HARRISBURG — The taxpayer-supported pool of money that covered most of the $295,000 sexual harassment settlement involving a former top Shapiro administration official has paid out almost $19 million for 138 claims of various types generated in recent years, state records show.
One multi-million dollar settlement went to the estate of Kevin Siehl, who spent 25 years in state prison and was released by court order after a judge found the murder case against him was mishandled. Another settlement went to the family of 81-year-old Edward Horowitz, one of dozens of military veterans who died at a state-run veterans’ home where COVID-19 precautions were botched.
But it was a prolonged lack of public knowledge about sexual harassment allegations that led to a settlement this year that has produced calls for greater transparency around taxpayer-supported payouts.
Mike Vereb, the former Secretary of Legislative Affairs for Gov. Josh Shapiro, resigned without a publicly stated reason on Sept. 27. Not until the following day did the public learn through media reports that Mr. Vereb had been accused by a female employee of sexual harassment. He has not commented publicly on the allegations.
The taxpayer-funded $295,000 settlement in the case included an agreement that prevented parties from talking about it. That led some lawmakers to push for public posting of some details on settlements.
In response to Post-Gazette Right-to-Know requests, the state Department of General Services supplied data on the low-profile self-insurance fund that paid most of the Vereb-related settlement.
The records included 138 claims that were wrapped up and got final payments from the fund between Jan. 1 and Nov. 13. The total paid out on those claims was $18.9 million, with 20 of them for $140,000 or more — indicating that even the Vereb-related base settlement of $196,000, excluding $99,000 in attorneys’ fees, was large in comparison to many others.
It was not paid until after Nov. 13, according to a state Treasury spokesperson. All but $45,000 of that settlement came from the fund, called the Employee Liability Self-Insurance Program, or ELSIP.
“This sort of information is exactly why we need the bipartisan legislation,” Sen. Kristen Phillips-Hill, R-York, said after being told of the DGS data. “This is why the status quo is unacceptable.”
Ms. Phillips-Hill plans to introduce a bill that would require all state agencies and the General Assembly to self-report the total number of monetary settlements with non-disclosure agreements tied to sexual harassment or sex discrimination accusations. The reports would be posted in the Pennsylvania Bulletin.
Rep. Donna Scheuren, R-Montgomery, said the data released to the Post-Gazette underscored the need for a bill she has proposed. It would allow posting of some settlement information on PennWATCH, a state government transparency portal.
“All the settlements paid out of that fund would lend themselves to be posted,” she said, excluding personal information.
‘It shouldn’t be hidden’
The nature of the allegations behind the settlements drawn from ELSIP range far beyond sexual harassment. The fund is used to pay settlements or judgements and related expenses against the state and its employees for claims tied to negligence, employment discrimination, sexual harassment, assault, false arrest, defamation, and more.
Sen. Anthony Williams, D-Philadelphia, said the fund performs a necessary function, “but it shouldn’t be hidden.”
Mr. Williams said he would support posting some settlement information on PennWATCH or in the Pennsylvania Bulletin. Sexual harassment allegations when first made should be vetted, and at that stage privacy is warranted, he said. Further along in the process — and especially after a settlement is reached — transparency is necessary, Mr. Williams said.
Publicly available information, he said, should include how much was paid out, over what period of time, and what categories of incidents led to the payments. Having that knowledge would allow lawmakers to improve the system, he said.
Similarly, Rep. Valerie Gaydos, R-Allegheny, said the existence of the fund is warranted, but that the real issue is “are they paying out for things regularly that instead should be fixed?” Greater transparency, she said, would help ensure that issue is addressed.
The fund doesn’t get talked about much. Former state Sen. Andrew Dinniman, a lawmaker for about 15 years, said he could not recall ever hearing it discussed. But Mr. Dinniman, a Chester County Democrat, said the amounts of money flowing through the fund are not the main cause for concern.
“The issue really comes down to the whole matter of non-disclosure,” he said. “How does anybody know what is going on if the non-disclosure agreements are there?”
So-called “NDA’s” could allow a teacher accused of sexual harassment in one district to get a job in another, Mr. Dinniman said. Their widespread use is a challenge in schools and local governments as well as in state government, he said. He called it a “single issue that has many tentacles.”
Among the claims for which DGS provided data, 52 involved individual state prisons, while 28 involved the Department of Corrections as an agency. A large majority of the total payments involved claims made against state police or individual troops. Those added up to more than $13 million.
The fund was restocked by premiums totaling about $5.7 million a year. For 2023-24, premiums are being charged to 84 different state agencies or entities. The Department of Corrections has the largest premium at about $1.5 million, followed by state police at about $977,000 and the Department of Human Services at $502,000.
The fund also is replenished when the roughly $9 million annual appropriation to the Bureau of Finance and Risk Management is divided between three self-insurance funds it administers, according to a DGS spokesperson.
A state management directive says the head of the individual agency and a DGS attorney must approve payment of claims greater than $10,000. The directive sets a coverage limit of $250,000 per incident, but “under extraordinary circumstances” that cap may be exceeded.
State-related tragedies
Kevin Siehl was 60 years old and had spent 25 years in prison when he was released from the State Correctional Institution at Huntingdon on Oct. 12, 2016.
“They took Mr. Siehl away from his family for 25 years,” said attorney Jonathan Feinberg, who represented Mr. Siehl in a 2018 federal civil rights lawsuit filed against defendants who included a state police trooper and a state police forensics specialist. “Mr. Siehl maintained his innocence throughout his entire period of incarceration.”
A painter by trade, Mr. Siehl was arrested following the 1991 murder of his estranged wife, who was found stabbed to death in a bathtub in her apartment in Johnstown. Mr. Siehl was convicted in 1992.
A federal judge ordered Mr. Siehl’s immediate release in 2016 after a finding that the case had been mishandled and a decision by the state attorney general’s office to abandon the case. Among other things, Mr. Feinberg said, Mr. Siehl was convicted using fabricated evidence and other genuine evidence favorable to Mr. Siehl was withheld.
He died in March 2022. About eight months later, the lawsuit was settled for more than $8 million. Of that amount, more than $4.6 million came from ELSIP.
“The money was paid out to his estate,” Mr. Feinberg said. “I am glad the funds were available to resolve the case.”
Edward Horowitz had been in the Army, worked as a police officer, and later was a saloon owner before he moved into the state-run Southeastern Veterans Center in Chester County. He had three children and was a grandfather.
When COVID-19 hit in early 2020, the veterans center made national news for its mishandling of the crisis. A special investigation done for the office of then-Gov. Tom Wolf found that during April and May, 40 residents who tested or were presumed positive for COVID-19 died.
“Southeastern Veterans Center mishandled its response to COVID-19 in many significant ways, which contributed tragically to the heartrending events that occurred there,” the report on the investigation said.
Mr. Horowitz died on May 10, 2020. His son, 56-year-old Ian Horowitz, said in a recent interview that his father watched his roommate get very sick with COVID, then got sick himself.
“It was horrible. We were very, very close,” Ian Horowitz said. “He was full of life.”
The DGS documents show Edward Horowitz’s estate received an ELSIP-funded settlement.
Both the Horowitz and Siehl settlements came after the filing of federal lawsuits.
Ms. Phillips-Hill’s proposal is specific to settlements with non-disclosure agreements that stem from allegations of sexual harassment or sex discrimination. Increased transparency around the settlements, she said, will deter the behavior.
“This is a way to change what is happening,” she said. “You can’t use these tools to quietly settle these claims against one of your top officials.”
Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.