Two state legislators have introduced a measure that would amend the Pennsylvania Constitution to protect abortion rights.

House Bill 1888, sponsored by Reps. Danielle Friel Otten, D-Chester, and Liz Hanbidge, D-Montgomery, comes as other states have introduced similar legislation following the repeal of Dobbs v. Jackson, which federally protected abortion. Ohio voted to protect reproductive rights on Nov. 7 by passing its own amendment.

Other states are pursuing the opposite approach: abortion is banned after conception in 14 U.S. states, according to a Guardian analysis — including neighboring West Virginia. Pennsylvania’s Constitution neither guarantees nor penalizes abortion, and the procedure is currently legal up to 24 weeks gestation. The intention of H.B. 1888 is to guarantee “personal reproductive liberty,” according to the bill’s memo, which would include the right to choose or refuse contraception or fertility care in the state of Pennsylvania.

“Abortion is currently safe and legal in the commonwealth, and as a mother to a young girl, I feel a responsibility to ensure that we protect and preserve that right,” said Ms. Otten. “I do not want my daughter’s personal health or economic future to be at the mercy of a governor’s veto pen. We need to explicitly enshrine these rights in the Pennsylvania Constitution.”

Advertise with us

The House Judiciary Committee held a hearing about the bill on Wednesday that included testimony from both supporters and opponents. The hearing was part of new operating rules of the House that any proposed amendment is subject to a public hearing before voting moves to the House floor. H.B. 1888 would need to pass the House and the Senate before being put on a general election ballot for Pennsylvania voters.

Judiciary Committee majority leader, Rep. Tim Briggs, D-Montgomery, affirmed his support for the bill and for reproductive health care during the meeting. “At the end of the day, what is clear, politicians have no business infringing or interfering with a woman's right to choose,” he said in a news release.

“What's happening in other states serves as a stark reminder of how quickly this right can be taken away,” said Ms. Hanbidge during her opening remarks at the meeting. “This constitutional amendment will allow all Pennsylvanians to explicitly reaffirm their belief that women have the right to make their own reproductive health care decisions, including decisions about contraception, fertility care and abortion.”

Two of the speakers mentioned Kate Cox, a 31-year-old Texas woman who has been in a legal battle to try to get an abortion in a state that bans it. A Texas Supreme Court judge denied her request this week, stating her life was not in danger. Ms. Cox has reportedly traveled out of state to seek abortion care.

“Just recently, I cared for a patient with a pregnancy affected by Trisomy 18, which we've already heard about, a lethal genetic disorder, and the same diagnosis received by Kate Cox in Texas,” said Dr. Sarah Gutman, a board certified OB/GYN at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. “Because I live and practice in Pennsylvania, when my patient received that same diagnosis, I could stay her doctor during one of the hardest times of her life, and offer her the decision to continue that pregnancy or to end it, and to provide her with the medical care that she wanted and needed.”

Advertise with us

Speaker Meghan Orbich, a mother of two living in Oakmont and the sister of Ms. Otten, gave testimony at the meeting about her own experience carrying a child with special needs to term.

Ms. Orbich said doctors found abnormalities in her pregnancy during the 20-week check-up visit, when she was pregnant with her second child in 2013. They gave her the option to get an abortion, but thinking the child had hope of surviving, she carried him to term. Her baby, Ian, received an ECMO surgery immediately after being born, which implants a device that helps the heart and lungs work when they do not work on their own. Ian is 10 years old now, lives with a tracheostomy, uses a ventilator at night and requires 24/7 professional care.

“There are thousands of women out there with similar but different stories that range from not having resources, to having an unexpected child, to women who want nothing but a child but experience the devastation of a pregnancy with a fatal outcome,” Ms. Orbich said.

“Women need to be able to make choices that affect their bodies, their families and their futures … I don't know how I would cope with the challenges of our life and our family's life if it was not a carefully made decision between my husband and I.”

Ms. Orbich said hearing about Ms. Cox was “heartbreaking” and “triggering.”

Advertise with us

Bill rapped over lack of restrictions

Elizabeth Kirk, the director of the Center for Law and the Human Person and a research associate at the The Catholic University of America, also provided testimony and said the proposed amendment would extend abortion rights past what Dobbs allowed.

“Proponents of amendments such as this one frequently claim that it's merely restoring Roe or that it's merely protecting and preserving existing laws,” said Ms. Kirk. “The language of the bill states that the commonwealth may not deny the fundamental right unless ‘justified by a compelling state interest achieved by the least restrictive means.’ This technical legal language is known as strict scrutiny, and this standard is so rigorous that it's referred to colloquially as strict in theory, fatal in fact,” she said. “Very few abortion restrictions survive challenge under this rigorous test.”

Ms. Kirk took issue with the vagueness of the bill, which she said had “no limiting framework,” such as conditions for fetal viability, or elaborations regarding the term “reproductive liberty” and what that might entail. She said the bill far exceeds both existing Pennsylvania law and what was laid out in Roe v. Wade.

“[This bill] is virtually certain to lead to the striking down of your existing laws and to discourage future common sense law,” she said.

Committee minority leader Rob Kauffman, R-Franklin, held up a plastic model of a 22-week-old fetus in his closing remarks, and also criticized the bill for allegedly extending abortion past any fetal viability restrictions.

Advertise with us

“I can't imagine this legislation coming to pass, it would be horrible for Pennsylvania, women, children, families, minorities who are just desperately impacted by abortion,” said Mr. Kauffman. “And I will be certainly adamantly opposing it and be fighting for those little ones who would be aborted past the point of viability if this legislation would come to pass.”

A vast majority of abortions occur in the first trimester of pregnancy. A Post-Gazette analysis of quarterly reports of abortion clinics throughout the state found that at Allegheny Reproductive Healthcare Center — a main reproductive health care provider located in East Liberty — fewer than 10% of abortions given in 2022 were performed in a patient’s second trimester, or between 15 and 26 weeks. Zero abortions that year were performed in the third trimester, past 27 weeks.

“There is broad consensus within the medical community that abortion care is an essential component of reproductive health care,” said Dr. Sarah Horvath during the meeting. Dr. Horvath is an assistant professor of obstetrics and gynecology and a practicing OB/GYN at Penn State Health in Hershey, Pa.

“Research has shown that non-medically necessary barriers, many of which were outlined by [Ms. Kirk] this morning, serve only to delay and complicate care, putting it completely out of reach for some patients.”

Dr. Horvath said reproductive health care restrictions impact people disproportionately: women of color, poor women and younger women are more likely to face barriers in accessing care, such as a lack of transportation to out-of-state clinics, the ability to secure child care, or to fund an abortion. Black women in Pennsylvania also face a maternal mortality rate double that of white women, added Dr. Gutman.

Advertise with us

“We have evidence that when people are unable to attain their needed abortion care, they're more likely to be living in poverty four years later,” said Dr. Horvath. “And they're more likely to remain in a relationship with a violent partner.

“Bodies are becoming political battlegrounds. We're seeing unprecedented numbers of measures that impose politics and ideology on clinical care, including political intrusion into our exam rooms,” Dr. Horvath said in her ending comments. “H.B. 1888 ensures that Pennsylvanians can make decisions regarding their reproduction without interference from state or local governments.”

No date for a vote on the bill by the committee was announced.

—

This story has been corrected to state Ms. Orbich’s pregnancy check-up which found abnormalities was at 20 weeks, not 12.