WASHINGTON — Tens of thousands of Western Pennsylvanians in both Republican and Democratic counties could lose Medicaid coverage or federal food assistance if President Donald Trump’s sweeping tax and spending bill becomes law, according to a review of state data and warnings from Democrats in Harrisburg and on Capitol Hill.
In the five congressional districts spanning the region — three represented in the House by Republicans and two by Democrats — nearly 800,000 are covered by Medicaid and more than 555,000 receive benefits through the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), according to state Department of Human Services figures as of April.
More than 118,000, spread almost evenly across those districts, could lose their health insurance coverage due to changes and cuts to Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act, according to estimates in a report released this week by Democrats on the Joint Economic Committee, which cited nonpartisan analysis by the Congressional Budget Office.
Trump’s so-called “big beautiful bill,” which narrowly passed the House along party lines earlier this week and is being scrutinized by senators as of Friday afternoon, shifts some of SNAP’s costs to states, and expands work, education or service requirements for both SNAP and Medicaid.
Proponents, including Reps. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, Mike Kelly, R-Butler and Glenn Thompson, R-Centre, say the bill will blunt wasteful spending and fraud in those programs.
But state officials and Democrats nationwide, including Reps. Chris Deluzio of Aspinwall, Summer Lee of Swissvale and Sen. John Fetterman, say the bill will hurt low-income Americans already struggling to pay medical bills and put food on the table.
Read More
The potential cuts could particularly impact rural areas, where about two dozen Keystone State hospitals that bank on payments through Medicaid are grappling to stay open.
Gov. Josh Shapiro says the bill puts Medicaid coverage at risk for more than 300,000 Pennsylvanians.
“After a decade of our hard work to reduce the number of uninsured Pennsylvanians by nearly 50%, we will go backwards and 10% of our Medicaid population will lose coverage and become uninsured,” he said in a statement Thursday. “This will raise health care costs for all Pennsylvanians – including those with private insurance.”
The governor, who called it a “bad bill” with negative and lasting impacts across the state, added that 25 rural hospitals in Pennsylvania are operating on a deficit as they rely “significantly on Medicaid.”
“This bill would put more strain on them and threaten the closure of hospitals in our rural communities,” he said.
Mr. Shapiro also said the bill would shift $1 billion in food assistance costs to the state budget, which is simply not doable. That means 140,000 Pennsylvanians “could lose access to assistance they need,” he said.
Just Harvest, a nonprofit combating hunger in Allegheny County, said this week that even a minimum 5% shift of SNAP’s cost to states would amount to “billions of dollars collectively pulled from state budgets.”
That could lead to cuts in other programs and agencies that are already strapped and understaffed, and weaken the program’s ability to withstand recessions.
Mr. Fetterman, who’s made headlines in recent months for his openness to working with the Trump administration and criticizing his own party, delivered some of his sharpest critique of Republicans in an organizing and fundraising email focused on the bill Friday.
“We won’t sugarcoat this: if the GOP budget passes the Senate, it’s estimated that over 10 million Americans will lose their health insurance,” he said.
The senator added that the cuts could force rural hospitals to shutter, make ER wait times even longer, evict seniors from nursing homes and increase premiums for millions of families.
“Republicans are shamelessly working to trade away a lifeline for Americans just so the richest people in America can get even richer,” he said.
Supporters tout the bill’s extension of Trump’s 2017 tax cuts for individuals and businesses, a $500 bump to the $2,000 child tax credit, phasing out Biden administration clean energy tax breaks, boosts to border and Pentagon spending, and temporary tax breaks on tips, overtime and car loan interest.
The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office said the bill would see household resources increasingly shrink through 2033 among the country’s lowest earners, “mainly as a result of losses of in-kind transfers, such as Medicaid and SNAP.” But resources would increase for more wealthy Americans because of reductions in taxes, CBO said.
CBO estimated more than 8 million could lose healthcare coverage over a decade as a result of the bill.
The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities noted last year that the 2017 tax cuts were “skewed to the rich,” with the top 1% of households receiving an average cut of more than $60,000 in 2025 compared to less than $500 for households in the bottom 60%, according to estimates from the Tax Policy Center, a nonpartisan think tank.
While the White House touted deficit reduction through $1.6 trillion in mandatory savings worked into the bill, CBO estimates an overall “increase in the federal deficit of $3.8 trillion attributable to tax changes, including extending provisions of the 2017 tax act.”
A handful of conservative Republicans in both the House and Senate have expressed concerns about the bill’s potential for increasing the deficit. And some Republican senators, including Josh Hawley of Missouri, Susan Collins of Maine, Jerry Moran of Kansas and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska want changes to the Medicaid cuts, as they share concerns with Democrats about the potential hit to rural hospitals.
In Mr. Reschenthaler’s 14th District, which spans Fayette, Greene, Washington, Indiana, Westmoreland, and Somerset Counties, almost a quarter of residents — 179,398 — are covered by Medicaid, according to state data and the latest U.S. Census Bureau figures from 2023. More than 127,000 receive SNAP benefits in the 14th.
Similarly in Mr. Kelly’s district, which stretches from Butler County up to Erie County, and Ms. Lee’s, which covers much of Allegheny County and part of Westmoreland County, almost a quarter of residents — more than 170,000 in each — are covered by Medicaid. More than 128,000 receive SNAP assistance in Mr. Kelly’s district, 121,000 in Ms. Lee’s.
Ms. Lee said Thursday that, “the oligarchy is alive and well, and it’s in the reconciliation package Republicans just passed. There goes access to your healthcare, food assistance, housing, and so much more. All to give billionaires a tax cut.”
In Mr. Thompson’s 15th District, which covers more than a dozen counties, 146,388 are covered by Medicaid, about 19% of residents, while 98,908 receive food assistance.
Mr. Deluzio, of the 17th District encompassing Beaver County and part of Allegheny County, represents more than 121,000 covered by Medicaid and almost 79,000 who participate in SNAP.
“The Republican Tax Scam Bill that was just rammed through and passed by a single vote would rip away healthcare from thousands of Western Pennsylvanians to fund tax giveaways to the richest people who have ever lived,” Mr. Deluzio said in a post on X. “This fiscally reckless bill would saddle us with trillions in debt and make so many sicker and poorer.”
Mr. Kelly said in a statement that Republicans, by passing the package in the House this week, fulfilled a promise to deliver tax relief.
“This legislation will strengthen working families and small businesses in Pennsylvania and across the United States,” he said. “We are building on the success of the 2017 Tax Cuts & Jobs Act and we are making sure these pro-growth tax policies will benefit generations to come," he said.
Mr. Reschenthaler, the chief deputy whip, said the “landmark legislation” fulfilled a “once-in-a-generation opportunity to deliver the largest tax cut for the working class and provide the largest border security investment in history. Simply put, this bill is pro-worker, pro-family, and pro-small business.”
Speaking on the House floor this week, Mr. Thompson, who chairs the House Agriculture Committee, described SNAP as a critical safety net. But he said it must function as Congress intended — “as a temporary bridge for those in need, not a permanent system of dependency.”
He noted that since 2019, SNAP spending had risen from $60 billion annually to $110 billion, while enrollment has grown from 36 million to 42 million. Work requirements that previously garnered bipartisan support have been sidestepped by previous executive actions and state waivers, Mr. Thompson said.
Americans between 18 and 54 who are able to work and don’t have dependents are already required to work, volunteer or take part in a training program to participate in SNAP. The bill expands the work requirement to those up to 65 years old, and to parents without children younger than 7, the Associated Press reported.
“States are mismanaging the program to the tune of nearly $13 billion annually in erroneous payments,” Mr. Thompson said. “Most states are out of compliance with basic application timelines, forcing vulnerable families to wait months for help. Our measures correct this course.”
Post-Gazette staff writer Jimmy Cloutier contributed to this report.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.