Down by fewer than 1,000 votes to Mehmet Oz in the GOP primary, U.S. Senate candidate Dave McCormick asked the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania on Tuesday to step in and order counties to tally mail-in ballots that lack a handwritten date, but were otherwise verified to have been cast on time.
As the campaigns battle on the margins of a Senate race that’s all but certain to head to an automatic recount, Mr. McCormick’s campaign had first asked the Commonwealth Court to issue an emergency injunction, warning that without immediate action by the court, “qualified voters will be disenfranchised today” when county boards reported unofficial returns to the state without their votes counted.
Neither court acted on Tuesday, but the Supreme Court justices ordered counties to file responses by 4 p.m. on Thursday, according to The Associated Press.
“These are legitimate votes where the voter didn’t handwrite the date on them, but again, they were time-stamped,” Mr. McCormick told The Hugh Hewitt Show on Tuesday morning. “If they were time-stamped, why would anyone want to throw those votes out?”
Mr. McCormick was trailing Mr. Oz by 985 votes as of Tuesday evening, according to the state’s election results portal. Even though the state had required counties to file unofficial results by Tuesday at 5 p.m., more votes will be tallied after the deadline in the coming days, including military and civilian overseas ballots.
Mr. Oz’s lead was at a margin of 0.07% as of Tuesday evening, well within the 0.5% margin for an automatic recount.
It’s highly unlikely that Mr. Oz can get the thousands of votes he’d need to widen the gap on Mr. McCormick and win without recount; in the populous Allegheny County, officials said they received only 194 military and civilian ballots overall, and that’s including Democratic ballots.
But with the likelihood of a recount changing the outcome facing long odds, Mr. McCormick's only path might be to scrape for any votes he can get to close the margin.
Mr. McCormick said his suit — seeking to compel counties to tally undated mail-in ballots — is about counting “legitimate votes.” The ballots in question are missing handwritten dates on their return envelopes, but were time-stamped by county elections offices upon receipt.
Mr. McCormick’s legal efforts began in Commonwealth Court on Monday, when he asked the judges to require counties to follow a brand-new federal appeals court decision and count the undated mail-ins.
He was referencing a ruling in a separate case in the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, which said late last week that the state election law's requirement of a handwritten date on the outer envelope was "immaterial." Lawyers in that case have signaled they will appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.
The request for emergency relief by Mr. McCormick — and the Supreme Court push — added a new layer of urgency to the vote count in one of the country's most important races.
Mr. McCormick’s legal team told the Commonwealth Court that “likely thousands of voters will be unlawfully disenfranchised on account of an immaterial technical error” if its judges don’t jump in.
To the state Supreme Court, his lawyers wrote, “All valid votes should be counted. Period.”
The state has not said how many of these ballots exist across Pennsylvania, but in Allegheny County — the county with the most registered Republicans in Pennsylvania — there are 218. Of those 218, though, just 36 are Republican ballots applicable to the Senate race.
In guidance sent to counties Tuesday morning, the state advised officials to segregate the undated ballots, tabulate them separately and wait for further direction, pending litigation.
Allegheny County’s election return board reconvened Tuesday in a warehouse on the North Side, where they reviewed provisional ballots alongside authorized representatives from both Mr. Oz and Mr. McCormick’s campaigns.
Both campaigns were given the opportunity to challenge specific provisional ballots, and in the end, 31 were challenged. The county Board of Elections — made up of county executive Rich Fitzgerald and at-large county council-members Bethany Hallam and Sam DeMarco — will meet on Friday afternoon to consider the challenges.
Mr. McCormick, on Mr. Hewitt’s radio show, said the race will “certainly go to a recount.”
In Allegheny County, elections workers are preparing for the prospect. On Wednesday, they will start “opening the ballot bags from each precinct and placing them in labeled banker boxes so that they are ready for any ordered recount,” a county spokeswoman said in a statement.
Counties were required to submit unofficial tallies — to the best of their abilities — by 5 p.m. on Tuesday.
The state is required to order a recount, if applicable, by Thursday at 5 p.m.
Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter @julianrouth. The Associated Press contributed




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.