Some Pittsburgh-area school districts are temporarily withholding payments to charter schools during the state budget impasse, a move that attempts to level the playing field as districts scramble to ensure learning continues despite a lack of funding.
So far, Jeannette, Monessen and Norwin school districts, all in Westmoreland County, as well as Southmoreland, in Westmoreland and Fayette counties, have temporarily stopped payments to charter schools during the 100-plus day impasse.
Districts are required to pay tuition for students who live in their areas but who attend charter schools, payments that often add up to millions of dollars.
The decisions come because districts are operating without state subsidies as the budget fight continues in Harrisburg, meaning they’re missing out on vital payments. That has forced many districts to take steps such as implementing hiring freezes, delaying contracts and cutting non-essential spending.
And now, districts are turning to charter school payments as they work to keep schools running.
“We don’t have a crystal ball to know when they’re going to pass the budget,” said Stephanie Geyer, vice president of the Southmoreland school board. “So in the best interest of just being prepared for when the time comes, to get the ball rolling is the best measure.”
Read More
Many local initiatives mirror what’s happening statewide.
In Lehigh County and parts of Northampton County, the Bethlehem Area, Northern Lehigh and Salisbury Township school districts are withholding funds, The Morning Call newspaper reported. The Northampton Area School District in Northampton County made a similar decision this month, the Lehigh Valley Press reported.
And this isn’t the first time districts have withheld charter payments. During the 2015 state budget impasse — when a budget did not take effect until March 2016 despite a June 30, 2015, deadline — school districts also withheld funds.
That led some charter schools to request payments from the state through gaming tax relief funds, the Centre Daily Times reported. But the payments were ultimately canceled until the impasse was resolved.
“I think it is called survival,” Sherri Smith, executive director of the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators, said in an email. “Our districts are running out of funds to keep their schools open and to educate our students.”
An official with the Pennsylvania Coalition of Public Charter Schools and a spokesperson for the Commonwealth Foundation, a Harrisburg-based conservative-libertarian think tank that advocates for school choice, did not immediately respond to emails seeking comment regarding the delayed payments.
At Jeannette, a district of 930 students, administrators decided to withhold payments earlier this year, Superintendent Matthew Jones said. The district budgeted $2 million for cyber charter schools this year.
“In Jeannette we understand that we’re committed to paying our shares required by the law for the cyber charter tuition. … It’s more of a moral obligation to the students that we have in our district right now,” Mr. Jones said.
He noted that the cyber charters will be paid the tuition once the budget is passed.
In addition to temporarily withholding charter payments, Jeannette officials have stopped discretionary spending. And the district has asked staff to refrain from participating in professional development to lessen costs.
Norwin, a district of more than 5,000 students, said in a statement that withholding charter school payments is “a temporary measure to maintain our own financial stability, and to ensure charter schools also feel the impact of the state’s inaction. Our intent is to pay the withheld amounts once state funding is restored.”
The Monessen City School District began withholding payments last month. The district of 660 students spends $2 million on the payments out of an $18 million budget, Superintendent Robert Motte said.
“We just thought it was a cost-cutting measure because of the budget impasse, and it costs us a pretty significant amount,” Mr. Motte said. “So they're just going to have to wait.”
The district has already pulled $2.5 million from its $5 million fund balance to cover costs during the impasse. If the impasse continues a couple of more weeks, the district will consider pausing field trips and other activities.
“The state needs to do something with these charter bills. … Somehow the funding for schools should be equitable, in my opinion,” Mr. Motte said. “I feel it's not. But the charter schools, it's a big, big number in our budget.”
At Southmoreland, school directors passed a resolution this month saying officials will withhold charter school payments until state funding is restored.
According to the resolution, current law requires districts to pay charter schools regardless of whether a state budget is passed, “placing an inequitable and unsustainable financial burden on school districts.”
Because of that, the resolution says, “it is both fair and reasonable that charter schools share in the impact of the state’s failure to pass a budget to the same extent as school districts.”
The resolution stemmed from a September conference that Superintendent Jason Boone attended in the Lehigh Valley, where he heard that several districts were considering the measure. He presented the idea to other Westmoreland County superintendents and to his school board, which was responsive to the idea.
“With us sending it to the governor and representatives of the Legislature, we're hoping to provide some more pressure as to try to get this done for the sake of all kids,” Mr. Boone said.
In addition to withholding charter payments, Southmoreland also cut all district spending that’s not critical. If the impasse lasts another two months, Southmoreland may consider program cuts or furloughs. The district may also consider a loan, Ms. Geyer, the school director, said.
“We want to just be sure that our students are educated that are in our buildings, because it's not their fault that the state can't get their affairs in order,” Ms. Geyer said. “They shouldn't be affected by that at all.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.