In the hours after the Smithfield Street Shelter closed Wednesday, there were mixed emotions from the people most directly affected. 

Those experiencing homelessness who used it as a temporary resting place were feeling lost. Outreach workers had safety concerns. And nearby business owners were relieved. 

The shelter at the Smithfield United Church of Christ closed Wednesday morning, and despite efforts by Allegheny County’s Department of Human Services, many people who used it still had nowhere to go. 

Keinen Winstad, 25, said he plans to live outside until he can find a place to stay — and has to come to terms with living on the streets again.

Advertise with us

“It’s a big deal because they give us food, and I can brush my teeth,” Mr. Winstad said.

Mr. Winstad said he is going to “post up outside and be patient until, you know, I can go somewhere.”

When Alyssa Cunha first heard the shelter — which she has used — was closing, she said she thought it was “really pointless because of the fact that a lot of people sleep there.”

“It’s really nice to have somewhere inside to sleep, and it was really convenient because it’s right downtown,” said Ms. Cunha, 18.

On Tuesday night, hours before the shelter closed, activist Lorenzo Rulli helped feed 100 people with 13 pizzas funded through community donations. He said the evening was somber, as people contemplated their options and confronted the reality that their nightly safety net is gone.

Advertise with us

“There's a sense of sadness because even the people that are being offered places could be spread across the city, so the community they built, the families they built, are being broken,” he said. “A  lot of people were sad. A lot of people shed a tear.”

Mr. Rulli said most of the people he’s spoken to plan to stay Downtown because that’s what they know. He hopes to see more shelter spaces in the future, ones that include bathroom facilities, counseling services and other resources. 

“If there is a funding issue, there is a $10 million Housing Opportunity Fund that is given to the city of Pittsburgh this year,” he said. “If there's a staffing issue, I am here for free every day anyway. There are also many people in the city that will volunteer their time every single day to keep those doors open. There is not one reason that this makes sense. It’s not going to work.”

Earlier this year, county human services announced that the shelter — which typically doesn’t remain open past the winter months — would stay in service through the summer. But in May, DHS officials announced that the shelter would close in June.

In a fact sheet posted to its website, DHS officials wrote that Smithfield shelter “was never designed as a year-round shelter or long-term living space.” Of the roughly 125 people who used the shelter regularly, DHS officials had found alternative shelter plans for over 30 of them, they said.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh City Council President Theresa Kail-Smith said that she was thankful that Mayor Ed Gainey’s office was working with the county to “try and figure out a best scenario for the people that are unhoused and in need of a place.” 

Since last week, John Holzer and other outreach workers from the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership have been providing shuttle services to help people affected by the closure get to nearby shelters. But due to limited capacity at other shelters, people often used the van to get a meal and return to Smithfield for the night.

“The shelter would kick people out at 6 a.m., the library doesn’t open until eight or nine and they're hungry,” he said. “They want to go out and eat. They can jump on the shuttle, get breakfast and get right back. Now obviously, that dynamic is gonna change because the shelter is no longer open.” 

The Downtown Partnership’s vans hold about 10 people each, with one running in the morning and another in the evening. They make stops at the shelters around the city — from Second Avenue Commons, to Shepherd’s Heart to Pleasant Valley, to East End Cooperative Ministry, where Mr. Holzer dropped off one person Tuesday night. The vans used to go to a shelter in McKeesport, but it ran out of space.

He says the shuttle program is set to run for the next couple of months.

Advertise with us

When Mr. Holzer arrived at the Smithfield shelter Wednesday morning, it hardly resembled the place he had come to know. It looked deserted, he said. 

Less than 24 hours earlier, the area right outside Smithfield United Church of Christ was bustling with people around the stairs and sidewalk, all waiting to secure a bed one last time. Now, in their place, just a few belongings were left behind. 

“There's a couple of items that people have sitting outside but it's pretty desolate compared to what it normally is,” he said. 

With “No Loitering” signs posted in the area,  Mr. Holzer wonders if people might be intimidated not to stay in the area. He does expect the nightly shuttle routes to get busier since people now don’t have anywhere to sleep.

He said he has helped people suffering from drug addiction get into housing and start making a better life for themselves. He’s also made calls to crisis services when someone is at risk of self-harm. 

Advertise with us

“I'm very close to a lot of these people out here,” Mr. Holzer said. “There is a success story, and that's what we live for.”

While those who relied on the shelter for food and a place to stay are struggling to find a new place to go, some of the businesses around the shelter are glad it closed. They said it negatively impacted their businesses, especially in the last year.

Nick Kouvaras, the manager of Yuriy’s Jewelry on Smithfield Street, said that while the city should open more shelters, he’s glad the one down the street from his store is closed. For the past several decades, he said, the shelter didn’t cause any disturbances. But extending its use to summer months was a bad decision, he said. Some customers have asked to be accompanied to their cars because of perceptions of danger in the area, Mr. Kouvaras said.

“It should not be in the business district,” he said.

Jack Cohen, the owner of S.W. Randall Toyes & Giftes on Smithfield Street, agreed. 

Advertise with us

“We work to make ends meet,” Mr. Cohen said. “Why can't they work? Get a job. There's jobs everywhere.”

Hallie Lauer contributed to this report.