HARRISBURG — A proposal to give Pittsburgh the right to create its own tax-break program for some longtime homeowners made a big step forward on Monday over the objections of Allegheny County Republican Rep. Rob Mercuri, who said it would exacerbate negative effects of a possible upcoming county property tax reassessment.

The Democrat-dominated House Finance Committee approved a bill backing the concept on the eighth day without a state budget in place. Veteran Democratic Sen. Jim Brewster of Allegheny County said the closed-door budget negotiations process “is going along pretty well,” echoing positive comments made last week by lawmakers of both parties.

The committee vote on the tax-program bill was 14-11, with all Democrats in favor and all Republicans opposed. The bill would let the city set up a Longtime Owner-Occupant Property Tax Relief Program, or LOOP, in which tax breaks could go to longtime owner-occupants in neighborhoods where property values are rising swiftly.

Sponsored by Democratic Sen. Jay Costa of Allegheny County, it passed the Senate last week. Clearing the hurdle of the House committee vote Monday was significant because the full House — which will consider the concept next — approved a nearly identical bill last year.

Advertise with us

The earlier bill, sponsored by then-Rep. Sara Innamorato, subsequently stalled in the Senate.

Mr. Costa has said that through no fault of their own, longtime homeowners have been hit by significant tax increases tied to rapidly rising property values in their neighborhoods. The goal, he said, is to allow those people “to remain in their homes” and not be forced out by high taxes.

He said East Liberty and Lawrenceville were areas where the program might help some homeowners.

The pushback from Republicans on Monday was led by Mr. Mercuri, whose district includes Marshall, Pine, Richland, and West Deer; Bradford Woods; and part of Hampton. He said the bill would create an “unequal playing field for property tax rates” across the Pittsburgh region.

Mr. Mercuri introduced two amendments. One would have required Pittsburgh to hold a referendum before starting a LOOP program, and the other would have instituted a statewide “taxpayer dividend program” that would use the current, huge state surplus to send out rebates to taxpayers statewide.

Advertise with us

Mr. Mercuri said the LOOP plan would exacerbate ill effects if a much-discussed reassessment happens in Allegheny County; would give an incentive to stay in an existing home rather than buying a new one, in an already stressed housing market; and should only be implemented if taxpayers get a chance to vote on it first.

The first amendment was rejected in a party-line vote. The second was designated not germane to the main bill.

Republican Rep. Jack Rader of Monroe County — one of the hardest-hit counties in the state in recent years in terms of rising property taxes — said it was unfair to set up tax break programs in one part of the state but not another.

Rep. Steve Samuelson, D-Northampton and chairman of the committee, noted that the 46-4 final approval vote in the Senate last week included 24 Republicans.

Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com