For many years, Pennsylvania has been slowly closing state institutions for people with intellectual disabilities in favor of caring for them in smaller, community-based settings such as group homes, a trend welcomed by many disability advocates.
But Tuesday, family members of people with severe disabilities whose loved ones live in any of four remaining state centers argued that an institutional setting provides the best care for their children and siblings.
“Sandy takes temper tantrums, like a two year-old, during which she can and has hurt herself and others. A familiar staff can see Sandy getting upset before she starts and redirect her to avoid an uncontrollable outburst of anger,” said Mary Wills, in written remarks she submitted prior to testifying before the state House Human Services Committee in Harrisburg
Her sister, Sandy Wills, who lives in Ebensburg State Center in Cambria County, has lived at a state center for 57 years, since age 10, Ms. Wills said Tuesday. An institution has been the best home for Sandy, she said.
Others testified that they believed the centers are the safest places for their sibling or child, due to dangerous or severely self-injuring behavior.
“Let us have more input into this very important decision concerning the state centers' future,” said Ms. Wills, who is the president of a group of Ebensburg family members.
Read More
A bill previously before the General Assembly would have required Pennsylvania’s Department of Human Services to prepare a plan to close the remaining state centers for people with intellectual disabilities by 2023, though the legislation did not get a vote and has not been reintroduced for the current legislative session.
Pennsylvania operates four state centers — Ebensburg, Polk State Center in Venango County, Selinsgrove State Center in Snyder County, and White Haven State Center in Luzerne County. Hamburg Center in Berks County officially closed last year, after a months-long process to relocate its remaining residents. With the closure of Hamburg, there are 731 people living in state centers, according to the Department of Human Services.
“We can serve folks at a higher level,” outside of an institution, said then-Human Services Secretary Ted Dallas when announcing Hamburg’s closure in 2017.
Because of costs, court decisions, and the disability rights movement, trends have been toward deinstitutionalization for some time, both in Pennsylvania and nationally. According to a 2015 state report, nine state centers (or units that were part of mental health facilities) closed from the mid-1980s to 1999; others have closed since then.
People are still admitted to the centers periodically, according to DHS officials. In fiscal year 2018-19, four people have been admitted and a fifth is pending admission. The prior year, 14 people were admitted, state officials said. “Admission to a state center requires a 406 court commitment, which occurs after a regional program office evaluates the patient’s eligibility for an intermediate care facility and determines that a less restrictive alternative does not exist that can meet the patient’s needs,” according to a DHS spokeswoman.
Caring for people in an institutional setting is generally far more costly — about $330,000 per resident per year, noted a 2015 report from the Legislative Budget and Finance Committee.
“Funds expended per individual at a state center averaged seven times the funds expended for an individual being served in the community; however, approximately 88 percent of the current residents of state centers are diagnosed as severely or profoundly disabled, compared to 16 percent of individuals similarly diagnosed who are receiving [home and community-based services],” the report stated. The report also noted more than a quarter of state center residents are 65 or older, and about 90 percent have been residents of a state center for longer than 16 years.
The cost per resident is also higher in a state center because they are operating at less than half their capacity, according to a 2017 analysis from the House Democratic Appropriations Committee.
“Once size does not fit all,” said Rep. Tom Murt, R-Montgomery, a human services committee member. “If many of these residents could function well in a group home, they would be there.”
Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.