HARRISBURG — Republicans who control the state Senate and some Democrats jolted 2024-25 budget negotiations into high gear on Tuesday by rapidly passing a proposal to cut the state income tax by nearly 9% and to get rid of a tax that nearly everyone pays on electric bills.

The proposals were moved quickly — passing the Senate 36-14 only a day after they first came to public attention — and signaled the start of serious negotiations ahead of the June 30 budget deadline in a year when state coffers are flush with money. They also stand in stark contrast to the $48.3 billion spending plan proposed by Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro on Feb. 6, when he said he wanted to invest in many new or expanded initiatives.

While some veteran Democratic senators spoke out against the bill, eight Democrats joined all Republicans in support of it.

All told, the state has a current surplus of about $14 billion, including about $6.2 billion in its Rainy Day Fund. Republicans on Tuesday said they wanted to use the big surplus to give money back to people — by paying for the proposed tax cuts with money previously collected.

Advertise with us

“What we are talking about is empowering the taxpayer,” said Sen. Joe Pittman, R-Indiana and the Republican majority leader. Referring to the Rainy Day Fund, Mr. Pittman said, “If you want to use some of that Rainy Day Fund to invest, let’s invest it in the taxpayer.” Sen. President Pro Tempore Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland, said the proposals amounted to a $3 billion tax cut, and would let people decide whether to spend the saved money on things like a vacation, health care, or food.

A spokesperson for Mr. Shapiro, Manuel Bonder, said the governor’s February proposal was intended to help families and communities.

“With this proposal, Senate Republican leaders are coming to the table and acknowledging that we must invest in Pennsylvania’s future. We look forward to continuing to work together with the only divided legislature in the country to make critical investments in our Commonwealth,” Mr. Bonder said.

One of Mr. Shapiro’s high-profile proposals is a $1.07 billion increase in funding for basic education. Others included $100 million on initiatives to reduce gun violence, $300 million for school facility and environmental repairs, and a big boost in public transit funding.

The bill will now go to the state House, which is controlled by Democrats. A spokesperson for House Democratic Leader Matt Bradford of Montgomery County, Beth Rementer, said they were open to “a mixture of investments and tax cuts” to stimulate growth with Mr. Shapiro in the lead, but the Senate bill “fails in that effort.”

Advertise with us

On Tuesday, some Democratic senators defended Mr. Shapiro’s proposals and ripped into the Republican concept. Philadelphia Sen. Sharif Street said it “puts more money in the hands of rich folks” and will not help grow the state.

Sen. Jay Costa of Allegheny County, the top Democrat in the chamber, said the quick introduction and passage of the concept trampled on the typical process. He called it “a rush to dismiss arguments from this side of the aisle.”

Republican after Republican, though, lashed out at the concept of having state officials and “bureaucrats” decide how to spend billions of dollars in excess money obtained from taxpayers.

Sen. Chris Gebhard, R-Lebanon, said the vote was an “historic opportunity” to help families with energy costs and reduce income taxes to their level prior to a 2004 increase. “These cuts will help improve lives,” Mr. Gebhard said.

The current income tax rate is 3.07%. The proposal that passed the Senate calls for a reduction to 2.8%. The reduction of 0.27 percentage point would be equivalent to a cut of about 8.8%.

Advertise with us

The other proposal would eliminate the gross receipts tax paid by electric utilities and require that the savings be passed along to electricity consumers.

Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com