Kathy Sherlock doesn’t have the words to describe the bond she and her 7-year-old daughter, Kayden Mancuso, shared. There was just “something different” about her little girl. 

Kayden, a Bucks County native, was just about to enter the second grade and start playing on a competitive softball team. She was a “vibrant, smart” kid who loved unicorns, mermaids, American Girl dolls and dancing. 

But in August 2018, the young girl’s life was abruptly cut short when her biological father beat her to death during a court-ordered, unsupervised visit. Ms. Sherlock’s father and husband found Kayden the morning after she was supposed to return home.

“As a mom, I still don't understand why,” Ms. Sherlock said. “Why her? I still can't comprehend or wrap my head around it. It doesn’t feel real. Her world stopped at 7.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Sherlock vowed to never let the tragedy happen to another child, embarking on a nationwide legislative campaign to advocate for family court reforms and help shield kids from abusive parents in custody cases. The result was “Kayden’s Law,” which several other states — including Colorado and California — have already enacted. 

Pennsylvania is expected to join that list soon, as the bill passed the state House this week and heads to Gov. Josh Shapiro’s desk. The bipartisan legislation unanimously passed the Senate last October. 

“This is a little girl in our community, so it shows that when you reach across the aisle and can work together, good things can occur,” state Sen. Lisa Baker, R-Luzerne, a primary sponsor of the bill, said.

Ms. Baker remembers hearing what happened to Kayden from Ms. Sherlock herself during a public hearing a few years ago. The details were horrific — Kayden’s father beat her with a dumbbell and suffocated her with a plastic bag. He left a two-page note on her body, writing, “You all get what you deserve,” before killing himself.  

“Kathy took her grief and spoke as the voice for her daughter who was no longer here; it was very powerful,” Ms. Baker said. “Her life changed in just a quick instant.”

Advertise with us

For the past five years, several senators have worked to push the legislation forward. The issue is especially close to another bill sponsor, state Sen. Steve Santarsiero, D-Bucks, as Kayden lived in his district.

“This bill cannot heal the grievous wound that Kathy and her family have suffered, but by protecting our children moving forward, I hope it will give them some measure of solace,” said Mr. Santarsiero in a news release.

Kayden's Law, or Senate Bill 55, would broaden the criteria judges must consider when making custody and visitation decisions, adding seven crimes to the list of offenses that must be taken into account before awarding custody of a child. 

If the court finds ongoing risk of abuse, Kayden’s Law would require that any custody order include safety conditions and restrictions — among them supervised visitation — to protect the child. It also encourages the state to implement a yearly educational and training program for judges and other court staff on child abuse, domestic violence and its impact on children.

Custody determinations are “without question” some of the most difficult decisions a judge will ever face, Ms. Baker said. She thinks the reforms of Kayden’s Law better positions the court to prioritize the child’s safety in those decisions. 

Advertise with us

“If there is the potential for that risk, based on past behavior or past convictions, then we should have ways in which that child would be protected with supervised custody,” Ms. Baker said. 

In 2021, another iteration of the bill successfully moved through the Senate, but languished in the House Judiciary Committee. The ACLU of Pennsylvania told the Post-Gazette that the organization opposed that version of Kayden's Law due to some concerns about the legislation potentially having unintended consequences on parents of color. Black Pennsylvanians are more likely be investigated for child abuse allegations, and Black children are removed from their homes at higher rates. 

After the bill was amended in the Senate Judiciary Committee, the organization says it maintains a “neutral” position.

When the 2021 bill stalled, the senators heard from those who argued against it, as well as judges, district attorneys and other families affected by the system, to revise some of the language, Ms. Baker said.

“We have a far better law and product than we did when we first introduced the bill,” she said. 

Advertise with us

Ms. Sherlock believes what happened to Kayden was preventable. Leading up to her daughter’s death, she said she turned to the police, child protective services, Kayden’s school and others to warn about how dangerous the girl’s father was. She asked the court to grant supervised visitation. Despite the father’s documented history of violence, those pleas were ignored. 

Instead, Ms. Sherlock said, she faced accusations of parental alienation. She has heard similar stories from parents worldwide, mostly mothers, seeking help in their custody cases. She said they tell her: “I don’t want my child to be the next Kayden.”

With the protections of Kayden’s Law, Ms. Sherlock thinks her daughter could be here today. She would have just entered her teenage years in October. While frustrated that it took five years for her own state to pass the reforms, she hopes other families will be saved from the grief she experienced.

“I want my daughter back, but that’s not an option,” Ms. Sherlock said. “This is just the right thing to do. If we don't stand up for kids, what can we stand for?”