Like many working parents, Samantha Melvin and her husband were searching for high quality care for their 7-month-old son, Beckett.
As a researcher who specializes in child care policy, Ms. Melvin knew exactly what she wanted: a nearby licensed home provider, as she preferred the more intimate setting and its general affordability.
But the family found “extremely limited” options in her neighborhood, especially those within walking distance of her Stanton Heights home. Earlier this month, the couple had to diverge from their initial plan and placed Beckett into a center-based daycare after they learned of an opening.
“You can live it through other folks every day, and then you experience it yourself,” Ms. Melvin said. “It was very humbling to be just right there in the trenches with every other new parent trying to figure out child care.”
A solution may be on the horizon for parents in similar situations. Earlier this month, Pittsburgh City Council approved legislation that could encourage more home-based providers to open and help families access quality child care in their own neighborhoods.
The change in the city’s zoning code will allow facilities that care for up to six children to be permitted without needing a special exemption. It also eliminates off-street parking requirements.
Read More
Councilmembers Bobby Wilson and Deb Gross introduced the legislation in October, at a time when staffing shortages and facility closures had created a nationwide child care crisis.

Seeing the challenges in Pittsburgh, Emily Neff, director of public policy for Trying Together, a children’s advocacy group, was an early supporter of the reform. The organization met with Mr. Wilson and the city’s department of planning to help shape the legislation.
“We're really thrilled that it's going to be easier and less burdensome for home-based providers to open within the city,” Ms. Neff said. “We know they play a really important role in the early care and education landscape, and they're often overlooked.”
The pandemic brings new problems
The pandemic illuminated the need for child care. Most child care centers, schools and Head Start programs shut down in the spring of 2020, unable to accommodate social distancing and other health protocols. It was largely home-based centers that could stay open.
COVID-19-related stressors proved to weigh too heavily on an already fragile business model, where stagnant wages and reimbursement rates had also made it difficult to hire and retain staff. Child care centers’ capacity fell by 50,000 as a result of the pandemic, an estimate Ms. Gross shared during a council meeting last fall.
Now, about 5,000 children in Allegheny County are on waitlists. The Start Strong PA survey, released last year, also found that nearly 90% of centers that responded to the survey indicated they were facing staff shortages, with about 500 positions open across Allegheny County.
“Imagine what that number would have been if we would have heard from every program?” Ms. Neff said.
At times, facing mounting debt or the risk of losing staff, providers pass on costs to parents. Child care has remained one of the largest expenses for families, Ms. Neff said, sometimes costing as much as rent. She heard from one provider who raised per-child costs $100 a month to be able to keep paying employees.
Home-based providers play a critical role in the early care and education landscape, advocates say, offering smaller groups, the ability to care for siblings in the same setting and more flexible schedules.
Kids can also keep the same caregiver over their entire early childhood experience, fostering “long and continuous” relationships between providers and families, said Natalie Renew, director of the Philadelphia-based nonprofit Home Grown, a national initiative dedicated to improving the quality of and access to home-based child care.
“They really are providing a much more comprehensive family support, especially for low income families,” Ms. Renew said.
And it’s not just glorified babysitting. Licensed home providers are subject to unplanned inspections, and staffers are required to undergo safety training and obtain certain professional credentials, like K-12 teachers do.
But actually developing these centers comes with a host of challenges. Obtaining zoning variances or special permits can be costly and even deter them from opening at all.
“It can cost $20,000 in legal fees to get a zoning special permit to open a home-based child care operation, where you may only earn $25,000 in your first and second year of operation,” Ms. Renew said.
The genesis of the legislation
Ms. Melvin, an assistant research professor at the child development graduate school Erikson Institute, shared her story with council in February and urged the city to remove zoning barriers. She pointed to the ways zoning requirements, including parking requirements and paperwork and hearing processes are barriers for people who want to open their homes to their communities.
In Pittsburgh, zoning requirements also led to smaller capacities in family child care homes that could otherwise serve more children, she said.
In dense urban areas, off-street or multiple-space parking is rarely available, especially in under-resourced communities. And about half of Pittsburgh households have no car or only one car, she said, making the city’s parking requirement “even less relevant” to many families with young children. Before the zoning reform, the amount of parking space someone had could affect how many children they were able to care for.
“As a parent and an expert, I support these zoning changes,” Ms. Melvin told council. “I believe that the new requirements will be an important step toward more home-based child care programs opening, more seats becoming available and overall greater access to affordable, small-group child care settings that many parents prefer.”
Ms. Renew says Pittsburgh’s legislation reflects a movement nationwide. Connecticut, Oklahoma, Colorado, Oregon and California have created laws focusing on the zoning issue, establishing new home-based child care operations as residential by right. What makes Pittsburgh’s approach novel is that the action came at the city level.
“Other places can look to Pittsburgh and say, even if the state is not acting on this issue, we, as a community that prioritizes child care and supporting small businesses and entrepreneurs, can do something similar,” she said. “Let’s make the regulatory experience for providers more streamlined, more coherent and more common sense.”
Pittsburgh has seen a slate of child care-focused investments in recent years. In 2019, the city started the $2 million Child Care Quality Fund. In 2021, the Urban Redevelopment Authority began offering a forgivable loan program to child care centers. As of last fall, all have remained open, and more than 70% have increased enrollment and more than 60% have hired additional staff.
Last year, Councilman Ricky Burgess introduced legislation to revive a program providing child care for city employees, an effort that ended when the provider went out of business. And earlier this year, one of new County Executive Sara Innamorato’s first actions in office was announcing $500,000 in funding to help residents pay for child care.
Despite such momentum, it’s clear that Pittsburgh parents are still feeling the effects of the child care crisis. For now, the family is digging into its savings to pay the cost of their son’s daycare.
Ms. Melvin is happy with the services but wishes parents didn’t have to make such tough choices balancing quality care, price and proximity. She hopes the new zoning flexibilities could open more possibilities down the line.
“It's a problem in Pittsburgh, but it's a problem all over the country — this is a national child care crisis,” she said. “If we can just keep making lots of little changes, eventually that will make progress towards solving the problem.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.