State Treasurer Stacy Garrity, the Republican nominee for governor, sat in the Butler County GOP headquarters in Cranberry on Tuesday, flanked by local officials to talk about an issue that is shaping politics from town councils to state governments to Congress.

The debate over data centers has turned neighborhoods around the commonwealth — and the nation — into political flashpoints as residents raise concerns about the immense amounts of water, land and power they demand to fuel the artificial intelligence boom.

As demand for AI spikes, regulations on the massive server farms that power the technology are still being written, and questions about how and where the facilities should be built are only growing more urgent.

All the while, new data center projects dotting the greater Pittsburgh region are moving forward.

Advertise with us

The debate over how to control their development has pitted Garrity — who has called for a full pause in their construction — against Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro, who has tried to balance billions in investments from tech giants with increasing worries from local residents who fear the projects will negatively impact their communities.

On Tuesday, Garrity accused the governor of being inconsistent.

“I know you know how incredibly difficult this situation has been, because of all the ambiguity and the flip-flops,” Garrity told the local officials. “And I want to be abundantly clear that I have had one position from the start on data center development. I don’t change depending on who my audience is.

“Josh Shapiro was the biggest cheerleader for data center development in Pennsylvania — until he wasn’t.”

Community pushback intensifying

The Shapiro campaign fired back in a statement that accused Garrity of being the one who has shifted positions on the issue.

Advertise with us

“Her long record of supporting completely unregulated data center development makes it clear that she just can’t be trusted,” the campaign statement said.

“Governor Shapiro has worked directly with community, labor, and environmental leaders to develop and propose some of the strongest data center regulations and standards of accountability in the entire country,” according to the statement.

Shapiro’s newly released Governor’s Responsible Infrastructure Development (GRID) standards call for data center developers to, among other things, create their own power — rather than drawing electricity from the broader grid and driving up consumer prices — and be transparent with communities about plans.

Under the proposal, developers would need to acquire GRID certification to access tax benefits around equipment purchases.

Garrity said that’s not enough. The standards in the GRID plan are “voluntary” she said.

Advertise with us

She said Shapiro is “failing” to lead and has demonstrated a “massive flip-flop” on data center development — from rolling out a red carpet, she said, to “pretending” to put up guardrails.

As governor, she said, she would pause all data center development until local governments and communities figure out a range of pressing questions — what the facilities would mean for them, whether they want them in their communities, and how to regulate them. The pause would not affect projects that are already in progress.

The debate over the past year, which has evolved alongside Garrity’s and Shapiro’s own approaches to the issue, has centered around striking a balance between providing opportunities in rural Pennsylvania and protecting those communities.

Constituents, for their part, are increasingly pushing back.

In Springdale Borough, people fought vehemently against an incoming data center, citing concerns over health risks from gas-powered generator pollution, 24/7 noise and spiking utility bills.

Advertise with us

In Big Beaver, residents and former racers are actively battling Las Vegas-based data center developer Switch’s proposal to build at the former Pitt Race racetrack in Wampum that shuttered last fall, saying they feared the depletion of natural resources in the bucolic community.

At the same time, industry leaders are making pushes of their own — including Pittsburgh’s tech community, which is calling on officials to hold off on any new rules for data centers until manufacturers weigh in.

Accusations of flip-flopping

Before the backlash against data centers coalesced into a potent political force, Garrity and Shapiro had praised the economic transformation the projects could bring to swaths of the state.

In September, Garrity said that rural areas of Pennsylvania were “perfect places to put data centers.”

“And you know what? Rural Pennsylvania largely would welcome it, because it’s jobs, it’s billions of dollars in economic opportunity for our communities that we desperately need,” Garrity said on the Dom Giordano Program, on AM 1210 WPHT.

Advertise with us

In June 2025, when announcing a $20 billion deal with Amazon to build data centers in the commonwealth, Shapiro said, “with this historic announcement, we’re creating opportunity for our workers, generating new revenue for our local communities, and ensuring the future of AI runs right through Pennsylvania.”

“Our team worked closely with local leaders and Amazon to land this deal, and we continue to be actively engaged on securing additional sites in Pennsylvania — helping them secure local support, developing the infrastructure needed to support more data centers, and ensuring our permitting processes move quickly and efficiently,” Shapiro said.

At the time, Garrity also praised the deal.

“Great news!” she wrote on X. “Amazon is investing $20 billion right here in Pennsylvania. This will not only bring historic investment into our commonwealth but also create thousands of jobs for Pennsylvanians.”

On Tuesday, however, Garrity criticized Shapiro’s Amazon deal as an attempt to “endear himself to [Jeff] Bezos in the leadup to the 2028 presidential primary election,” where Shapiro has emerged as a potential contender for the Democratic nomination.

Advertise with us

Garrity was adamant that her stance has not wavered.

“What I was specifically referring to, there are a lot of rural areas where there’s a lot of open areas, but they also have industrial sites and brownfield sites. Every single county does,” she said. “And so, no, my position hasn’t changed. I’ve learned a lot, I will say that, from these listening sessions.”

During those conversations, local firefighters have told her about the need for them to train for new types of emergencies because of the enormous amount of electrical equipment packed inside data centers. Local residents have told her they worry what will happen to the hulking structures if the technology changes and they become obsolete.

“As governor, I think it’s your responsibility … to be a cheerleader for your state, and you have to bring economic development in it,” Garrity said. “But again, you can’t do it in isolation, and you can’t do it in a silo, and you have to make sure that whoever it’s impacting, that they have a seat at the table.”