WASHINGTON — Pennsylvania, which will play an outsized role in electing the next president of the United States, remains a statistical dead heat in a hypothetical matchup between incumbent Democrat Joe Biden and Republican frontrunner Donald Trump, according to a poll released Thursday.
Mr. Biden led Mr. Trump, 42% to 40%, in the Franklin & Marshall Poll, well within the survey’s margin of error of 4.5 percentage points. In April, Mr. Biden was ahead, 36% to 35%. They also were virtually tied in a Quinnipiac University survey of a hypothetical general election matchup, 47% to 46%.

Taken before Wednesday’s Republican presidential debate, the poll showed Mr. Trump widening his lead over Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis for the GOP nomination. He led, 39% to 21%, compared with 40% to 34% in April. None of the other candidates were in double figures.
Mr. Biden remained underwater in the state, with only 30% saying he was doing a good or excellent job as president, with 70% rating him as fair or poor. But that was better than April, when 27% rated his performance as good or excellent and 72% as fair or poor.
In addition, 58% viewed Mr. Biden unfavorably and 40% favorably. Mr. Trump had 64% negative and 34% positive ratings.
Perhaps more troubling to Mr. Trump, a majority of Pennsylvania voters – 58% – called his efforts to overturn his electoral defeat, which culminated in the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection by his supporters, a serious crime. Just 35% said it was not.
Mr. Trump’s other ethical problems also did not sit will with Pennsylvanians. More than four in 10 voters in the state – 42% – said the charges against Mr. Trump for mishandling classified documents were so serious that he should end his campaign now, and another 20% said he should withdraw if found guilty. Just one-third of voters, 33%, said he should continue to run for president no matter what.
“The Biden-Trump horse race is mostly a matter of partisanship: Eighty-three percent of Dems and 63% of independents think it is a serious crime, versus only 20% of Republicans,” said Berwood A. Yost, director of the Center for Opinion Research at Franklin & Marshall College. “So, almost everyone who thinks Trump committed a serious crime is voting for Biden (76% Biden and 16% someone else) and those who don't are mostly voting for Trump (88% and 11% someone else). The same is true for the extremes in the documents question. What's interesting is the middle group who say Trump should drop out if convicted in the documents case: those voters are currently split 36% Biden, 39% Trump and 23% other.”
Mr. Yost said Mr. Trump widened his lead for the GOP nomination because of “a DeSantis fade,” not a gain in support for the former president.
“What is clear is that he has slipped a bit among Republicans when you look at his favorability ratings, which were about 82% favorable before the 2020 election and are about 70% now,” Mr. Yost said. “The race might look very different if he were running against only one or two other candidates.
The poll said the economy was the No. 1 issue among Pennsylvania voters, followed by government, crime and drugs, education and taxes.
Mr. Trump narrowly won Pennsylvania in the 2016 election before Mr. Biden returned it to the Democratic column in 2020.
Another part of the survey found Gov, Josh Shapiro was in positive territory, with 47% saying he was doing a good or excellent job and 40% rating his performance as fair or poor.
But in the case of U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, D-Pa., up for re-election next fall in a race that could determine which party controls the Senate, 50% of poll respondents rated his job performance as fair or poor while 31% rated it as good or excellent.
The poll did not ask about U.S. Sen. John Fetterman, D-Pa.
The survey of 723 registered voters was conducted Aug. 9–20, 2023. The margin of error for the subgroup of 297 Republicans was 7 percentage points.
Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.