HARRISBURG — The Independent Regulatory Review Commission is scheduled to vote this week on a proposal by the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission to change the definition of “sex” in sex discrimination cases to offer protection to people who are discriminated against based on their gender identity or sexual orientation.

“The proposed regulation provides a comprehensive definition pertaining to the protected class of sex, including pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, sex assigned at birth, gender identity or expression, affectional or sexual orientation, and differences in sex development,” according to the regulatory analysis form submitted to IRRC.

The vote, scheduled for Thursday, comes as Congress considers whether to codify the right to same-sex marriages. Even so, the state move has largely flown under the radar as the final vote looms. The regulatory review commission received thousands of comments (many of them form letters) when the draft regulations were circulated, but there has been little comment submitted ahead of the final vote.

Republicans in both the House and Senate submitted comments criticizing the commission’s proposal, saying that the proposed changes should be accomplished legislatively rather than through the regulatory process.

Advertise with us

In seeking the change, the PHRC asserts that the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act and the Pennsylvania Fair Educational Opportunities Act don’t include a definition spelling out the meaning of the term “sex,” which creates the opportunity, or need, for the PHRC to set the definition.

While arguing that the ambiguity in those two acts give the commission the opportunity to set the definition of sex discrimination to include sexual orientation and gender identity, the PHRC also pointed to the 2020 U.S. Supreme Court Decision in Bostock v. Clayton County, which found that employers can’t legally discriminate against their employees based on their sexual orientation. Gerald Bostock had been fired by Clayton County, Ga., for “conduct unbecoming” of a county employee because he’d joined a gay recreational softball team. The Supreme Court concluded that Mr. Bostock’s firing violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which bars discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex and national origin.

In a June letter, a group of Republican lawmakers asserted that the PHRC is inappropriately trying to use the Supreme Court decision in Bostock to expand the definition of sex discrimination.

“The Supreme Court was clear in its decision that that particular holding narrowly pertains to the realm of employment discrimination prohibited under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. In fact, the ruling goes as far as to specifically refute the extension of its holding to such state laws similar to the PHRA when it said, ‘The employers worry that our decision will sweep beyond Title VII to other federal or state laws that prohibit sex discrimination... But none of these other laws are before us; we have not had the benefit of adversarial testing about the meaning of their terms, and we do not prejudge any such question today.’ In other words, while employers and employees are bound and/or protected by the provisions of Title VII, neither the PHRC nor the General Assembly are subject to any interpretation of the term ‘sex discrimination’ under the holding in Bostock,” according to the letter signed by Senate President Pro Tem Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland, and 10 other Senate Republicans.

Groups representing the LGBTQ community, however, have cheered the proposal and the implication that it would extend discrimination protections beyond simply employment discrimination.

Advertise with us

“We appreciate the work of the Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission, and we applaud your decision to draft new regulations relative to these classes. Through the new regulations, which cover the Pennsylvania Human Relations Act (PHRA) and the Pennsylvania Fair Educational Opportunities Act (PFEOA), the Commonwealth’s LGBTQIA+ community will be protected from discrimination in housing, employment, medical care, education, and access to public accommodations,” according to comments submitted to IRRC by the Rainbow Rose Center in York.