Nicole Cherico knew she wanted to work with seniors when she was just a teenager.
At 16, she took a receptionist job for a Highland Park nursing home. Even in just answering phone calls or greeting families visiting their loved ones, she immediately saw her future — helping the most vulnerable people in her community.
Ms. Cherico went on to pursue a career in nursing and worked her way to assistant nursing director at The Willows, a skilled nursing facility in Oakmont. But the landscape of senior care has taken a drastic turn in recent years, a far cry from the industry she entered. Each day can bring new uncertainty about the future.
When someone calls out sick or doesn’t show up to work, it’s on her to figure out how to fill the gap. It can change on a dime — not day by day, but from shift to shift. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, her facility has been increasingly losing nurses to more flexible, well-paying jobs like case management or insurance. Others have fled the field entirely.
“You want to give the residents the best care, but you don't always have enough staff to do that,” Ms. Cherico said. “Instead of 10 residents, now you have 20, and you're trying to make sure that everybody has everything they need, but you can't give them the attention that they deserve. You see a lot of burnout. You saw a lot of people who were here for a long time quit or explore other options.”
As a result, Pennsylvania’s long-term care providers have been forced to take desperate measures — diminishing the number of open beds they offer, limiting admissions, turning to outside agencies for temporary, more expensive work or even shutting their doors.
Read More
Ask providers, and they cite the same root problems: chronic Medicaid underfunding and staffing shortages.
Now compounding the issues are recent state and federal measures implementing stricter staffing minimums for nursing homes.

The second phase of a statewide mandate for nurse-to-resident ratios and required direct care hours begins this July. And providers are figuring out how to manage it along with a new Biden administration rule approved in April, which will establish national minimum staffing requirements for nursing homes for the first time. The goal, the administration said, is to ensure that facilities have sufficient staff and promote resident safety.
Without a funding component or increased Medicaid reimbursement, advocates like Zach Shamberg, president of the Pennsylvania Health Care Association, say the new regulations may have the opposite effect it’s aiming for.
“It's asking providers to climb from the first to the 10th floor without giving them the rungs of a ladder,” Mr. Shamberg said. “It's really a backwards way of trying to bring more workers into the continuum. It should come with funding, and it should come with workforce development initiatives, otherwise it will not work.”
High costs, little staff
A survey released by the Pennsylvania Health Care Association of nursing facilities this spring illuminated the operating struggles and challenges for providers to sustain care in Pennsylvania.
The respondents identified inadequate Medicaid reimbursements as the number one reason why the operating environment isn’t viable. The inability to recruit more workers stands out, too, as a large reason for why providers are struggling to provide care.
The problem, Mr. Shamberg said, is that nursing home providers are extremely reliant on state and federal reimbursements for Medicaid and Medicare. More than 70% of Pennsylvanians residing in nursing homes depend on the state Medicaid program to fund their care.
But Medicaid reimbursements in particular have not kept pace with rising costs over the last few years. For eight years, from 2014 to 2021, there was no increase at the state level. Providers received federal stimulus funds during the early years of the pandemic, but no recurring payments to help sustain their operations.
This year, the PHCA expects the shortfall for the cost of care versus what the government reimburses to eclipse more than a billion dollars statewide.
“There needs to be more investment into this system, year over year, like we see with education and other initiatives,” Mr. Shamberg said. “Otherwise it will be an unsustainable system, especially given our aging demographics and the fact that our older population is exploding across Pennsylvania.”
Fueling the crisis
When overlaying the upcoming state and federal staffing requirements, it may cost the state millions to afford staff that can fill those positions, according to Garry Pezzano, president and CEO of LeadingAge PA, an industry group that represents aging services providers.
While outside agencies can temporarily fix the staffing level problem by supplying contracted employees, it only adds more financial burden in the long run.
“There's no check on what they can charge the provider,” Mr. Pezzano said. “Our providers are paying exorbitant amounts of money just to get the agency staff to fill in where they don't have staff. That's where you come to the closing of the beds.”
The PHCA survey found that most providers are compensating by leaving beds unfilled. Nearly 75% of respondents reported they have beds that can’t be used because their facilities do not have enough caregivers.
Roughly half of providers denied admissions to new residents in the first quarter of 2024, citing the state’s existing staffing ratio mandate and the inability to hire more workers. One facility revealed that it denied almost 250 referrals for care in just a matter of three months.
Every facility that responded to the survey reported that it had job openings for direct care positions.
“We have this workforce crisis, this underfunding crisis, and what it's all culminating into is an access to care crisis,” Mr. Pezzano said.
Already, the region has been rocked by the worst case scenario. Two nursing facilities in Pittsburgh are set to shutter this summer. And more may be on the way.
Just in the last month, 21 nursing and personal care homes filed for bankruptcy across Pennsylvania, including 12 Pittsburgh-area providers.
Creating a better future for senior care
PHCA hopes to mitigate further fallout by advocating for more than $25 million to help providers offset the cost of the state’s staffing mandate.
PHCA is also asking the state legislature and Gov. Josh Shapiro to adopt and fund a quality incentive program that would distribute more funding to providers who meet specific standards. Combined with other additional payments for nursing facilities that heavily rely on Medicaid, this represents a total ask of more than $140 million in the 2024-25 state budget.
“Pennsylvania nursing facilities need state officials to undo years of insufficient investment in senior care and end the Medicaid reimbursement shortfall gap,” Mr. Shamberg said.
For now, long-term care facilities like Ms. Cherico’s are offering more financial incentives, like adding $10 to hourly wages, for nurses who can fill open shifts. Providers are often paying overtime hours on top of that.
“You add the increasing ratios, and we're kind of having to up the ante even more, and we don't have that extra income coming in to do that,” Ms. Cherico said. “What are we supposed to do?”
Long-term care providers emphasize that the state needs a more reliable pipeline of caregivers to truly address the ongoing staffing shortage. That’s why the Presbyterian SeniorCare Network created a tuition loan forgiveness program in 2022, allowing staff to become licensed practical nurses while continuing to work limited hours for their facility.
“The program is amazing,” Ms. Cherico said. “It gives people a really great opportunity to fulfill their dreams and go to school and not have that debt. I mean, what else could you hope for?”
To help young students get early exposure to the senior care field, the Presbyterian SeniorCare Network is recruiting high schoolers for hands-on training opportunities. The organization is also offering its own nurse aide program with Department of Education certified trainers.
Bobbie Gray, vice president of care communities for the Presbyterian SeniorCare Network, said even the schools that provide this kind of specialized training have been closing since COVID-19, too.
“There's no surprise that there's a nursing shortage,” she said. “It's just really hard to recruit those people to come and work in these areas. We’re now trying to offer the training ourselves.”
For Ms. Cherico, she hopes more health care professionals will see the field in the same way she does. Pennsylvania seniors need them now more than ever.
“I feel like nursing homes have this big stigma,” she said. “But to be here and to be able to care for these residents, it's a gift. It’s nurse-driven.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.