Chil­dren typ­i­cally look like one or both par­ents. No news there. In fact, when they don’t, that’s when there’s gos­sip.

And there’s surely no gos­sip over Don­ald and Kiefer Suther­land, Tom and Colin Hanks, or Will and Jaden Smith, to name three of a bil­lion ex­am­ples.

Science, how­ever, has yet to ex­plain why Ava Phil­lippe looks ex­actly like her mother, Reese With­er­spoon; or how Mamie Gum­mer could pass as a young ver­sion of her mom, Meryl Streep; or how ge­net­ics turned So­phie von Hasel­berg into the spit­ting im­age of her mother, Bette Midler.

So fi­nally ar­rives a study pub­lished Feb. 19 in Na­ture Ge­net­ics in­volv­ing the Univer­sity of Pitts­burgh that takes im­por­tant steps in ex­plain­ing such ge­net­ics — how some­thing so ob­vi­ous in­volves such a com­pli­cated in­ter­ac­tion of genes. Some of the genes re­spon­si­ble for fa­cial ap­pear­ance also play a role in body size, body com­po­si­tion in­clud­ing waist-to-hip ra­tio, and height.

Advertise with us

“The study high­lights tech­niques that will have fu­ture ben­e­fits in health care and as­so­ci­ated pro­fes­sions, ex­plain­ing the bi­o­log­i­cal ba­sis of fa­cial shape that can be used to im­prove med­i­cal di­ag­no­sis and treat­ments,” said Ste­phen Rich­mond of Card­iff Univer­sity in Wales, who wasn’t in­volved in the study. “Also un­der­stand­ing which genes af­fect faces and body shape will be use­ful in fo­ren­sic sci­ence and med­i­cine in gen­eral.”

The study re­veals that many in­ter­act­ing genes are re­spon­si­ble for the nose you de­spise, the eye­brows that em­bar­rass you, and the lips that you think are way too thin. And other in­ter­act­ing genes, in fact, led to those chip­munk cheeks, even if sin­gle genes ac­count for less no­ta­ble ar­eas around the pe­rim­e­ter of the face.

When you look in the mir­ror, you can only blame your genes and their vari­ants.

In all, the study that also in­volved re­search­ers from Penn State and Stan­ford uni­ver­sities, with KU Leu­ven re­search uni­ver­sity in Bel­gium lead­ing the way, iden­ti­fied 15 genes that play an im­por­tant role in fa­cial struc­ture.

Still, the pro­cess “is more com­plex than pre­vi­ously thought,” said Seth Wein­berg, the study’s se­nior au­thor who di­rects the Pitt School of Den­tal Med­i­cine’s CCDG 3D Fa­cial Imag­ing and Mor­pho­met­rics Lab. “We are at­tempt­ing to map genes that un­der­lie nor­mal or typ­i­cal vari­a­tion in fa­cial fea­tures — the kinds of vari­a­tions that give each of us our unique fa­cial ap­pear­ance. But there are thou­sands of genes in­volved in fa­cial de­vel­op­ment.”

Advertise with us

Lead au­thor Peter Claes of KU Leu­ven cre­ated a unique com­puter model to an­a­lyze thou­sands of com­mon points from 3-D fa­cial im­ages of more than 2,300 in­di­vid­u­als. The in­ter­dis­ci­plin­ary study also re­quired re­search­ers with dif­fer­ent skill sets to an­a­lyze how clus­ters of points from that anal­y­sis came to rep­resent dis­tinct fa­cial “mod­ules.”

“Points in the same mod­ule tend to be­have the same way, mean­ing that they vary in a co­or­di­nated fash­ion,” with each mod­ule rep­re­sent­ing “a dis­tinct chunk of fa­cial anat­omy,” said Mr. Wein­berg, who holds a doc­tor­ate in an­thro­pol­ogy.

Fur­ther anal­y­sis linked each mod­ule to a spe­cific gene or vari­ant of that gene. That meant that each per­son with a spe­cific vari­ant showed sim­i­lar fa­cial char­ac­ter­is­tics in that part of the face.

The nose, for ex­am­ple, in­cludes sev­eral mod­ules. One gene de­ter­mines the tip and an­other, the nos­trils, with sev­eral oth­ers dic­tat­ing the struc­ture of the rest of the nose. One vari­a­tion in the tip of the nose, slightly or dra­mat­i­cally, can al­ter the shape of the nos­trils or bridge of the nose, re­veal­ing how mod­ules in­ter­act. As it turns out, the face emerges as a patch­work of over­lap­ping, in­ter­act­ing mod­ules.

Or, as Mr. Wein­berg ex­plained, “Each of the 15 [ge­netic] sig­nals showed unique ef­fects of the face with each im­pli­cat­ing dif­fer­ent sets of mod­ules.”

Advertise with us

One gene — TBX15 — is in­volved with both the fore­head and round­ness of the cheek re­gion. Mu­ta­tions of that gene cause Cousin syn­drome, char­ac­ter­ized by a large pro­trud­ing fore­head.

Over­all, the study pro­vided “nearly com­plete cov­er­age of all fa­cial shape vari­a­tion at five dif­fer­ent lev­els of de­tail,” while ad­vanc­ing the field of fa­cial ge­net­ics on sev­eral fronts, “in­clud­ing ar­eas of the face whose shape in­volves a spe­cific gene and vari­ants of that gene.”

It also sug­gests that the tim­ing of gene ex­pres­sion in the em­bryo de­ter­mines fa­cial char­ac­ter­is­tics and some­day could be used to al­ter mu­tated genes to avoid fa­cial birth de­fects.

The fo­ren­sic use of DNA to de­scribe a crime sus­pect isn’t yet pos­si­ble and may never be, even if that idea draws the most at­ten­tion in this field of study, Mr. Wein­berg said.

In time, how­ever, such stud­ies could ex­plore the ge­netic vari­a­tions in dif­fer­ent races and eth­nic groups.

Advertise with us

Ad­ding to the com­plex­ity, there are other fac­tors that af­fect ap­pear­ance — en­vi­ron­men­tal ex­po­sures, nu­tri­tion and dis­ease — with Mr. Wein­berg not­ing that “all com­plex traits in­volve en­vi­ron­men­tal and ge­netic in­puts and in­ter­ac­tions.”

Jef­frey C. Mur­ray, a pro­fes­sor of pe­di­at­rics and ge­net­ics re­searcher at the Univer­sity of Iowa, said the study, in which he was not in­volved, shows “how co­op­er­a­tion across dis­ci­plines and coun­tries is the quick­est path to suc­cess” in un­der­stand­ing med­i­cal pro­cesses.

“It is a re­ally beau­ti­ful study that rep­resents a lot of work by many peo­ple over the years,” he said. “It com­bines state-of-the-art tech­nol­ogy and statis­ti­cal ap­proaches with the gen­er­ous co­op­er­a­tion of many pri­vate cit­i­zens will­ing to help sci­en­tific re­search ad­vance” by hav­ing their pic­tures taken for use in the study.

“It pro­vides ter­rific new in­sights into how the struc­ture of the face de­vel­ops and will be an im­por­tant bridge to fu­ture work that may im­prove the treat­ment of fa­cial in­ju­ries and birth de­fects,” Dr. Mur­ray said.

David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578. Twitter: @templetoons.