WASHINGTON — A year after President Donald Trump and congressional Republicans enacted a massive tax and spending bill, Pennsylvanians are feeling its effects amid a debate on how big and beautiful the One Big Beautiful Bill actually was.

The legislation provided for $4.5 trillion in tax cuts, extending the reductions enacted during Trump’s first term while also reducing the taxes taken from tips, Social Security, new cars made in America and overtime pay. In fact, Republicans rebranded their legislation as the Working Families Tax Cuts after polls showed the measure was unpopular

“In its first year, the Working Families Tax Cuts put more money back into the pockets of hardworking Pennsylvania families, made historic investments in our nation’s children, gave a boost to our seniors, and strengthened Main Street businesses for years to come,” said Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Butler, who sits on the tax-writing House Ways and Means Committee.

But the measure also reduced spending on health care and nutrition programs by $1.4 trillion. The number of Pennsylvanians receiving what formerly were known as food stamps dropped by more than 10% from July 2025, when the bill was signed, to March 2026, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

Advertise with us

“If you ask most folks, ‘What have you seen Donald Trump as president do to affect your family budget?’ they point to the war in Iran and his trade wars,” said Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Fox Chapel.

“Then you lay on top the One Big Beautiful Bill, which has hurt people on health care and food assistance. That’s just a pretty clear record,” Deluzio said.

The debate over the effects of the law is taking place during the 2026 midterm elections that will decide which party controls Congress next year. Dissatisfaction with the tax law passed during the first Trump administration soured voters on the GOP and helped end the Republicans’ governing trifecta of the White House, Senate and House in the 2018 midterms.

The law passed last year was the party’s major response to address the economic concerns that Pennsylvania voters named as their top issue in last month’s Franklin & Marshall College Poll.

“I think the public is rightly tuned into their own pocketbooks, and are rightly tuned into the difficulties of affordability in the modern economy,” said Wesley Tharpe, senior adviser for state tax policy at the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities, a progressive research group.

Advertise with us

The Franklin & Marshall poll of registered Pennsylvania voters found that 47% said things were going in the wrong direction compared to 36% who said they were going in the right direction. By 47% to 14%, voters said they were worse off than when Trump signed the legislation into law, with 40% saying there was no difference.

Midterm elections traditionally are considered a referendum on the president, and the F&M poll showed only 29% rated Trump’s job performance as excellent or good. In addition, 51% gave Trump a failing grade on handling inflation, compared to just 5% who said he was doing an excellent job on the issue.

“When the public is in a foul mood and not very pleased with the direction of the country, the challenge of selling the positives of the big, beautiful bill becomes harder,” said Christopher Borick, director of the Muhlenberg College Institute of Public Opinion.

“In its first year, the Working Families Tax Cuts put more money back into the pockets of hardworking Pennsylvania families,” said Rep. Mike Kelly, R-Erie, who sits on the tax-writing House Ways and Means Committee. (Rod Lamkey, Jr. / Associated Press)

Kelly attributed the bill’s unpopularity to the fact that Americans didn’t see its benefits until this spring, when they were able to claim the new tax breaks and received bigger refunds.

“Every single advantage went to people that really needed help and needed to get more of their own money back, but you had to wait a year to see it,” Kelly said. “That’s when it becomes meaningful.”

Advertise with us

Still, Americans remain upset over the same issues that helped Trump defeat President Joe Biden in 2024 — the economy and inflation.

The inflation rate stood at 4.2% in May, compared to 3.0% in January 2025 when Trump took office. And the average price for a gallon of regular gas stood at $3.98, down from $4.46 last month but still up 18% from a year ago, according to AAA.

“As much as Republican Party would like — and the officeholders who are standing for re-election in the fall would like — the conversation to be about the benefits to the average consumer from the big, beautiful bill, that’s not what the national conversation is about right now,” said Lew Irwin, a political science professor at Duquesne University.

Rep. Glenn Thompson, R-Centre, said the country is still recovering from the Biden era. Prices spiked at $5.07 a gallon for regular gas in June 2022, the same month the inflation rate stood at 5.7%. (It would rise to 6.6% in September before beginning its decline.)

“That’s not an excuse, that’s kind of a reality,” Thompson said.

Advertise with us
“If you ask most folks, ‘What have you seen Donald Trump as president do to affect your family budget?’ they point to the war in Iran and his trade wars,” said Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Fox Chapel. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Through early May, Americans saw more and bigger refunds, according to the Internal Revenue Service. Almost 70% of filers who received a tax cut made less than $100,000. More than 7.5 million filers took advantage of the tax break on tips and more than 29 million saved taxes on their overtime pay, according to the U.S. Treasury Department.

But 72% of the tax breaks still went to the richest 20% of Americans, according to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, a progressive research group.

To pay for those tax cuts, the bill reduced federal funding for nutrition programs and health care programs, including Medicaid. The legislation imposed new reporting and eligibility requirements, and already fewer people are receiving assistance.

In the first seven months after the bill was signed into law, the number of Pennsylvanians receiving benefits under the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program fell by almost 200,000, according to the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities.

And the bill’s Medicaid cuts would leave 310,000 Pennsylvanians without health coverage and could cause 26 rural hospitals to close, according to Gov. Josh Shapiro’s office. 

Advertise with us

Shapiro spokeswoman Rosie Lapowsky criticized the “cruel budget bill” that would cut food assistance from those “who just need a little help feeding themselves and their families” and “result in over 300,000 Pennsylvanians losing health insurance, all to give the wealthiest Americans a tax cut.”

Kelly said the law was designed to root out waste. “We have an obligation to make sure that every single penny that we collect actually gets spent the right way,” he said.

The state’s hospitals already are feeling the impact of the tax law, according to Nicole Stallings, president and CEO of the Hospital & Healthsystem Association of Pennsylvania.

Rep. Glenn Thompson, R-Centre, said the country is still recovering from the Biden era. (Haraz N. Ghanbari / Associated Press)

Over the next decade, the state’s hospitals face a $4.5 billion cut to payments they receive from the federal government — payments that even now do not cover the full cost of providing health care, Stallings said.

“We can’t have healthy, vibrant, and economically competitive communities without financially stable hospitals,” she said.

Advertise with us

As for SNAP, the number of enrollees in Pennsylvania declined from 1.9 million last July, when Trump signed the legislation, to 1.7 million in March, according to the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities.

Thompson said no one who is eligible for SNAP will lose benefits, especially children.

“There are no cuts to any of that for people who are truly eligible,” Thompson said. “The biggest misinformation or lie that I hear from my Democratic friends is all the children that have been removed from SNAP. You know, the only reason they may have come off SNAP is because their families, their parents actually got a good-paying job and they’re in a better position now.”

In addition, states for the first time will have to share the costs of providing benefits to their residents. That would cost Pennsylvania $410 million a year, according to CBPP.

The law also requires the state to pay a greater share of the administration costs, adding an additional $120 million hit to the state treasury, according to the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services.

Advertise with us

“Deep cuts to Medicaid and SNAP are forcing families to navigate more red tape, threaten rural hospitals and nursing homes, and put health care and food assistance out of reach for millions,” said Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale.

“At a time when housing, groceries, and childcare are already stretching family budgets, our government should be lowering costs, not making life harder so billionaires can get another tax break,” Lee said.

“Deep cuts to Medicaid and SNAP are forcing families to navigate more red tape, threaten rural hospitals and nursing homes, and put health care and food assistance out of reach for millions,” said Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale. (Giuseppe LoPiccolo / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Democrats need to win just three GOP-held seats this fall to win a majority in the U.S. House, and a sweep of the four competitive Republican congressional seats in Pennsylvania would be more than enough to do it. In the Franklin & Marshall poll, voters said they preferred a generic Democratic congressional candidate over a generic Republican by 47% to 35%.

Deluzio said House Democrats will pledge to rewrite the tax law if they win back the majority.

“We will try to undo the worst of the worst,” he said. “It is something we should undo and replace with a fiscally responsible tax cut for hard-working Americans and a tax increase for the ultra-rich and corporations.”