HARRISBURG – A report released by a conservative think tank estimated that public schools could be on the hook for billions of dollars to settle lawsuits filed by survivors of sex abuse.

A lobbyist for a group that has been advocating for opening windows for justice for survivors of abuse in Pennsylvania and other states dismissed last week’s report as “the sky-is-falling fear-mongering.”

This comes as a group of House lawmakers appointed by Speaker Mark Rozzi, D-Berks, are scheduled to meet this week to try to develop a compromise to get the House moving on an amendment that would allow past lawsuits, particularly as lawmakers face a tight deadline to pass legislation in time to get ballot questions before voters in May.

Mr. Rozzi has said his top priority as speaker is to see that the state opens a window for justice to allow adult survivors of childhood sex abuse to sue their abusers and organizations, like the Catholic Church that covered up for predators. The state Senate, last week, passed legislation that would put the window for justice question on the ballot, but Republicans in that chamber bundled the relief for abuse survivors with other proposals that Democrats oppose – including measures that would ask voters whether to mandate voter ID, expand election audits and eliminate the governor’s veto power on legislative resolutions disapproving regulations.

Advertise with us

Gov. Tom Wolf called on the General Assembly to convene a special session to quickly pass the window for justice bill – a special session that Republican leaders dismissed as unnecessary. And the partisan gridlock means that adult survivors of sex abuse -- who have repeatedly had their hopes of relief dashed by the Legislature (and infamously by a bungled public notice requirement which delayed the ballot question by two years) -- could see another deadline pass without Pennsylvania joining the 24 other states -- including Delaware, New Jersey, New York and West Virginia – that have opened windows for lawsuits by abuse survivors.

While much of the focus of debate about the window for justice has focused on lawsuits targeting private organizations and churches, if the window were opened, it would also create an opportunity for lawsuits by people who’d been abused by public employees – including teachers and other school workers.

“Should the House pass Senate Bill 1, the question of changing the statute of limitations for child sexual abuse survivors will be presented to voters to decide if this matter warrants a change to the Constitution and the costs associated with it. Senate Bill 1 makes it clear that victims must have the same right to obtain justice, regardless of whether the abuse took place in a private or public institution,” said Kate Flessner, a spokeswoman for Senate President Pro Tem Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland.

An analysis released last Tuesday by the Susquehanna Valley Center for Public Policy suggests that the price tag from settlements involving school districts could be startling.

The center’s analysis said the costs to public schools of settlements with survivors of sex abuse could range from $5 billion to as much as $32 billion.

Advertise with us

The Susquehanna Valley Center for Public Policy report noted that in one New York school district, alone, the Ken-Ton School District, settled 35 claims – at a price tag of $17.5 million.

The report noted that depending on the methodology used, the number of potential claims ranged widely – from 10,000 to 15,000 claims “on the lower end,” and potentially 100,000.

The report pointed to comments made by a researcher who’d studied sex abuse in schools and concluded that the abuse in public schools was likely “100-times” worse than the abuse perpetrated by Catholic priests.

Those estimates don’t reflect the reality of the settlement claims in other states that have opened windows for justice, said Kathryn Robb, executive director of Child USAdvocacy.

A 2021 report by Child USA examining lawsuits filed in New York after that state opened its window for justice found that of almost 11,000 lawsuits, about 13% dealt with allegations of abuse in public schools.

Advertise with us

Clearly, though, there have been large settlements spawned by abuse in public schools. But there seems to be little available data to describe how many settlements involving public schools there have been nationally.

In California, the Los Angeles school district in October agreed to pay $52 million to settle a lawsuit filed by victims of a wrestling coach. Last March, the San Jose school district agreed to pay $102.5 million to settle lawsuits filed by victims abused by a middle school district.

A fiscal note attached to Senate Bill 1 includes no estimate of the potential public costs of settlements from lawsuits filed by survivors of abuse. Constitutional amendment ballot questions must be approved by the General Assembly in two consecutive legislative sessions. When the window for justice question bill was approved by the General Assembly, the fiscal notes completed by the Appropriations Committees in the House and Senate also did not attempted to quantify the cost to taxpayers from lawsuits by abuse survivors.

A spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association said the group “will not be speculating on how this situation will unfold.”