WASHINGTON — Years after he railed against voter ID requirements as “insidious and unnecessary,” U.S. Sen. John Fetterman’s comments this week that it’s not “unreasonable to show ID just to vote” were quickly celebrated by Republicans making an aggressive push for national election reforms.

“Bravo!” Elon Musk wrote in one of a half-dozen posts amplifying Mr. Fetterman’s message to his 234 million followers.

“[Democrats] hate that guy now. They’re mad at him because he says, ‘I think you should probably have ID to vote,’” the podcaster Joe Rogan said to his millions of listeners Tuesday.

As House Republicans prepared to pass the SAVE America Act to his chamber, Mr. Fetterman said his comments on Fox News over the weekend may have been taken out of context.

Advertise with us

In an interview with the Post-Gazette, he stressed that he did not say that he would support the bill, which is an expansive effort to require proof of citizenship during voter registration and photo ID during voting, limit registration by mail and purge voter rolls more frequently, among other measures. It passed the House by a vote of 218 to 213 on Wednesday, with one Democrat joining all Republicans in supporting it.

Mr. Fetterman said the changes to curtail mail-in registration were “a nonstarter” for him. Even if he were to vote for the bill, he said, it’s almost certain to die in the Senate because it won’t win the necessary 60 votes.

Still, the Pennsylvania Democrat reiterated that he was not opposed to voters showing ID at polling places.

He said the idea made sense to him even when he was lieutenant governor and running for U.S. Senate but that he framed his comments then “out of deference” to then-Gov. Tom Wolf.

Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, vetoed Republican lawmakers’ election reform package in 2021, partially because it included what he called “extremist” voter ID requirements. Mr. Fetterman, who was running for the Democratic nomination for Senate at the time, repeatedly voiced his opposition.

Advertise with us

Mandatory voter ID is “insidious and unnecessary,” he said in a 2021 speech to Texas Democrats after the veto and at a time when Texas Republicans were pushing new voting restrictions.

Republicans, he said in an interview a few months later, were “ruthless” in their pursuit of “voter suppression” policies.

“They understand that at any given time there’s tens of thousands of Pennsylvanians who typically are on the poorer side and are people of color that are less likely to have their ID at any one given time,” Mr. Fetterman told the progressive podcaster Brian Tyler Cohen in December 2021. “It’s a very insidious and effective strategy that they’re employing.”

The then-lieutenant governor was referring to lawsuits and studies that claimed many voters would face barriers to voting under laws that require additional forms of identification.

In social media posts that year, he specifically cited a court case that struck down a 2012 Pennsylvania law mandating voters show a state-approved photo ID to cast a ballot. Mr. Fetterman pointed out that state officials at the time had said about 9% of voters, totaling more than 700,000 people, did not have photo identification from the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation.

Advertise with us

During a renewed nationwide push for such laws after President Donald Trump’s false claims that the 2020 election was packed with fraud, one survey found 9% of all U.S. adults — nearly 21 million people — did not have a nonexpired driver’s license. Another 12%, or 28.6 million people, had a nonexpired license that did not have both their current address and name.

More than a quarter of Black adult citizens and Hispanic adult citizens did not have a license with their current name or address, making them disproportionately affected by voter ID laws, according to the survey from the University of Maryland’s Center for Democracy and Civic Engagement.

The survey has been cited recently by groups opposed to the SAVE America Act because of the legislation’s focus on proof of citizenship.

About 21.3 million people “cannot readily access documentary proof of citizenship (DPOC), either because they do not have it at all or because they could not access it easily if needed,” the survey found. About 2% of voting-age American citizens lacked any form of DPOC.

“This means 3.8 million voting-age American citizens do not have a birth certificate, passport, naturalization certificate, or a certificate of citizenship,” the survey stated. “This disproportionately affects marginalized racial and ethnic groups, as 3% of People of Color lack any form of DPOC, compared to 1% of White Americans.”

Advertise with us

Though Mr. Fetterman highlighted those kinds of disproportionate impacts before his 2022 election, he appeared to dismiss other Democrats’ similar concerns this week.

“It’s not Jim Crow 2.0,” he told the Post-Gazette.

According to the Campaign Legal Center, a nonpartisan Washington-based organization, the additional requirements in the SAVE America Act would “silence millions of Americans by creating new barriers to voter registration,” including for people of color and married people who have changed their names.

Incidents of noncitizens voting are also rare and already illegal, according to the Bipartisan Policy Center, a nonprofit think tank in Washington. Many state election offices verify voter citizenship through the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services’ Systematic Alien Verification for Entitlements program. Noncitizen voters accounted for just 0.04% of verification cases, and the actual rate “may be even smaller than this data suggests,” according to the center.

Maureen Grosheider, a past president of the League of Women Voters of Greater Pittsburgh, said the percentage of noncitizens voting was “miniscule,” raising requestions about the purpose of the legislation. She said the documentation requirements in the bill could pose problems in a variety of situations — like when married women change their name but need their birth certificate to register, if a senior citizen no longer drives and doesn’t have an active driver’s license, or if a family loses their documents in a natural disaster.

Advertise with us

“Those are the kinds of things that the League would be very concerned about,” Ms. Grosheider said.

‘Once again, we agree’

Still, polls have found voter ID requirements are widely popular among the electorate.

U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick, a Pennsylvania Republican, posted on social media his support for the new legislation Tuesday alongside an image of a survey showing 95% of Republicans and 71% of Democrats favor requiring a photo ID to vote.

“I support the #SAVEAmerica Act, a straightforward bill that ensures only American citizens can register to vote, and requires every state to mandate photo ID in order to vote in elections,” he wrote.

Advertise with us

Mr. McCormick also highlighted Mr. Fetterman’s public comments — saying on social media that it was another area where, “once again, we agree.”

The bipartisan duo have said often that Pennsylvania’s narrowly divided electorate means they have to appeal to voters on both sides of the aisle. For Mr. Fetterman, that’s culminated in occasionally high-profile moments in which he’s bucked his party and refrained from criticizing Trump, costing him support in polls and, seemingly, campaign donors along the way.

“Just trying to call balls and strikes,” he said on Fox News this week, echoing a phase he’s used in many of those party-defying moments. “I do not believe it’s radical or extreme to just produce an ID to vote.”

Asked by the Post-Gazette about his previous statements opposing that very idea, Mr. Fetterman did not say explicitly what form of voter ID requirements he would support now, though he suggested he was open to the concept.

“It’s a strange hill for Democrats to die on,” he said.