HARRISBURG — With lawmakers in stark disagreement on the wisdom of its finances and who it would help, the state House on Monday approved an expansion of a tax credit program to help offset parents’ child care costs.

Separately, the House gave final approval to a bill to let Pittsburgh set up a Longtime Owner-Occupant Program, or LOOP, that would give tax breaks to homeowners in neighborhoods where property values have increased rapidly.

The child care tax credit bill passed by a 141-62 vote, with 39 Republicans joining all Democrats in support of the measure. It now goes to the Senate for consideration. A spokesperson for Gov. Josh Shapiro declined comment.

The federal tax code includes credits to help offset the cost of child care. Last year, Pennsylvania enacted a similar program with a maximum credit of $315 for a family with one child. The bill sponsored by Rep. Tina Davis, D-Bucks, would expand that to a maximum of $900 in the first year and increase it gradually to $2,500 in 2027.

Advertise with us

Ms. Davis said child care costs generally range from $11,000 to $29,000 a year for families, depending on the number of children. She said the tax help newly offered to them in Pennsylvania was “a step in the right direction” but not enough.

“It is an unaffordable problem that we have to address now,” Ms. Davis said. “We need to support our working families.”

Several Republicans spoke out against the proposal. Rep. Seth Grove, R-York, said an estimate showed that if the bill becomes law, Pennsylvania will lose $1.5 billion in tax revenue over a five-year period. Mr. Grove called it “a welfare program built within the tax code.”

He also criticized the lack of an income limit for the tax credit. A review of federal data indicated that if it becomes law, 61% of the benefits in the first year would go to families with incomes of $75,000 or more. He called it legislation that would benefit “the working rich,” a sentiment echoed by Republican House Minority Leader Bryan Cutler, R-Lancaster.

“I don’t believe we are going after the right group of people who need help,” Mr. Cutler said.

Advertise with us

They were rebutted by Democrats. Rep. Steve Samuelson, D-Northampton, pointed out that the state has more than $5 billion in its Rainy Day Fund, as well as unspent money in the current fiscal year’s budget. The cost of child care, he said, is “absolutely a nightmare for our families and we should do something about it.”

House Majority Leader Matt Bradford, D-Montgomery, acknowledged the bill would help “middle class people” and was, at the same time, pro-business, pro-worker and pro-family in that it would allow some parents to return to work.

A somewhat parallel bill — one that would create an Earned Income Tax Credit in Pennsylvania similar to one offered in the federal tax code — was approved Monday by the House in a 122-81 vote, with 20 Republicans joining all Democrats in support.

Hours earlier, Republican Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman, R-Indiana, was asked how he felt about expanding child care state tax credits. He said he was willing to talk about it.

“I think there are areas we can come to agreement on in child care,” Mr. Pittman said. “Obviously parents need to be able to have their children cared for if they are going to be part of the labor force. We conceptually get the need to make those kinds of investments.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Pittman spoke to reporters as negotiations on the state budget intensified ahead of the June 30 end of the fiscal year. On Monday, Pittman said constant, informal conversations are taking place between the parties, and he doesn’t anticipate a major logjam that would prolong negotiations deep into the summer.

He spoke in blunt terms about a budget bill passed by the Democratic-controlled House that increased by more than $1 billion the spending called for by Mr. Shapiro in March. 

“I think the number that the House sent us is an impossible number to have under consideration,” Mr. Pittman said.

The LOOP bill was sponsored by Rep. Sara Innamorato, now the Democratic nominee for Allegheny County executive. It passed by a 103-100 vote, with a single Republican — Dauphin County’s Tom Mehaffie — joining all Democrats in support. That bill also will go to the Senate for consideration.

“I have often heard from this body a bipartisan cry for more local control,” Ms. Innamorato said. “This bill does just that.” She called the rapid increase in property values “a double-edged sword” which, because of bigger tax bills, hurts longtime homeowners.

Advertise with us

Currently, Philadelphia is the only city in the state with a program intended to help longtime homeowners with property tax relief.

Rep. Doyle Heffley, R-Carbon, attacked Ms. Innamorato’s bill as singling out a tiny sliver of homeowners for property tax relief when many across the state are in need of help. Mr. Heffley called it “only relief for a select few” and “a tax burden shift,” in which other homeowners would have to make up for breaks given to LOOP participants.

The Republican nominee for Allegheny County executive, Joe Rockey, called the bill “camouflage” for a plan by Ms. Innamorato for a countywide tax reassessment. 

“The focus on Pittsburgh and owner-occupied properties suggests it will shift the tax burden to suburban homeowners and renters across the county,” he said in a statement.

Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com