After President Donald Trump lost the 2020 U.S. presidential election, Pennsylvania’s Republican lawmakers spent $1.1 million for legal work on issues related to the outcome.

It was prompted by two situations:

• First, several Republican state lawmakers were subpoenaed in August 2022, around the same time the FBI was investigating the role of U.S. Rep. Scott Perry in efforts to overturn the election.

• And a GOP-led state Senate committee subpoenaed the Department of State for sensitive voter information, including driver’s license numbers, similar to the current national Department of Justice probe under the second Trump administration.

Advertise with us

None of the lawmakers involved in either effort responded to requests for comment for this story.

PennLive found these legal bills by submitting multiple public records requests. The bills were paid from a Senate account that is used for a wide range of expenses, such as office renovations, food and computer supplies.

The General Assembly makes information on the hiring of outside legal counsel — including who they hire, why and what the lawyers are paid — available only to those who file a Right-to-Know request.

Good government expert Craig Holman, of Public Citizen, said any expenditure of money that is designed to shape or influence public affairs should be automatically disclosed, because residents may not know how to ask for it through a public records request — or even know what to ask.

“So, for instance, like spending money to deal with the January 6th insurrection, that is a public matter that should be fully disclosed,” Mr. Holman said. “The public has a right to know how they’re being manipulated, essentially, by lawyers.”

Advertise with us

Federal grand jury investigation

During the same time the federal government was looking into Mr. Perry’s role in the Jan. 6 Capitol uprising, at least eight state Senate Republican lawmakers hired private counsel to represent them in connection with a federal grand jury subpoena. Most hired criminal defense attorneys.

Engagement letters — typically agreements describing the work for which a lawyer is being hired — were drawn up for attorneys to represent President Pro Tempore Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland County; Sen. Judy Ward, R-Blair; Sen. Kristin Phillips-Hill, R-York; Sen. Cris Dush, R-Centre; Sen. David Argall, R-Carbon; Sen. Devlin Robinson, R-Allegheny; and former senators Mike Regan, R-Cumberland , and John DiSanto, R-Dauphin.

Grand jury investigations are secret under federal law, so PennLive cannot confirm the reason for the subpoenas or the purpose of the investigation. Several sources at the time told PennLive the information being sought centered around Mr. Perry and efforts to change the outcome of the election, in which Joe Biden beat Trump.

Some engagement letters listed only “grand jury investigation” when describing the scope of work, but others, such as Sen. Devlin Robinson’s, specified a case number: “Grand Jury Subpoena #GJ2022080593449 in the D.C. United States District Court.” Two engagement letters referenced the same date: “federal grand jury subpoena issued to him on August 23, 2022.”

Combined legal fees for these eight lawmakers and the Republican caucus cost taxpayers $399,500.

Advertise with us

Taxpayers also paid $395,000 to hire a criminal defense attorney for Sen. Doug Mastriano, R-Franklin, in January 2023 related to a Jan. 6 grand jury investigation, according to his engagement letter.

Judy Ward had the second-highest legal fees after Ms. Mastriano from that period, with $102,700 billed for a “confidential matter with the United States Government.”

Senate Republican leader Kim Ward told PennLive in August 2022 that she did not receive an FBI subpoena. Less than a month later, she retained criminal defense attorney Robert Ridge from Clark Hill, for $70,800 in taxpayer dollars. Her contract only reads that it was in “Response to Grand Jury Investigation.”

The Department of Justice closed its investigation into efforts to overturn the 2020 elections after Trump took office for his second term.

Penn State law professor Stanley Brand was one of Mr. Perry’s lead lawyers during the same FBI investigation. He advocated for more transparency with the legal bills.

Advertise with us

“Over time, the interest that you’re trying to protect for confidentiality does fade,” Mr. Brand said. “You know, it’s not as compelling two years later.”

A fight over false claims of election fraud

Following Trump’s baseless claims that the 2020 election was rigged, a Republican-led state Senate committee spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on an “audit” into the state’s election results.

Mr. Mastriano, as acting chair of the rarely used Senate Intergovernmental Operations Committee in 2021, sent letters to three counties seeking election materials, even after two mandated state audits found Trump lost.

The Franklin County senator was ousted from his leadership position a month later, but Senate Republicans still pushed for a vaguely described audit that cost taxpayers $270,200 in consulting fees. (Votebeat reported in 2022 that it could not confirm whether the hired firm ever did any work.)

The committee also issued subpoenas to the Department of State for 9 million Pennsylvanians’ voter information, including their driver’s license numbers and last four digits of Social Security numbers. Then-Attorney General Josh Shapiro argued the subpoenas violated voters’ right to privacy.

Advertise with us

In early 2023, a Commonwealth Court said it wouldn’t compel the department to provide the voter data.

PennLive found Senate Republicans spent $312,600 on their failed efforts to get voter information. Senate Democrats spent $267,400 in public money fighting the release of the data.

Senate Republican leaders did not respond to requests for comment.

Christina Hartman of Common Cause, a good-government group, said she doesn’t understand why Pennsylvanians footed the bill.

“So on one hand, I want my officials to have the ability to do such a thing if something was actually wrong,” she said. “But we’ve known that there’s very, very few instances of fraud, so it feels like a very unnecessary thing and a very politically motivated expenditure.”