HARRISBURG — When Gov. Josh Shapiro takes to the podium in the ornate House chamber for his state budget address Tuesday, he’ll face the daunting task of charting a course for Pennsylvania in a rapidly evolving political environment shaped by the most pressing financial challenges his administration has confronted.

It will be Mr. Shapiro’s third budget address, and the first since he emerged last summer as a top-tier contender for vice president on the Democratic ticket. His status as one of just three finalists cemented his place as a national leader in a party that’s searching for a new direction.

With a re-election campaign looming, and a potential White House run in 2028, Mr. Shapiro’s viability on the national stage will be tested over the coming months as the state confronts a series of challenges that the governor is expected to address Tuesday.

In a major court decision two years ago, the state’s basic education funding system was declared unconstitutional. The needs of mass transit systems in urban areas and aging transportation infrastructure are pressing. At the same time, communities statewide — including Pittsburgh — are clamoring for economic development aid to counter the lingering effects of the pandemic.

Advertise with us

Mr. Shapiro also faces a financial situation where the state is spending more money than it is bringing in — a structural deficit that could lead the government to spend down its reserves to provide vital services.

The most pressing topic for Mr. Shapiro is energy and electricity.

In just the past week, the state’s top utility regulator predicted looming cost spikes, Mr. Shapiro reached an agreement in his lawsuit against the region’s power grid organization, and he separately announced his own energy plan during an event at Pittsburgh International Airport.

Meanwhile, the political playing field has shifted dramatically. After having a fellow Democrat in the White House during his first two years, Mr. Shapiro must adjust to the second presidency of Republican Donald Trump, who won an election in which Republicans made strong showings.

The new Trump administration is threatening trillions in spending cuts that could have a drastic effect on the state’s finances, because agencies that lose federal funding could turn to state government for help.

Advertise with us

“Really reckless and really dangerous” is how Mr. Shapiro described the Trump administration’s implementation last week of a freeze in federal spending on some programs. The chaotic situation led to a temporary halt in Pennsylvania online access to major federal-state programs — and Mr. Shapiro pointed out that about one-third of the money Pennsylvania spends comes from Washington, D.C.

“He obviously won the election,” Mr. Shapiro said of Trump. “He has every right to put his views forward. He has every right to try and change the scope of federal programs. I would just encourage him as he does that to remember that when you make a change like that, it has an impact on people in our states.”

The brief freeze — announced by the Trump administration Tuesday and rescinded Wednesday — sent local government and nonprofit officials scrambling to figure out what programs would be able to survive, and it kicked off fears across the state that vital services would be slashed.

State Rep. Scott Conklin, D-Centre, said he would like to hear Mr. Shapiro deliver “calm, stabilizing remarks” after the experience of the past week.

In Harrisburg, whatever spending plan Mr. Shapiro puts forward will have to be carefully shepherded through the rocky politics of a closely divided Legislature.

Advertise with us

Republicans control the Senate. In the House, Democrats control the chamber, but the recent death of Rep. Matt Gergely, D-Allegheny, left the chamber in a voting tie at 101-101. That means that, at least until after the March 25 special election that will fill the vacant seat, either party will need at least one vote from the other side to pass a bill.

A Republican House member, Rep. Russ Diamond of Lebanon County, said he hopes Mr. Shapiro’s address Tuesday will show “he was paying attention in November, when the citizens of Pennsylvania said they want efficient government.” More specifically, Mr. Diamond said residents want “no big spending ideas, no huge expansion of government.”

One key player in the coming budget negotiations, Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman, R-Indiana, said what he wants to hear most from Mr. Shapiro is an acknowledgement that the state spends far more than it takes in. That structural deficit has been pegged at billions of dollars by the state Independent Fiscal Office.

On energy, Mr. Pittman disputed Mr. Shapiro’s claim that his deal with the power grid operator, PJM Interconnection, would save consumers $21 billion. 

“There is fallacy in everything the governor has said” about the agreement, Mr. Pittman said. “The reality is that electricity bills are going to go up the next two years.”

Advertise with us

But Mr. Pittman said he found some elements of Mr. Shapiro’s brand-new energy plan — dubbed “Lightning” — intriguing. Other parts, Mr. Pittman said, will cost consumers more money.

While deepening partisan divisions have led to intractable disagreements on key issues in recent years, Senate Minority Leader Jay Costa of Allegheny County, in an interview earlier this month, expressed optimism that the parties can come together this year to meet the obvious challenges that are bearing down on the state.

“There are a number of areas that I think we have consensus on in terms of what needs to be done,” the Democrat said. “We need to focus on those.”

Among specific issues, the debate over basic education will be in part a continuation of last year’s budget debate, which ended with a $1.1 billion increase for K-12 spending.

After a landmark court ruling in 2023 that found poorer school districts were vastly underfunded, a commission determined there was a $5 billion-plus “adequacy gap” between what Pennsylvania spends on those districts when compared to spending on wealthier ones. The current budget chipped away at the disparity, but Mr. Shapiro is expected to push for more.

Advertise with us

“There is about $4 billion left in terms of the adequacy gap,” said Stephen Herzenberg, executive director of the Keystone Research Center in Harrisburg. “We are looking to build on the progress made last year.”

Republicans will listen for any proposal from Mr. Shapiro that would provide state funds to help children leave low-performing public schools for private ones — an issue that Democrats have long opposed, but where Mr. Shapiro has shown some willingness to break from party orthodoxy. 

“Allowing state funding to follow students to the school of their choice” would address many of the state’s education issues, the conservative, Harrisburg-based Commonwealth Foundation posted on its website.

For transit agencies, the coming address could signal how much help is coming for their beleaguered finances. 

Philadelphia’s public transit system learned of an upcoming, one-time boost of $153 million when Mr. Shapiro announced it in November. But lawmakers on both sides of the aisle believe the state must come up with a new infusion of money for transit agencies and more money to repair and replace state roads and bridges.

Advertise with us

Mr. Shapiro has been a prolific traveler within Pennsylvania during his first two years in office, and his appearances in various counties frequently are tied to economic development. That theme is likely to be reflected in his budget address.

In October, he appeared in Downtown Pittsburgh to unveil a $600 million plan to pump new life into the area, including about $63 million in state spending.

For years, the city's core has been beset by rising office vacancy rates that began when the COVID-19 pandemic forced workers to abandon skyscrapers and work from home. In the years since, the shift in work habits has hollowed out many of the city's most valuable properties — real estate that Pittsburgh counts on for a quarter of its property tax revenue. 

The state spending is a cornerstone of the years-long Pittsburgh project, which will rely on commitments from major local corporations and governments for hundreds of millions more in investments.

On Tuesday, any new spending proposals from Mr. Shapiro will be viewed by Republicans through the lens of the structural deficit that currently exists in the state budget. 

Among potential new sources of revenue that have received serious discussion are the legalization of recreational marijuana and the regulation of the thousands of so-called “skill games” being used in convenience stores, clubs, bars, and other venues across the state.