A recent report released by Allegheny County lends new understanding of intimate partner violence on the local level, posing larger questions about where the system could better intervene before the problem turns fatal. 

The county Department of Human Services analyzed data on intimate partner homicides from January 2017 through September 2022. Several key demographic trends emerged – homicides happened more frequently in high-need areas, and younger Black women, most commonly aged 24 to 35, are victimized at the highest rate. The finding also indicate that both victim and perpetrators have high rates of involvement with the system, particularly in human services and behavioral health. 

These findings come over a year after the county assembled a task force of leaders to head domestic violence initiatives. The new insights lay the groundwork for conversation among the board and the greater community, says Kathi Elliot, a member of the Intimate Partner Violence Reform Leadership Task Force. She is also chief executive officer of Gwen’s Girls, a Pittsburgh-based organization that provides gender-specific programming and education. 

“This is just the start,” she said. “We started with gathering the data, the historical data from the county, and the next step is to be more of a working group to make sure that the solutions are in place. It's at that level where we need everybody to address this.”

Advertise with us

Intimate partner violence, as defined by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, is abuse or aggression that occurs in a romantic relationship, including current and former spouses and dating partners. The issue remains devastatingly common nationwide. 

The CDC’s National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey indicates that about 41% of women and 26% of men have experienced some form of intimate partner violence in their lifetimes.

The report writes that in the past, the county has largely relied on national data. The recent findings confirm what some local advocates already suspected, with disproportionate impact falling on those disadvantaged by racial and socioeconomic inequalities.

The number of intimate partner homicide incidents increased between 2019 and 2021, climbing from five to 11. Intimate partner homicides comprised a slightly higher share of all homicides in 2021 than they did in any year since 2017. The majority of these incidents, over half, involved a firearm.

Patterns emerged in terms of where the violence occurred. Homicides tended to concentrate in higher-need areas across the county, with roughly 55% occurring in extreme- and high-need census tracts. When looking at the data by the census’ “Community Needs Index” category, the number of incidents progressively increased as the level of need goes up.

Advertise with us

This reality is already at the forefront of Ms. Elliot’s work with Gwen’s Girls, which offers education and health coping strategies around intimate partner violence specifically. The organization primarily serves girls living in neighborhoods with high rates of poverty, crime and violence. The report underscores the need for targeted assistance and intervention, she said. 

“There's some sad realities, and it's not shocking because it's things we've known based on the different populations we serve,” Ms. Elliot said. “Oftentimes young people who have grown up in households where they have been witnesses to that type of violence tend to be also victims or even perpetrators. We try to highlight those facts and present healthy coping strategies.”

Intimate partner homicides, the report describes, is often a culmination of escalating violence between partners, even though this escalation isn’t always visible. However, data on emergency department visits among victims and criminal filings among perpetrators does indicate growing violence in the months leading up to the homicide. Longer term trends in emergency department visits showed an uptick starting 18 to 24 months before the incident.

Pittsburgh’s Crisis Center North has worked to facilitate a stronger connection between the hospital system and victim services. Michael Brayack, the organization’s grants and publications manager, says part of their programming, on top of their domestic violence emergency shelter, housing and counseling center, is a medical advocacy program. Crisis Center North staff meets regularly with local hospitals to provide training to doctors, nurses and medical students about dynamics of domestic violence and intimate partner violence. They work with clients directly in hospital settings as well. 

The goal is to help medical professionals feel more comfortable asking tough questions to identify potential victims. 

Advertise with us

“The purpose is to help medical providers to see the signs of domestic violence,” Mr. Brayack said. “But more importantly, to feel empowered themselves and comfortable to be able to ask that question of someone potentially in need. If medical providers would find someone who has been victimized, they can now be referred to us.”

Both victims and perpetrators of intimate partner homicide showed high rates of involvement across human services and behavioral health systems. That’s especially the case for the perpetrators, with 74% having prior involvement with child welfare, publicly funded behavioral health or homeless and housing systems. 

They also had a high incidence of overlapping behavioral health needs they were accessing treatment for. Though it is “impossible” to conclude from this data alone that these needs were a direct cause, this utilization of behavioral health services points to a potential screening and intervention point for intimate partner violence.

More recently, Crisis Center North has embedded its mobile advocacy team at places like Gateway Rehab, for example, to connect with people who may not be actively seeking out services on one particular issue, like domestic violence, but may be experiencing it concurrently. As the report indicates, there’s more work ahead to bridge services.

“Everyone is working at their own small piece, and we're not able to treat the person holistically,” he said. “Increasing interconnection between victim service agencies, medical establishments, law enforcement and just all these places in the community, creating this network of referral, is very much a good thing.”

Advertise with us

The report also looks at where risk factors could be overlooked, especially in the criminal justice system. Among the perpetrators with domestic violence related criminal cases, the majority occurred in the 18 months leading up to the homicide incident. 

While a meaningful proportion of perpetrators had indicators of intimate violence history, only a handful of these were referred, as far as the county could tell, to the Battering Intervention Program.

And all the while, there appears to be a lack of resources for those who have engaged in intimate partner violence outside of the criminal justice system, which the report says may be a critical missing piece in effectively preventing homicide. That’s something Womanspace East case manager Dana Morton wants to see, as someone who works closely with women affected by domestic violence. 

She says a range of support services, rightly, focus on victims, including her own organization that shelters homeless families and screens for issues like domestic violence upon intake. She wants to see more proactive response to prevent the worst case scenario. 

“The county does have a lot of resources for domestic violence, and there are shelters providing that direct assistance,” she said. “But I feel like we can't just stop at the victim. What is happening to the perpetrators besides incarceration?  There's childhood trauma, family trauma, mental health. We need to provide support, rehabilitation services.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Elliot of Gwen’s Girls looks forward to an upcoming task force meeting in November to discuss the report and steps ahead.

“It's going to take the government, nonprofits, healthcare systems, everybody, to really play their part and be at the table,” she said. 

Correction, posted at 2:55 p.m. Oct. 31: An earlier version of this story was updated to correct the following: The correct the name of the organization is Crisis Center North.