HARRISBURG — State leaders tried and failed in 2025 to create a law intended to disrupt a vicious and heartbreaking cycle of hospital purchases and closures across Pennsylvania, but negotiations to get it done in 2026 are underway.

Recent hospital closures that occurred following a merger, acquisition or change of ownership include Sharon Regional Medical Center in Mercer County, Heritage Valley Kennedy in Allegheny County, and Crozer Chester Medical Center in Delaware County. Sharon Regional later reopened under a different owner.

A Pennsylvania Health Access Network analysis found at least 32 hospitals have fully closed since 2004 and that 1 in 3 hospital mergers and acquisitions lead to a full or partial closure.

“We know that we have a real crisis,” said state Rep. Dan Frankel, D-Squirrel Hill, who chairs the House Health Committee.

Advertise with us

Only three scheduled voting session days in Harrisburg remain for the Senate and two for the House before the holidays. But both Mr. Frankel and Sen. Frank Farry of Bucks County, a Republican who heads a key committee in his chamber, said negotiations on a bill intended to address the crisis are ongoing.

The bill would give the attorney general oversight responsibilities in for-profit or private equity transactions involving health care facilities. Gov. Josh Shapiro, a Democrat, publicly supported it. After some amendments were made it passed the House in June and since then has been awaiting action in the Senate.

Part of the reason, Mr. Farry said, is the monthslong state budget debacle that ended Nov. 12, and a tangentially associated argument in Harrisburg about short-term funding for transit agencies.

Those things “took a lot of the oxygen out of the room” and “derailed it [from] coming to a conclusion,” Mr. Farry said.

Asked about the hospital closing crisis, a spokesperson for Mr. Shapiro, Kayla Anderson, pointed to $10 million in hospital stabilization funding that was included in the new budget, and Mr. Shapiro’s pursuit of money from a specialized federal fund to support health care in rural communities.

Advertise with us

“The governor remains steadfast in his commitment to bringing meaningful, long-term changes to the health care industry and ensuring hospitals in every community remain open and accessible when Pennsylvanians need them,” Ms. Anderson said.

The hospital where the oldest son of Democratic Rep. Lisa Borowski of Delaware County was born, Crozer Chester, was the setting for a May news conference where Mr. Shapiro and others advocated for passage of the bill that would bring the attorney general in on proposed hospital transactions. A private equity firm closed the hospital and others, creating health care chaos in the region.

“We want to make sure that what happened with Crozer Chester doesn’t happen again,” Ms. Borowski said on Tuesday.

Giving the attorney general review powers in certain proposed health care transactions, she said, would show that state leaders are committed to improving health care – a part of society so riddled with problems that trying to legislate on them feels like “a game of whack-a-mole.”

Her bill would give the attorney general review power to determine if transactions are in the public interest. In its current form, the bill calls for reviews not only of for-profit hospital transactions but also those involving nursing homes.

Advertise with us

Mr. Farry chairs the Senate Institutional Sustainability & Innovation Committee, which is considering Ms. Borowski’s bill. He believes nursing home transactions should be dealt with separately, perhaps in a different bill.

“It adds a whole other layer of people coming to the table with their concerns,” Mr. Farry said. “Hospitals and nursing homes are two separate things.”

Mr. Frankel said including “long-term” health care facilities like nursing homes is the “primary issue of contention” in the negotiations. It’s possible, he said, that a compromise will be reached.

Another question in the negotiations has been whether to include in the bill a ban on sale-leaseback arrangements. Mr. Frankel said that in what has become a pattern, private-equity interests purchase the land occupied by a hospital, lease the land back to the hospital at a “predatory rate,” and then take advantage of the situation when the hospital goes bankrupt.

Yet another wrinkle is whether to address only transactions involving for-profit entities or also those involving nonprofits.

A spokesperson for Pennsylvania Health Access Network, Patrick Keenan, said, “Regardless of the corporate structure, Pennsylvania needs to be prepared to respond to the next wave of hospital transactions and mergers.”