LAS VEGAS — Pennsylvania has more Jews than all but four other states, and their votes a year from now in the nation’s most populous battleground state could help determine who wins the 2024 presidential election.
While a large majority of American Jews identify as Democrats — 71%, according to the Pew Research Center —- Republicans have tried for years to tout their pro-Israel bonafides to woo them away from a party that includes progressives more willing to criticize the Jewish state’s policies toward Palestinians.
Their efforts were on display this weekend at the Republican Jewish Coalition’s annual leadership summit, which attracted all of the major GOP presidential candidates, new House Speaker Mike Johnson of Louisiana, and hundreds of campaign donors and activists.
“Obviously, this is an issue that’s very important,” said Tom Malinowski, a former Democratic congressman and former assistant U.S. secretary of state. “But Republicans make a mistake in treating them as one-issue voters about Israel and assuming they don't care about what’s happening in our country.”
On topics such as abortion, civil rights, social justice, right-wing extremism and helping the poor, Jewish values more readily align with Democratic Party positions — and it shows up on Election Day, said Halie Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America.
“There’s a reason why three quarters of American Jews have been Democrats for decades,” she said. “Democrats represent Jewish values on a wide range of issues that Jews are voting on – democracy, abortion, climate change, guns, health care. You go down the list. Israel is included on that list, but Jews are not voting solely on Israel.”
Republicans have made some inroads among Jewish voters. President George W. Bush received 25% of the Jewish vote in 2004, according to network exit polls.
“There has been a discernible shift,” said Ari Fleischer, White House press secretary under Mr. Bush and a Republican Jewish Coalition board member. “It’s because of foreign policy.”
The attack on Israel earlier this month by Hamas, designated by the U.S. as a terrorist organization, threatens to elevate that issue.
“I think that the war has pushed Israel back to the center of American Jewish life,” said Jonathan Sarna, a professor of American Jewish history at Brandeis University. “The horrific slaughter reminded the bulk of American Jews how much Israel matters to them and how emotionally attached they are to Israel, sometimes even more than they realize.”
That’s what GOP presidential candidates gathered here were counting on as they took turns Saturday expressing their unconditional support for the Jewish state, cheering Israel and condemning Hamas.
“When I’m back in the White House, the United States will stand with Israel 100%,” former President Donald Trump said. “This is a fight between civilization and savagery. There is no comparison between a group that worships death and a group that cherishes life.”
“We stand with Israel,” Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis said. “We stand with the people of Israel. The United States will have their back. We will give them what they need so that they can defend themselves. And that means not just a couple of glancing blows, that means a complete and total victory in this conflict. Hamas must be no more at the end of this conflict.”
“We need to commit ourselves to ensuring good defeats evil,” said Nikki Haley, a former South Carolina governor and U.N. ambassador. “It means giving Israel everything she needs to destroy Hamas.”
And shortly before announcing he was ending his campaign for the 2024 nomination, former Vice President Mike Pence said: “In this dark hour, every American leader should speak with one voice and say to the world, ‘America stands with Israel.’ Her cause is our cause. Her values are our values. Her fight is our fight.”
The importance of attracting Jewish voters in Pennsylvania and other battleground states can be seen by the outsized role the Republican Jewish Coalition is playing so far.
Not only did every major GOP presidential candidate show up here, but the RJC is co-sponsoring the party’s debate next month in Miami. And Mr. Johnson, R-La., the new House speaker, made the Las Vegas conference the site of his first major address, speaking at the closing dinner Saturday night.
Republican National Chair Ronna McDaniel said that having the RJC co-sponsor the debate was a sign that “the Republican Party stands with Israel.”
This weekend’s event took place at the Venetian Resort, built by the late Republican uber-donor and casino executive Sheldon Adelson, who with his wife, Miriam, spent $215 million on behalf of Mr. Trump and other GOP candidates in 2020, more than anyone else, according to the research group OpenSecrets. Miriam Adelson received a standing ovation at Friday’s dinner.
The Republican candidates’ pledges to stand with Israel for as long as it takes to eradicate Hamas is not going to shift too many voters from blue to red, said Guy Ziv, a professor at American University and associate director of its Center for Israel Studies
“I don’t think the American Jewish Community is going to change its voting pattern over these developments,” Mr. Ziv said. “Republicans get frustrated when their pro-Israel policies do not translate into additional votes from the American Jewish community.”
In fact, President Joe Biden’s response — offering comfort and support to Israelis, moving carrier strike groups into the Mediterranean, and even traveling to Israel during the war — earned him high marks even among some Republicans, Mr. Sarna said.
“A vast majority of the people I've spoken to think President Biden hit a home run — maybe even a grand-slam home run — in his actions so far,” Mr. Sarna said.
Mr. Ziv said those actions have strengthened Mr. Biden’s support among Jewish Americans in advance of 2024.
“As far as most American Jews who see themselves as Zionists and pro-Israel, he has displayed a very, very admirable leadership,” Mr. Ziv said. “It’s not just rhetoric but he’s backed up his rhetoric with action.”
Mr. Biden faces some dissension from a small group of liberal Democrats who have called for a ceasefire and voted against a bipartisan resolution condemning Hamas and supporting the Jewish state. They’re the same lawmakers who voted against a Republican-drafted measure this summer that condemned antisemitism, declared that Israel was not an apartheid state and said the U.S. government would always stand by its ally.
The lawmakers, known as “the squad,” include U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, and Republican presidential candidates took turns denouncing them at the conference.
The RJC’s national chair, former U.S. Sen. Norm Coleman, R-Minn., dubbed them the “Hamas caucus,” and Mr. Brooks said there was a Democratic divide.
“If you stand up at a Republican Lincoln Day dinner and say, ‘I stand with Israel,’ it’s an automatic applause line,” Mr. Brooks said. “If you do that as a Democrat at a Democratic event, you’re likely going to be booed off the stage.”
But the 15 House Democrats who either voted against the anti-Hamas resolution or abstained represent just 8% of the House Democratic caucus, Ms. Soifer said.
“I wouldn’t exaggerate or overemphasize the voices in our party that, frankly, have been marginalized in this issue,” she said. “I don’t want to conflate that with what is the overwhelming support of the Democratic caucus — 90% —- that stands with Israel and President Biden on this issue.”
Polls show Mr. Biden and Mr. Trump, the frontrunner for the Republican nomination, running neck and neck for Pennsylvania’s 20 electoral votes. The state has more than 430,000 Jewish residents, behind only New York, California, Florida and New Jersey, according to the American Jewish Year Book.
The RJC already has staff in Pennsylvania, which CEO Matthew Brooks said would be a top target in 2024. “We’re going to be all-in in the presidential, targeting the Jewish community for our nominee,” he said.
Mr. Biden, though, has what political science professor Gilbert Kahn called a “wild card” in 2024’s Pennsylvania contest: the backing of Gov. Josh Shapiro, who is Jewish and sits on the president’s re-election campaign’s national advisory board. Mr. Shapiro received a 57% favorable rating in a recent Franklin & Marshall poll, against just a 29% unfavorable rating.
“Even just the repair on Interstate 95 was such an extraordinary feather in his cap,” said Mr. Kahn, who teaches courses on the American presidency, Middle East politics and antisemitism at Kean University in New Jersey. “I don’t think anybody in the Jewish community can say a bad word about him. His connections to Biden will be very helpful.”
Mr. Trump is suffering from some self-inflicted wounds. After the Hamas attack, he called Hezbollah, another Iran-aligned, U.S.-designated terrorist group that has attacked Israel from the north, “very smart,” and criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
He said Mr. Netanyahu “let us down” by bowing out of the U.S.-led attack that killed Qassem Soleimani, a top Iranian general, in 2020, and said Israel “was not prepared” for the Hamas attack. “They’re going to have to step up their game,” he said.
Ms. Haley criticized those comments during her appearance Saturday.
“As president, I will not compliment Hezbollah,” she said. “Nor will I criticize Israel’s prime minister in the middle of tragedy and war. We have no time for personal vendettas.”
But when Mr. Trump came on stage Saturday, he received the loudest and most sustained reception of any of the candidates, with the crowd standing and waving signs. They cheered when he talked about moving the U.S. embassy to Jerusalem, when he cited the Abraham Accords between Israel and some Arab nations, and when he recognized Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights, captured from Syria in the Six-Day War.
And Mr. Trump’s sharpest campaign critic, former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie, received heckling and only tepid applause from the same people.
Mr. Trump “shouldn’t have said it, but his record is so strong and so good, he still has a deep pool of goodwill,” Mr. Brooks said.
But Mr. Trump’s earlier comments can only help Mr. Biden among Jewish voters, Mr. Ziv said.
“Trump isn’t going to change a lot of people’s minds at this point, but Biden’s actions will attract greater support from the more conservative elements of the American Jewish community,” he said. “In retrospect, some of [Trump’s] biggest supporters in the Jewish community realize that Biden has delivered and is delivering at a time when Israel needs the United States the most.”
Still, “a lot can happen between now and November 2024,” Mr. Sarna said.
“The question now is what will be the long term effect,” he said. “A very long drawn-out war in Gaza is likely to undo some of the unity that we have seen. The longer the war lasts, the more difficult it is to maintain support.”
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.