In a stunning election in a deep-red state House district in southwestern Butler County, Democrat Brandon Dukes was leading Republican Scott Timko by a razor-thin margin Tuesday night, leaving the GOP in peril of losing a seat the party has held for decades.

The unexpectedly close special election to fill the vacant District 12 seat comes just months before Republicans across the state and country will try to hold onto crucial congressional and state legislative seats that will decide the balance of power in Washington and key battleground states — including Pennsylvania.

As of 10:30 p.m. Tuesday, Dukes held an 88-vote lead with all 27 precincts in the district reporting their results — a margin of just over half a percentage point in a race where more than 16,800 ballots were cast. The county has not yet tallied provisional ballots.

The ultimate victor in the race will serve the remainder of former Republican state Rep. Stephenie Scialabba’s term after Scialabba announced her resignation in March.

Advertise with us

Timko and Dukes are already set for a rematch in the November midterms when Scialabba’s term concludes and both candidates will be on the ballot again, vying to serve a full two years in Harrisburg.

“One election down, one election to go,” Dukes said in a statement. “We are still 70-odd days away from our statewide Election Day in November. Between now and then, I won’t take a single vote for granted — I will be out knocking doors and connecting directly with voters.”

Timko, in a brief speech to about two dozen supporters late Tuesday, didn’t outright concede the race to Dukes.

“Special elections sometimes produce special results,” Timko said Tuesday night. “This is not the result we wanted, but let’s not lose sight of the goal. That’s Nov. 3.”

Timko entered the race with huge structural advantages. Republicans outnumber Democrats in the district — an area covering the southwestern corner of the county — by almost 2 to 1.

Advertise with us

Just two years ago, Trump won the district by 18 percentage points, and in the same election, Scialabba trounced her Democratic opponent by 30 points.

In 2024, Trump carried all 27 precincts in the district. On Tuesday night, Dukes was leading in 15 of them.

“I am really shocked,” Claudia Timko, Scott’s mother, said late Tuesday night. “I felt very positive today, especially at the polls. It seemed like the people turning out for Scott was 2 to 1.”

She attributed the close race to Democrats' use of mail-in ballots, a method of voting that Republicans have attacked in recent years but that Democrats have used to rack up votes before election day.

The winner will also determine whether the GOP can keep the Democrats to a one-vote majority in the state House, or whether that majority will expand slightly for the first time in years.

Advertise with us

Ahead of the special election, Dukes and Butler County Democrats said they were confident they could pull an upset.

Days before the election, Dukes, who campaigned on bringing back infrastructure funding to the district, received an endorsement letter from former U.S. Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg through his Win the Era PAC.

“He will focus on making everyday life more affordable, strengthening public schools, and protecting hospitals from closing,” Buttigieg said in a news release last week. “We share a belief that good transportation policy creates a stronger economy — and I believe he has the experience and focus to reduce gridlock on Route 228 and give people a smoother commute.”

Dukes and Butler County Democratic Committee Chair Donald Vigliotti said that despite the disadvantage their party has in the county, they were encouraged by recent victories to flip formerly GOP-held state House and Senate seats elsewhere — including in Fort Worth, Texas, and Palm Beach County, Fla., this year.

They said Dukes’ own run for Cranberry Township supervisor last year also indicated that Tuesday’s race would be closer than expected after Dukes narrowly lost to Republican incumbent Bruce Hezlep, who won after securing just 50.6% of the vote.

Advertise with us

“I consider myself a canary in the coal mine,” Dukes said last week ahead of his race.

Timko described himself as a “true constitutional conservative” that is “dedicated to keeping this seat representing Butler County instead of Allegheny County and Harrisburg special interests.”

“Together we can fight inflation and outside special interests and protect life and our God-given constitutional rights, especially the Second Amendment,” Timko said in a quote posted on his campaign site.

Despite a contested primary in May that saw Timko edge out GOP candidate Ethan Nicholas by fewer than 250 votes for his party’s nomination, Republicans in the district ended up coalescing behind Timko to help him secure Scialabba’s seat for the next few months.

In Butler County, Republican Committee Chair Stacey Palmer predicted her party’s sheer voter registration advantage in the district would help Timko win both the special election and the November general election.

Advertise with us

Last week, Palmer said she was even more confident in Timko’s advantage in the midterms because, due to the late summer timing of the special election, she expected larger voter turnout in November because families will be less likely to be on vacation or busy with back-to-school preparations.

“Two-thirds of our voters as Republicans did not participate today,” Timko said. “It’s my job to reach out to these voters and make my case for the November election. I’m still optimistic.”

Despite the close race, Democrats were taking the victory lap Tuesday night.

“This is just the first of many exciting flips Democrats are fighting for in November,” PA House Democratic Campaign Committee Executive Director Madeline Zann said in a statement. “Voters are tired of Republicans’ chaos and their refusal to make changes for working families like raising the minimum wage and lowering our cost of living.”