Three weeks after he was elected governor last fall, Josh Shapiro held a press conference in Montrose, Pa., to announce what he called a historic settlement with the oil and gas company Coterra Energy.

Coterra would pay $16.29 million to build a public water line in Dimock, a small town where Coterra’s fracking operations were blamed for contaminating the water, and would plead no contest to a misdemeanor charge under the Clean Streams Law.

“We are here today because fundamentally Pennsylvanians have a right to clean air and to pure water,” said Mr. Shapiro, then the Pennsylvania attorney general. “That right is enshrined in our state constitution.”

He saluted the people of Dimock who had testified in his investigation of Coterra as “good friends.” “When big corporations are not held accountable,” he said. “then the people suffer.”

Advertise with us

Standing at his side was Victoria Switzer, a Dimock resident and community advocate. Taking the microphone, she was emphatic in her praise for him. “My deepest respect and gratitude goes to the attorney general-governor-elect, Josh Shapiro, for making this day happen,” she said.

The next day, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection said it would lift a 12-year ban on drilling in Dimock, allowing Coterra to operate there once again. Ever since, people in Dimock have speculated that Mr. Shapiro must have known about DEP’s decision at the time of the press conference even though he was not yet governor; they see the settlement and the lifting of the ban as part of a larger deal with Coterra.

“If he didn’t know about it, where’s the outrage?” said Karen Feridun, a founder of the Better Path Coalition, a grassroots environmental collective. “Why didn't they do something?”

For Ms. Switzer and others who have fought for years for access to clean water, the news from DEP was a betrayal of everything Mr. Shapiro had promised them.

“Had we known about that, do you think I ever would have stood there with him in a public forum in front of all these news reporters and said it was the ‘people's lawyer’ that got this done?” Ms. Switzer said in an interview. “I am so mortified that I was paraded and made a puppet.”

Advertise with us

For many environmentalists, the reversal was both a turning point in their hopes for the Shapiro administration and an omen of a worrying new development: secretive state climate talks.

A “climate working group” appointed by the governor now is convening privately, its members unidentified and the minutes of its meetings unreleased. The group’s existence came to light because of reporting by the Associated Press. The secrecy is fueling suspicion about other deal-making and skepticism about the administration’s dedication to reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

“He talks about how he's there to listen and hear you, but he hasn't heard anyone,” said Ms. Feridun. “That’s not the governor he said he was going to be.”

A Moderate in a Purple State

During his campaign, Mr. Shapiro spoke of taking “real action” to address climate change and ensuring “reliable, affordable and clean power.”

Advertise with us

“The governor . . . said he was going to be one who took climate change seriously,” said Michael Badges-Canning, the Green Party candidate for lieutenant governor in 2022. “He talked about science; he talked about how important it was that we act on climate.”

Now, the fear is that Mr. Shapiro’s term will be marked by middle-of-the-road climate and environmental policy rather than the drastic action on emissions, pollution and energy that activists say is needed.

In statements to the AP, the Shapiro administration has said the climate working group is made up of “environmental, labor and business leaders” who will “work together to recommend solutions” for tackling climate change, to “create and protect energy jobs” and “protect consumers.”

The AP’s reporting suggests that one of the group’s main topics will be the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, a trading mechanism through which 12 states work to reduce carbon dioxide emissions from power plants.

As a candidate, Mr. Shapiro criticized the climate change plan outlined by his predecessor, Gov. Tom Wolf, which focused on RGGI, as potentially damaging to Pennsylvania’s energy industry, hurtful to consumers, and not aggressive enough in reducing emissions. (Because of lawsuits filed by gas and coal interests, the state’s involvement with RGGI is currently pending in the courts.)

Advertise with us

During the campaign, Mr. Shapiro was noncommittal about Pennsylvania’s joining. But his 2023 budget proposal assumes that the state will participate in the consortium. Environmentalists in Pennsylvania are divided on the value of joining RGGI, but even supporters see it as insufficient.

“It's not a climate plan,” said Ms. Feridun. “At best, even if you think it's a great thing, it's part of a budget plan.”

The Shapiro administration did not respond to requests from Inside Climate News for additional comment on the climate working group or on the reasoning behind lifting the drilling ban in Dimock.

Environmentalists are also worried that the energy solutions discussed by the climate committee could involve the creation of “clean hydrogen hubs” that could involve laying miles of pipeline carrying carbon dioxide. As the federal Department of Energy considers applications to build six to 10 regional hubs nationwide, the governor has rallied behind the two proposed in Pennsylvania.

“Who Is He Listening To?’’

Advertise with us

Steve Hvozdovich, Pennsylvania campaigns director for Clean Water Action, said he was encouraged that Mr. Shapiro was “trying to bring in various stakeholders” for the climate working group who could “develop a strong and cohesive policy” on climate change.

The governor “has done a fairly good job up to this point in time, especially considering that he's had to deal with a state House that's been in flux,” he said.

Mr. Hvozdovich said the governor’s decision to obscure the details of the climate working group’s goals has had the unintended effect of calling attention to what it could be hiding rather than on what it could accomplish.

“We would like to see a little bit more transparency there,” he said. “I understand, in some ways, not wanting to have the process influenced. But it's tough to know how encouraging the fruits of that committee's labor is when you don't know who makes up the committee, let alone what they're actually discussing beyond the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative.”

“Who is he listening to? That's the question,” Mr. Badges-Canning said of Mr. Shapiro. “If these are reliable folks, why isn't he telling us who they are?”

Advertise with us

The only names that have been released to the public are those of the two co-chairs: Mike Dunleavy, a retired business manager for the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local Union No. 5 in Pittsburgh, and Jackson Morris, who oversees energy issues in the Northeast and Mid-Atlantic states for the Natural Resources Defense Council.

In his work for the NRDC, Mr. Morris has been a consistent advocate of RGGI, writing about the benefits of its cap-and-trade framework since at least 2014. He has published five blog posts on NRDC’s website over the last three years about Pennsylvania’s potential participation in the initiative, heralding it as “Pennsylvania’s path forward on climate in 2023.”

Wariness About Hydrogen Hubs

The governor’s support for hydrogen hubs, meanwhile, has alarmed environmental activists, who view the proposals as a cover for the oil and gas industry to continue business as usual under the guise of producing “clean” energy. Advocates for hydrogen as a fuel believe it could help reduce greenhouse gas emissions and could someday be used to power transportation and heating.

Because most forms of hydrogen production rely on fossil fuels, with blue hydrogen making use of carbon capture to reduce emissions, detractors are apprehensive about its effects on the environment. Hydrogen itself has been shown to have a “warming power” that is “much greater than previously recognized,” according to the Environmental Defense Fund.

Advertise with us

The Western Pennsylvania proposal, called DNA H2Hub, would produce blue hydrogen from natural gas and is backed by Shell Oil and the public-private partnership Team Pennsylvania, a group co-chaired by the governor. Promoters describe the proposal as a “collective vision for emissions reduction and economic revitalization.” Mock-ups on the project’s website depict the new Shell petrochemical plant in Monaca as a potential recipient of “feedstock and fuel” from the hub. Two environmental groups recently sued Shell over emissions and flaring at the Monaca plant.

“Blue hydrogen has a large greenhouse gas footprint,” said Ginny Marcille-Kerslake, the eastern Pennsylvania organizer for the environmental group Food & Water Watch.

Even green hydrogen, which harnesses renewable energy, is inefficient and has only limited necessary uses in industry, Ms. Marcille-Kerslake said. The eastern proposal, called MACH2, says that it will produce green hydrogen and pink hydrogen, which is made using nuclear energy.

Ms. Marcille-Kerslake is particularly concerned about the risks posed by the miles of pipeline that would be constructed to carry carbon dioxide for these hubs. Three years ago, she noted, a 2020 explosion of a carbon dioxide pipeline in Mississippi sent 46 people to the hospital and led to the evacuation of 300. “Fortunately, nobody died,” she said. “But it's a wake-up call to what we would be facing.”

This story is published in partnership with Inside Climate News, a nonprofit, independent news organization that covers climate, energy and the environment.