WASHINGTON — Like the boll weevil in the old folk song, John Fetterman may be lookin’ for a home.
Fetterman, a Democrat, has sided with President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans often enough that he is almost certain to face a primary challenge when he’s up for reelection in 2028.
And while Fetterman adamantly denies he would switch parties, Republicans are unlikely to just hand him their Senate nomination in any case.
“I don't think he's going to survive a primary as a Democrat, and I don't think he's going to survive a primary as a Republican,” said former U.S. Rep. Jim Greenwood, a Republican from eastern Pennsylvania.
Where does that leave Fetterman then? A senator without a welcoming political home.
He’s not the first in that position. A former occupant of the Pennsylvania Senate seat that Fetterman now holds, Arlen Specter, was one of only three Senate Republicans to back President Barack Obama’s stimulus package. That led to a GOP primary challenge by former U.S. Rep. Pat Toomey. Specter then became a Democrat, but lost that party’s primary to U.S. Rep. Joe Sestak.
Fetterman did not respond to a request for comment, but recently again denied he was thinking about switching parties.
“If I turn a Republican, then I’ll be a liar,” Fetterman said in a video posted by NBC News on Tuesday.
Fetterman’s apparent frustration with the recurring question comes amid a months-long deterioration of his relationship with many in his own party.
He earned the ire of many Democrats by voting for some of Trump’s Cabinet appointments, traveling to Mar-a-Lago to meet with the president, opposing resolutions that would limit Trump’s ability to attack Iran without congressional approval, and voting to fund Immigration and Customs Enforcement while other Democrats withheld support to push for changes in the agency’s operations.
He also became one of Congress’ most ardent supporters of Israel, even as other Democrats expressed opposition to that country’s response to the Oct. 7, 2023, attack by Hamas. Indeed, Fetterman said he’d leave the Democratic Party if its platform opposed aid to the Jewish state and “officially becomes the anti-Israel party.”
Even Republicans are wondering how a Democrat who once endorsed Bernie Sanders, the self-described Democratic Socialist senator from Vermont, and won his Senate seat with the support of progressives who viewed him as their champion, could face questions about his future political home.
“If you told me this 3½ years ago I would say, ‘You're insane,’” Republican consultant Vince Galko said.
Rather than try to mend fences with his fellow Democrats, Fetterman has continued to erect new walls. He appeared by video at the Republican midterm convention in Dallas earlier this month to introduce fellow Pennsylvania U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick, promising to work with Trump to “defend the steel way of life.”

The two senators have developed a friendship, often appear at public events together and even formed a joint fundraising committee. On Friday, both Fetterman and McCormick addressed the AI Horizons Summit in Pittsburgh and argued against government regulation of the development of artificial intelligence.
But appearing at a convention of the other political party was a step too far, said former Democratic Rep. Paul McHale, who preceded Toomey in representing the Lehigh Valley in Congress.
“I certainly wouldn't have attended, and I deeply regret that he did,” McHale said. “If he's going to appear at a midterm convention, he's signing up for the Republican agenda, perhaps not on every issue, but on most issues, and that is the implied statement that he has made by choosing to attend.”
Rep. Chris Deluzio of Fox Chapel, one potential Democratic challenger to Fetterman in 2028, said the convention appearance and other Republican-friendly moves by Fetterman hinder Democratic efforts to capture the House and Senate this fall.
“I'm trying to win my own race and help other Democrats win all over Pennsylvania, and John’s making it harder for us,” Deluzio said. “He’s badmouthing the party on television. He helped Donald Trump and the Republicans at their convention. He is making it harder for us to do things that we have to do in November.”

Despite some high-profile dissents, Fetterman has been a loyal Democrat. Last year, he voted with a majority of his party — and against a majority of Republicans — 80% of the time, according to CQ-Roll Call’s annual vote studies.
“Ronald Reagan once said somebody that's with me 80% of the time is not my enemy,” Republican strategist Charlie Gerow said. “And John Fetterman has proven himself to be both a voice of conscience and a voice of common sense. That's why the people of Pennsylvania and folks nationally really like him. He's totally authentic.”
But in the current era of hyper-partisanship, even that 80% voting record makes him an outlier. No senator supported his or her party less than Fetterman did, according to CQ. By contrast, McCormick backed the GOP 99% of the time.
Fetterman’s breaks with his party have placed him in an awkward position with the voters of his state — one that might be unique in modern American politics.
Republicans approve of the Democrat’s job performance by a 77% to 12% margin, according to a Quinnipiac University poll released in July.
At the same time, he was underwater with Democrats, with 69% disapproving of the way he was handling his job and only 19% approving.
Overall, the poll found 48% of registered voters approved of Fetterman’s performance in office, with 41% disapproving.

But the partisan split over Fetterman that has emerged in recent polling does not mean he’d be a viable candidate among conservatives, Greenwood said. Just because most Republicans say they approve of the job he’s doing doesn’t mean they’d vote for him over a longtime Republican.
“I think the Republicans view him as kind of a useful tool right now, but one that they would easily [reject] for a real Republican,” Greenwood said.
U.S. Rep. Jeff Van Drew, R-N.J., who switched from the Democratic Party in 2019 after being threatened with a primary fight for opposing Trump’s first impeachment, said he briefly talked to Fetterman and offered to help if he wanted to become a Republican. But nothing came of it.
“I think he is truly a Democrat, but more of an old-school Democrat,” Van Drew said. “From everything he has said and indicated, he does not want to become a Republican, and I have to take him at his word. So I don't know if he's not going to run at all.
“Or if he's going to attempt to run in the Democratic primary, good luck with that.”
When Van Drew made his switch, his new party was eager to have him.
“I was welcomed in, first of all, because of my record,” he said. “I've always been generally a conservative, very pro-America.”
Many of Fetterman’s positions are anathema to the majority of Republican voters. He supports abortion rights and legal cannabis, opposed GOP efforts to impose new restrictions on registering and voting, and cast a ballot against Trump’s giant tax and spending law.

“There's no question there's a lot of votes and statements and policies that won't sit with some Republicans, so no question it would be a struggle to get Fetterman through a Republican primary,” Galko said.
“Where does he go? Does he roll a dice and just say, ‘I'm going to run, and let the chips fall where they may’? That's probably where it ends up,” Galko said.
Or he could follow the path of others who’ve angered their parties’ base voters in recent years — Republican Sen. Mitt Romney and Democratic Sens. Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema — and simply decline to run for reelection in a party that has turned on them.
Deluzio said Fetterman should finish out his term as a member of the party that nominated him.
“He should stay in the Democratic caucus, That's what the people of Pennsylvania elected him to be,” Deluzio said. “At its core, it comes back to what the voters expect and what you told the voters you would do. So I think there's no world where he should be switching caucuses. The people who sent him there sent him to be a Democrat.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.