David McCormick announced his entry into Pennsylvania's U.S. Senate race on Thursday, banking on a united Republican Party, a long record in business and government, and the unpopularity of President Joe Biden to make the difference in his second attempt at elected office.
“Sadly, the America we know is slipping away,” Mr. McCormick, 58, said during an evening event in Pittsburgh at the Heinz History Center. “Under the failed leadership of Joe Biden, America is in decline, economically, militarily, spiritually. You see it, you know it, you feel it. I’m here to tell you tonight It doesn’t have to be that way.”
But Mr. McCormick faces some of the same headwinds as he did in last year's unsuccessful Senate run: Trying to appeal to Republicans who nominated an election denier for governor in 2022 while also seeking to attract more moderate voters, facing questions about the years he spent as a hedge fund CEO living in Connecticut, and needing to find daylight between himself and the outsized presence of former President Donald Trump, the favorite to lead the GOP ticket next fall.
“It’s going to be a very loud [race],” said J.J. Balaban, a Democratic strategist and ad maker based in Philadelphia. “This will be a high-spending, high-communication campaign that will dominate the airwaves and political talk for months.”
Keenly aware the criticism he took even before entering the race for the time he still spends at his Connecticut home, Mr. McCormick heavily emphasized his Pennsylvania roots during his campaign kick-off Thursday. He noted that he was born in Washington, Pa., and told the crowd that he was “Pennsylvania first” and “America First,” starting with his first day at West Point. He credited his home state as the birthplace of the country and Pittsburgh as one of the nation’s major industrial engines.

But he said the country is experiencing a downturn as it faces a host of struggles, including an immigration problem, too many shuttered factories, and rising costs for food, rent and gas that are hitting Americans’ pockets. He quickly linked his opponent, three-term Democratic U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, with Mr. Biden. He accused Mr. Casey as being a “rubber stamp” for the president, sparking chants of “rubber stamp” from the crowd.
“Under Joe Biden and Bob Casey, what’s supposed to be up is down and what’s supposed to be down is up,” he said to cheers from a boisterous crowd as he stood behind a podium affixed with a red “Dave” sign against a backdrop of a large American flag. “We can do better. We cannot lose our country. We cannot lose our culture. We must not accept the status quo.”
Before his speech, supporters donning “Day One Supporter” buttons mingled and enjoyed drinks, hors d'oeuvres, and a playlist of rock and pop hits from a local cover band. Mr. McCormick was joined on the stage by his wife, Dina Powell McCormick, a former Goldman Sachs executive and Trump administration official, and dozens of family members and supporters.
A former hedge fund CEO and Army veteran who grew up in the Pittsburgh area, Mr. McCormick’s second attempt to represent the Keystone State follows a book tour and meetings and events with GOP leaders and donors across Pennsylvania. Republicans ranging from county party chairs to Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., urged Mr. McCormick to take on Mr. Casey, as the battle lines for control of the chamber run through Pennsylvania.
Mr. McCormick highlighted his leadership experience in business and in the military.
“My opponent was born to run for political office,” he said. “I was born to shake things up. … That’s why I refuse to let things stay the way they are in Washington. Congress is broken. I’m the only candidate in this race that can change Washington.”
The announcement took place less than a year after celebrity doctor Mehmet Oz, who beat Mr. McCormick in the 2022 Republican Senate primary, lost the general election to Democrat John Fetterman. Dr. Oz, buoyed by an endorsement from former President Donald Trump, beat Mr. McCormick by less than 1,000 votes.
This time, the primary field is clear for Mr. McCormick — at least so far. No other Republican has entered the race, and a potential rival on Mr. McCormick’s right flank, state Sen. Doug Mastriano, said earlier this year that he wouldn’t run.
Every member of the state’s Republican congressional delegation immediately endorsed Mr. McCormick after his announcement.
Vince Galko, a Republican consultant based in northeastern Pennsylvania, said Mr. McCormick “will have the resources and party support,” and can go after independent and swing voters without having to worry about playing to far-right elements of the GOP base.
Before becoming CEO of Bridgewater Associates, one of the world’s largest hedge funds, Mr. McCormick served in the first Gulf War, was under secretary of the Treasury for international affairs in the George W. Bush administration, and was a consultant at McKinsey & Co. in Pittsburgh.
In a book released earlier this year, Mr. McCormick argues that the chasm between the Democratic and Republican parties has left voters and their needs behind. He said he applauded Mr. Trump’s “America First” policies, but suggested the former president fell short when it came to actually advancing a conservative agenda.
“To save our republic,” he wrote, “we need a vision for how we will address the immense problems before us, and we need leaders who can unite our country around that vision.”
Democrats went on the offensive against Mr. McCormick before he entered the race, raising questions about his residency and likening him to Dr. Oz, who moved to Pennsylvania from New Jersey to run for Senate. While Mr. McCormick owns a Pittsburgh home and a family farm near Bloomsburg, news reports have noted how much time Mr. McCormick spends in his rented $16 million mansion in Westport, Conn. He lived on Connecticut’s wealthy “Gold Coast” for years before returning to Pennsylvania shortly before launching his 2022 campaign.
On Thursday, a plane circled Downtown towing a banner saying, "Welcome to Pennsylvania, Dave."
“According to reports, he does not reside in Pennsylvania and has built his career as a Wall Street executive, advocating for policies that support job outsourcing and tax cuts primarily benefiting himself and his Wall Street associates,” state Sen. Sharif Street, the chair of the state Democratic Party, said in a statement.
Democrats also have hit Mr. McCormick over his opposition to abortion rights, which has proved to be a potent political issue for them in recent elections and one they plan to continue campaigning on in races up and down the ballot in 20204.
Allegheny County GOP chairman Sam DeMarco shrugged off the Democratic attacks on Mr. McCormick as a Connecticut resident.
“If that’s all [the Democrats] have, that’s good for Dave McCormick,” he said.
Republicans have painted Mr. Casey, the son of a former governor, as a decades-long politician, and accused his family of profiting from his position.
“What has Bob Casey done?” Mr. DeMarco said. “He’s a nice guy, but no accomplishments.”
To beat Mr. Casey — a former state treasurer and auditor general who’s won three Senate races by at least nine percentage points — Mr. McCormick’s team must “make sure this is a referendum on Casey and not a proxy battle for Biden-Trump,” Mr. Galko said.
While Mr. Biden’s approval ratings nationally and in Pennsylvania have remained middling, more voters view him favorably compared to Mr. Trump, according to the latest Franklin & Marshall College poll. In the survey, Mr. Biden was viewed negatively by 58% and favorably by 40% while Mr. Trump had 64% negative and 34% positive ratings.
Mr. Biden led Mr. Trump 42% to 40% in a potential general election rematch in the state, a statistical dead heat.
GOP strategists, even when quick to dismiss the Biden campaign’s claims of a successful economic agenda, have for months questioned whether Mr. Trump is the best bet for Republicans to flip Pennsylvania back to their column after Mr. Biden’s 2020 victory.
Christopher Nicholas, a longtime Harrisburg-based GOP consultant, said Mr. Biden’s unpopularity could be a drag on Mr. Casey that he never had to deal with in his previous Senate races: All three took place during strong Democratic election cycles.
“Casey has benefitted from having a lot of perfect political luck,” he said. “He’s benefitted from being bland and running at the correct times. It’s pretty clear the Democrats are worried about [McCormick].”
But Mr. Balaban said Mr. Casey has developed strengths not only in policy but in retail politics over the years.
“What he’s been building with his maps and drinking a beer — that sends a signal that he’s not running a campaign like he did in 1996,” Mr. Balaban said, referring to the incumbent’s penchant for knocking back a cold one while dissecting local election results on social media. “He’s already adapted to the way that people and communication have changed.”
Mr. Casey was raising money ahead of Mr. McCormick’s announcement, saying in an email to supporters that it “will change the stakes of this race.”
“Mitch McConnell has already promised this mega-millionaire candidate super PAC support, which means MILLIONS in dark money will pour into our Commonwealth,” his campaign said.
The Fetterman-Oz race saw more than $400 million in campaign and outside spending, according to the research group OpenSecrets.
Mr. McCormick spent $14 million of his own money on last year’s primary. He raised $5.2 million, while a super PAC supporting him, Honor Pennsylvania, spent more than $20 million.
Mr. Casey has raised $11.2 million so far for his re-election, including a record three-month total of $4 million from April through June after announcing a bid for a fourth term.
“This will be the most expensive Senate race in Pennsylvania history and one of the most expensive in the history of the country,” said Charlie Gerow, a prominent Republican strategist. “It’s just crazy — regardless of who’s team you’re on.”
Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com; @BenKail





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.