opening emergency facilities only if existing shelters encountered issues like heating failures. Advocates worried these ad hoc protocols didn’t go far enough — Allegheny County had already seen a 20% increase in emergency shelter use before any guidelines were in place.
At a December press conference, Light of Life Rescue Mission and other shelters cautioned that they were already overextended. The county acknowledged that its final plans came after a cold spell, which dropped into the 20s.
“We’re very glad the system is now in place,” DHS Deputy Director Abigail Horn said at the time.
With this year’s announcement coming two months earlier, DHS said new shelter and added bed capacity eliminates the need for a temperature-triggered response like Code Blue.
Instead, Second Avenue Commons will operate daily from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m.; previously it was only open during weekdays. DHS said it’s also adding 105 new shelter beds. And the Northside Partnership Project will open a nightly shelter, expanding the county’s network to over 600 beds across 12 facilities.
“That will allow us to have a winter shelter open every night this winter, regardless of temperature,” according to a statement from DHS.
In response to concerns about communication gaps, the agency said it holds monthly meetings with homeless service providers to “regularly” gather input.
However, Nicole Harrington, vice president for community programs at the East End Cooperative Ministry, said she only learned of the new shelter space and around-the-clock care commitment through a press release.
“I think once DHS concludes how they want to go about it, that’s when they start reaching out to us,” she said.
In 2023, when DHS closed the Smithfield Street overnight shelter, it turned to Ms. Harrington to run an overflow shelter for a nine-month period — well beyond the usual winter operations. Maintaining adequate staffing and managing capacity was a challenge, and the Code Blue protocol added more complications. There were times when Ms. Harrington had to scramble to keep the shelter open 24/7, as required by the protocol, because scheduled staff didn’t show up.
Ms. Harrington said they found ways to make it work, even if it required bringing mattresses from the shelter basement to prevent turning people away. This year won’t be any different.
“Anything we can do to get people off the streets and keep them warm, fed and comfortable, we're always going to be on board with it,” she said.
Jerrel Gilliam, director of Light of Life Rescue Mission, has reservations about the county’s new winter strategy. He is disappointed that by the elimination of Code Blue, which cities across the country, including New York City and Philadelphia, utilize as a response to severe weather. He’s concerned that promising shelter around the clock may create a reliance on temporary solutions.
“When you provide a space for a person to live rent-free for four months … people will choose that as a living option,” he said.
Mr. Gilliam said the region’s housing shortage will leave few options for those needing long-term support once winter shelters close in March. As it stands, there are still only 600 beds for the 1,000+ unhoused individuals in Allegheny County. Light of Life is offering 25 winter overflow beds.
“I'm not sure how they plan to make up that gap,” he said. “It goes back to the idea that there has to be more comprehensive solutions.”
As for the Salvation Army, Ms. Rorison plans to open overflow on Nov. 11, earlier than the official Nov. 15 start date. She allows people to keep their overflow spot for as long as they need it, even days or weeks.
“I don't care who you are, your lifestyle, you do not deserve to freeze to death at night,” she said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.