On Tuesday, Democrat Brandon Dukes will face off against Republican Scott Timko in a special election in Butler County’s 12th State House District. It’s a race some are viewing as a political barometer for the region ahead of the midterms later this year.
The race is also a preview for a rematch between the two candidates vying to fill former Republican State Rep. Stephenie Scialabba’s seat for the remainder of her term after Scialabba resigned in late March to focus on her family.
No matter the results of the special election, Dukes and Timko will be required to square off again in the November general election for the full two-year term in the seat that the GOP has held for decades.
In Butler — where registered Republicans outnumber Democrats about two to one — conservatives said they have the sheer numbers to make sure the GOP holds the seat in the Democrat-controlled House.
That confidence extends past Tuesday’s special election.
“I’m confident that Scott Timko is going to win Tuesday,” Butler County Republican Committee Chairwoman Stacey Palmer said. “We just need Republicans to show up and vote … and I think that in the midterms, we’re going to have much higher Republican turnout, and Scott wins in November no matter what.”
Read More
Timko, a pilot and retired Air Force captain, won his party’s nomination for the seat in a tightly contested primary in May that saw him edge out Ethan Nicholas by fewer than 250 votes.
Timko’s campaign did not respond to an interview request, but his campaign website describes him as “a true constitutional conservative and dedicated to keeping this seat representing Butler County instead of Allegheny County and Harrisburg special interests.”
“Together we can fight inflation and outside special interests and protect life and our God-given constitutional rights, especially the Second Amendment,” Timko said in a quote included on his site.
Despite a primary that saw Republicans split on who should take Scialabba’s seat, Palmer said she expects voters who supported Nicholas will show up Tuesday to back Timko.
“There was not a lot of drama in the primary,” She said. “Most Republicans felt like both were good candidates so it wasn’t nasty by any stretch. Both candidates acted like gentlemen, and as a result, there was not any bad blood among Republicans.”
Although Republicans hold a significant edge in voter registration in the county, Palmer said the timing of the special election during the dog days of late summer — when families are preoccupied with vacations and back-to-school preparations — helps Democrats because they have been more likely to vote by mail.
During the May primary, Republicans cast about 5,000 more total votes than Democrats in Butler County, but Democrats cast 3,000 more mail-in ballots than Republicans.
“Republicans definitely have voter advantage, that part we know, but we also know that the Democrats are very good at their mail-in ballots,” Palmer said. “We’re working against that and trying to solve that.”
While Republicans hope to hold on to the state House seat, Butler County Democrats are optimistic that the special election will be the first step in flipping the seat and widening the majority they have in the state House.
Dukes, a construction loan administrator at TD Bank who lives in Cranberry, has campaigned, in part, on bringing back infrastructure funding, including for Route 228. On Friday, he received an endorsement from former U.S. Secretary of Transportation Pete Buttigieg through Buttigieg’s Win the Era PAC.
“I think having (an endorsement) from the former transportation secretary to the United States is a huge deal,” Dukes said.
Dukes said he also supports keeping public schools funded and increasing the state minimum wage.
Dukes said his run for Cranberry Township supervisor last year could be an indication that the political tide may be turning in the county. Dukes narrowly lost to Republican incumbent Bruce Hezlep, who won by securing 50.6% of the vote.
“It was a two-term Republican incumbent who was chair of the board and we denied him a 51% majority and I think that speaks volumes to where this district is going in terms of it becoming less red and more blue … and I feel like Tuesday’s results are going to reflect that,” Dukes said.
Dukes said Democratic victories to flip state House and Senate seats elsewhere in the country — including in Fort Worth, Texas, and Palm Beach County, Fla., this year — may spur move voters to turn out Tuesday despite the advantage Republicans have in Butler County.
Butler County Democrats share that hope.
“Throughout the country, we’re seeing more and more Democrats winning in pretty red areas, and I think that will signal to voters that this is the time that maybe we could see some change,” Butler County Democratic Committee Chairman Donald Vigliotti said.
Dukes said he recognizes that his race will put that to the test.
“I consider myself a canary in the coal mine,” he said.
While Republicans have long held the seat Dukes is seeking to flip, Vigliotti said he believes the GOP’s hold over the district has been weakening.
“I think this area is ripe for change,” Vigliotti said. “Maybe this area really isn’t as red as it was once thought to be. It seems like we may be turning a little more purple and we’re definitely seeing that in the Cranberry area.”
Ultimately, the results of Tuesday’s special election — namely how tight the race is — is expected to have larger implications on voters in the district come November, Dukes said.
‘If it’s a close victory or close loss to whoever, then I think there’s a better chance of either side picking up in November,” Dukes said. “But if it’s a blowout on either side, whoever wins or loses, it’ll be tougher to win in November. That’s just how I feel. ... This is a very different type of race being so close to the general [election].”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.