As vendors set up a community festival in downtown Beaver on Friday, Republicans were angry about the federal indictment of former President Donald Trump.

“It’s disgusting,” said Linda Clapper, 75, of Plum Borough. “I think they’re after him and going to do anything they can to stop his momentum.” 

“We know now the Democrats politicize everything, from the Department of Justice to the FBI,” said Tim Best, 76, of Beaver, another vendor at the annual Garrison Day Show and Sale. 

Mr. Trump, the only former U.S. president ever to face criminal charges, was indicted Thursday for allegedly mishandling classified documents after leaving office and obstructing attempts by authorities to retrieve them. The indictment unsealed Friday said those included documents regarding America’s nuclear program and “potential vulnerabilities of the United States and its allies to military attack.”

Advertise with us

In April, he was indicted in Manhattan on charges that he falsified business records to cover up hush-money payments to an adult film actress before the 2016 election. He remains under investigation by federal authorities and a Georgia prosecutor for his attempts to overturn his loss in the 2020 election. He has pleaded not guilty in the Manhattan case, denied all wrongdoing, and dismissed the investigations as partisan witch hunts to derail his 2024 campaign to win back the White House. The former president, a frontrunner in next year’s GOP primary contest, is due to appear Tuesday in federal court in Miami to answer the latest indictment.

None of it has caused his supporters to back away. In fact, it appears that Mr. Trump’s infamous statement that he could “stand in the middle of Fifth Avenue and shoot somebody” without losing voters remains operative.

Interviews with almost a dozen voters Friday in Beaver and Butler Counties, both Trump strongholds, provided just the latest of many indications over the years that Mr. Trump’s political standing with his most fervent supporters is all but unshakeable. Mr. Trump won Beaver County by 18 percentage points in the 2020 general election, and Butler County by 33 points (Joe Biden won more Democratic-friendly Allegheny County by 20 points).

At the Jeep Festival in downtown Butler, one voter, who said he supported Mr. Trump in 2016 and 2020 and would “absolutely” do the same in 2024, called the indictment “pathetic” and “a shame.”

“Why are they fighting so hard to keep this guy out of office?” said the 71-year old Vietnam veteran, who would only be identified as Bob D. “[The Democrats’] hatred of him is so great, they’re letting it get in the way of commonsense.”

Advertise with us

“Trump came in and ran the country like a successful business,” he added. “Sure he was rude and maybe crude, but he got stuff done.”

Public opinion research shows that voters like the Western Pennsylvania Republicans interviewed Friday are hardly alone.

In a Quinnipiac University survey released in May after the Manhattan indictment, 75% of Republicans said criminal charges should not disqualify Mr. Trump from running again, while only 23% said they should. And 93% of Republicans said Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg’s case was mainly motivated by politics, with only 5% saying it was motivated by the law.

Polls of the GOP presidential primary contest showed that Mr. Trump’s standing only improved after the earlier indictment. In the Quinnipiac survey in May, Mr. Trump led Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis 61% to 32%, compared to a 52% to 42% advantage in late March.

Republican primary voters are likely to greet the latest charges with a similar shrug of the shoulders. But Christopher Nicholas, a longtime Harrisburg-based Republican strategist, said the ongoing legal problems can only hurt Mr. Trump — and his party — in the long run.

Advertise with us

“The constant drip-drip-drip of criminal trouble for Trump is not good for him or the Republican Party,” Mr. Nicholas said. “While he may have a small and brief bump — a sugar high in polling — I think that will ease off once more details come out about the charges.”

And such strong statements of support from Mr. Trump’s supporters worry GOP strategists who fear he’s the only Republican who could lose the general election in 2024.

“What’s frustrating to a growing number of Republicans is that it’s becoming clear he’s the one potential nominee who could lose to Biden,” Mr. Nicholas said. “The Republican Party is united that we can’t have Biden for president one more day than required, so that’s very frustrating. If you took out [little-known GOP candidate] Larry Elder and Trump and put every Republican candidate in a hat and picked one, they’d be better situated to beat Biden.”

But almost no Republican elected officials or leaders are deserting Mr. Trump. After news of the indictment broke Thursday, they said it was just the latest chapter in an ongoing effort to bring down the former president before he can capture his third consecutive Republican nomination.

“The Deep State, Democrats, and Mainstream Media have relentlessly attacked President Trump for the past seven years in a disgraceful effort to stonewall his America First agenda and stop him from making America great,” U.S. Rep. Guy Reschenthaler, R-Peters, tweeted on Friday. “This time is no different.”

Advertise with us

Not every Republican is rushing to Mr. Trump’s defense. Some prefer to avoid the topic altogether. 

Asked about the indictment Friday, state Senate President Pro Tempore Kim Ward’s spokeswoman, Erica Clayton Wright, said: “Senator Ward is focused on making sure Pennsylvanians know we have their backs by advancing a budget that meets their needs while continuing to maintain a fiscal path that makes our Commonwealth more competitive.”

Democratic officials in Pennsylvania greeted the indictment more warmly.

U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, dismissed GOP claims that Mr. Trump is being unfairly targeted. “Every time I see a Republican talk about a ‘two-tiered’ justice systems,” she said in a series of Twitter posts, “I think of the countless Black lives ruined by a suddenly legalized and lucrative Marijuana industry. I think of Black kids handcuffed and arrested in elementary school. I think of Black mothers locked in jail for enrolling their kids in school using grandma's address so they can get a better education . . . I think of the #Exonerated5 who Donald Trump tried to have executed despite evidence of their innocence!”

On the other side of the state, Rep. Brendan Boyle, D-Philadelphia, mocked Mr. Trump by tweeting: “No President in American history is better at getting indicted than Donald Trump.” And Rep. Dwight Evans, D-Philadelphia, said that “no one should be above the law in the United States of America.”

Advertise with us

Republican voters said Friday that Mr. Trump’s policies, not what they called politically motivated investigations, are what matter in 2024. 

“When he was in office for four years, everything he promised to do he did do,” said Rita Mayberry, 55, a banker from Sarver, in Butler County. “He had the country going in the right direction and I know if he was in office again he would take the country in the right direction.

“I think that they’re just trying to make him look guilty of anything so he won’t run again,” said Ms. Mayberry, echoing Mr. Trump in calling the indictment “a witch hunt.”

Judy Lefevers, an independent voter who lives just over the Pennsylvania border in Rogers, Ohio, called the indictment “just wrong all the way around.” 

“They keep going after him so he won’t run,” said Ms. Lefevers, 61, adding that she would vote for Mr. Trump in 2024.

Advertise with us

Chaz Letzkus, a Democratic voter who lives in Allegheny County, said Mr. Trump deserved to be indicted

“It’s not just political. It’s not just a witch hunt or weaponization” of the system, said Mr. Letzkus, of Dormont. “Obviously, I think he needs to go to trial. At the very least, he should never be in the White House again and have access to classified documents.”

At the Beaver community festival, Ms. Clapper said that voters “who liked his policies are going to re-elect him because they want to go back to the way it should be. This giving away everything is ridiculous. No wonder we’re in the financial shape we’re in.”

And Mr. Best said Democrats are “scared to death he’s going to be elected again, expose them for who they are and get this country back on track.” 

“Unelected bureaucrats are running a lot of the government,” he said. “It shouldn’t be that way. Elected people should be running the government.”

Advertise with us

Ford Turner contributed to this report.

Adam Smeltz: asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz; Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com; Benjamin Kail: bkail@post-gazette.com, @BenKail; Jonathan D. Salant: jsalant@post-gazette.com, @JDSalant