Lawmakers and advocates say a last-minute addition to a state budget-related bill last year could harm Pennsylvanians who depend on an assistance program for transportation to medical appointments, as well as seniors and people with disabilities.

Federal law requires states to provide non-emergency medical transportation to anyone enrolled in the Medicaid program for travel to medical appointments, to pick up prescriptions at a pharmacy, or to buy medical equipment.

The services are paid for jointly by the state and federal governments.

Because people using the program have serious medical conditions such as kidney failure, or substance abuse disorders, the program helps pay for itself by allowing for preventative care, and avoiding missed medical appointments that can lead to complications and higher costs, according to a study touted by advocacy groups Pennsylvania Health Access Network and the Pennsylvania Transportation Alliance.

Advertise with us

Currently, the services are provided differently in different counties. Some counties hire vendors to provide transportation, some provide transportation directly.

A provision in last year's state Human Service Code, a budget-related bill, required the state to provide this service using a statewide or regional “brokerage model.”

Under the brokerage model, the state would be divided into three regions, and a state-contracted brokerage firm would negotiate with transportation networks and manage call centers.

Human service and transit officials from rural counties have expressed concern that any changes would undermine existing integrated transportation programs, which combine Medicaid-covered transportation with shared ride services that serve seniors and people with disabilities and are funded by a variety of sources, such as state funds and lottery proceeds.

“We combine those rides together and run it as as efficiently as we can and as effectively as we can,” said Alan Blahovec, executive director of the Westmoreland County Transit Authority. Many rural counties do this, Mr. Blahovec said, and the state even helped counties to purchase scheduling software to do this more effectively.

Advertise with us

Pulling out Medical Assistance rides could undermine the whole system, Mr. Blahovec fears.

“We're going to go from a coordinated system to essentially an uncoordinated system,” he said. “Nobody can say yet if there is going to be a savings from it.”

His worries were echoed by Karen Bennett, the human services administrator for Greene County. Ms. Bennett oversees the transportation program, which provided 13,000 trips in the last fiscal year.

“We're very, very concerned in our rural areas,” she said.

These potential changes have some lawmakers saying the issue needs to be studied further. Some criticize the brokerage requirement as an eleventh-hour addition to legislation just prior to its passage. No legislator has yet claimed credit for adding the provision to the bill.

Advertise with us

“This is a sweeping change in Pennsylvania's transportation policy,” said Rep. Eric Nelson, R-Hempfield, speaking at a press conference in support of studying the issue further. “Once a change like this is implemented, it will be extremely difficult to dial it back.”

Companion bills in the state House and Senate would delay the implementation of the brokerage model, require a study on the impacts to each county of using that model, recommend how to minimize disruptions, and forbid the state from taking action prior to 90 days from the end of the study.

Both House Bill 986 and Senate Bill 390 have bipartisan support; the Senate version of the bill was voted out of that body's Health and Human Services committee 10-1 last week.

“This the transportation network of last resort. These are a lot of very vulnerable people,” said Sen. Lisa Baker, R-Luzerne, the prime sponsor of the Senate bill.

In Allegheny County, Port Authority contracts with the Access system to transport Medicaid recipients. Port Authority is "actively monitoring and supporting," the two bills, a spokesman for the agency said.

Advertise with us

State human service officials say they are acting because a law passed by the legislature required this change, they project a $15 million annual savings from the switch, and they won’t implement the new model without ensuring services are in place.

The state Department of Human Services is currently evaluating the proposals it received from brokerage companies, said Sally Kozak, deputy secretary for the department’s Office of Medical Assistance Programs. She said no changes would be enacted for riders until the fall of 2020 or later.

“That would give the broker time to work with existing providers,” she said, adding that she believes shared ride systems could remain in place.

“We anticipate that while there could be some changes, most of the existing providers will remain intact,” she said. “While we appreciate the concerns about access, we don't expect that consumers will lose the existing large service providers that they are currently familiar with.”

Kate Giammarise: kgiammarise@post-gazette.com or 412-263-3909.