As state Treasurer Stacy Garrity ramps up her campaign to replace Gov. Josh Shapiro — who hasn’t announced a 2026 re-election bid yet — another Republican voice in Harrisburg continues to criticize not only the Democratic governor but the state GOP.

State Sen. Doug Mastriano, the Adams County conservative who lost to Mr. Shapiro in 2022 by almost 15 percentage points, repeated his frustration last week with the early Republican Party endorsement of Ms. Garrity, which came about a month after she launched her bid in August. 

“I’m really sick and tired of it — why do we have a primary, then?” the senator told Pittsburgh-based radio host John Fredericks this past week. “We all like Stacy, it’s irrelevant who the person is. The factor is, now the weight of the party, all the county chairs … basically if you don’t get in line [behind Ms. Garrity], we’re going to push you out.”

Mr. Mastriano, who told the Post-Gazette this summer he was “leaning towards” running but had not made a final decision, said his concerns were not about his potential candidacy, but about fairness. 

Advertise with us

He claimed a more open, drawn-out contest between potential primary candidates could have fired up Republicans across the state, giving them a better chance next year of defeating a popular governor allegedly backed by “money from Hollywood.”

“This just pisses off the grassroots,” he said. “There’s no enthusiasm.”

State party leaders and strategists dispute Mr. Mastriano’s take on the GOP endorsement.

“The endorsement process was completely transparent and open to any interested Republican,” state GOP spokesman James Markley said Friday. “Potential candidates were invited to participate in regional caucus meetings and the full meeting of the [Pennsylvania] Republican State Committee this past September. Candidates interested in the position had the ability to throw their name into the ring.” 

Mr. Markley added that Ms. Garrity was endorsed by the full elected body of State Committee representatives “from every corner of the commonwealth.”

Advertise with us

“Since that endorsement, we've seen complete unity with Treasurer Garrity and the State Committee body,” he said.

Mr. Mastriano cited a recent Quinnipiac University poll of more than 1,500 Pennsylvania voters that suggested his favorability is currently stronger than Ms. Garrity’s, with 73% of respondents saying they have not yet heard enough about her. 

“Most people in the state really don’t know who she is,” he said. “She’s not going to have the grassroots working for her.”

Mr. Mastriano’s favorability was well below Mr. Shapiro’s, according to the poll. Fifty-eight percent said they had a favorable view of the governor, compared to 23% for Mr. Mastriano and 13% for Ms. Garrity. Sixty percent of voters said they approve of Mr. Shapiro’s performance. That marks the governor’s highest approval rating since Quinnipiac began tracking him in June of 2023.

The state senator, who has shared over social media several AI-generated posts lambasting the governor over the long-delayed state budget, also told Mr. Fredericks that Mr. Shapiro “doesn’t care as long as his poll numbers are good.”

Advertise with us

On social media Thursday, Mr. Mastriano criticized the governor for heading out-of-state to campaign for other Democrats this weekend while the state budget remained at an impasse. 

A spokesman for the governor’s campaign team declined to comment.

“I’m not going to get into their parlor games,” Mr. Shapiro said after Ms. Garrity teased a run this summer. “I’m going to focus on doing my job.”

The Garrity campaign did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

But this past week, she mocked Mr. Shapiro’s national profile and news of the governor’s memoir coming in January. Her campaign team shared satirical book covers seeking to tie Mr. Shapiro to former President Joe Biden and his policies.

Advertise with us

Republican and Democratic analysts alike said the early endorsement of Ms. Garrity wasn’t surprising, particularly as the GOP looks to reverse the tough defeat of 2022. They also said a similar move helped Republican U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick in his successful bid against longtime Democratic Sen. Bob Casey last year.  

“I sense a lot of support and enthusiasm for Treasurer Garrity,” Christopher Nicholas, a Republican consultant based in Harrisburg, said this week. “Because she’s not Doug Mastriano.”

Mr. Nicholas said Ms. Garrity will raise more funds than Mr. Mastriano and won’t rely on Facebook live for campaigning. He cited Ms. Garrity surpassing Mr. Shapiro’s 2022 record for most votes cast for a statewide candidate, at more than 3.5 million when she won her second term last year. 

Mr. Nicholas added that he’s “not taking anything away from Shapiro’s political might,” but “she’s won two statewide elections — that’s a pretty good background.”