Protest signs are typically designed to communicate a simple idea in clear language. At their most effective, they become akin to brand names, like “Black Lives Matter.” More often, they’re forgettable slogans that signal allegiance to a cause more than anything substantive or original.
I’m not a fan of the genre, truth be told.
Which is I was so enthralled by a sign that appeared recently in the Post-Gazette. Held by 61-year-old Jane Steege, of Monaca, at a community session regarding a proposed Beaver County computing hub, it said, “Say NO to data centers — choose life!”
The relationship between the sign’s two clauses is not at all clear on a semantic level. If the opening phrase referred to abortion, for instance, the slogan would have an obvious meaning. But there is no such clear connection, on the surface, between rejecting data centers and “choosing life.”
And yet I, and I suspect a great many other people who read the sign, know exactly what it communicates. More accurately, we feel its meaning, which is difficult to describe in words beyond those right there on the sign.
But I’m going to try.
Read More
Overstated harms
First, let me say what the sign does not mean to me: It does not refer to “life” simply as the condition of being alive. Specifically, the threats of data centers to life-giving water — human, animal, plant — are significantly overstated.
The world’s biggest data centers only use the equivalent of a few seconds of the daily flow of the Ohio River at Pittsburgh. And the water used for cooling acres of computers isn’t annihilated: At worst it’s evaporated, where it re-enters the atmosphere and later returns as precipitation.
Concerns about data-center energy use leading to increased emissions from power generation (as well as backup diesel generators) have a more solid factual foundation. Further, the interminable white-noise hum that emanates from the computer warehouses is at best annoying and at worst disorienting.
Yet I think those who express such concerns are grasping for a more profound critique, or trying to articulate a deeper fear. And this is that data centers — whatever their quantifiable costs or benefits — are unnatural or even anti-natural.
Transcending limits
What human beings build reflects our sense of what we value and what it means to be human. For instance, I’m writing these words in a coffee shop across the street from the Benedum Center, which reflects a culture that values craftmanship and communion and which sees art as essential to a flourishing life and society.
Skyscrapers reflect the aspiration to overcome the limitations of being earth-bound — though their design can also manifest classical notions of form and proportion (that is, beauty) or modern notions of scale and utility (that is, power). Railroads and highways reflect the value of mobility and commerce but also, at the time of their first construction, contempt for the wilderness through which they passed.
So, what do data centers represent? Like skyscrapers and railroads, they represent the desire to exceed natural limits.
But now the limits being transcended are those of the mind rather than the body.
And it is the mind where human distinctiveness primarily resides. Transcending its limitations represents, or at least can represent, a rejection of humanity and our limits and responsibilities rather than an enhancement of what makes us special and of what makes life worth living.
This is what Jane Steege’s sign was getting at: The sprawling, formless, ravenous data center, which blights the landscapes that human beings are meant to steward, visibly and audibly represents a rejection of nature, including human nature, and not its elevation or ennobling.
It represents not a rejection of life simply speaking, but of the fullness of human life.
Choosing life
And yet the tragedy of Steege’s exhortation to “choose life” is that the choice has already been made for us. This is what the market and its makers have decided is “progress”: to maximize computing power to manufacture and distribute “intelligence” like a utility, as OpenAI’s Sam Altman put it.
If there is no data center in Big Beaver, there will be one — several, many — elsewhere. And those places will receive economic benefits, from construction and maintenance jobs to increased desirability for high-tech employers, while those who reject the data centers will still suffer the costs of anti-human “progress” just like everyone else.
This is why, while I strongly support data center regulations such as requiring builders to bring or build their own power, I am skeptical of policies that would exclude or seriously discourage them in Western Pennsylvania. This would do little if anything to reduce the costs we bear, while certainly reducing the benefits we receive.
I would prefer a world without massive data centers and the AI they enable, but that is not the world in which we live. So we have to make the best of it.
One way is to heed the call to “choose life” in our own lives. Focus on spending time, in-person, with friends and family. Go outside. Read books (actual books, preferably good ones). Endure hardship. Practice love.
And never forget that AI is a tool, nothing more.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Pittsburgh struggled to use ARPA funds to improve facilities for residents.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.