CARLISLE, Pa. — The chances are dwindling now for candidates for statewide office to change the trajectory of their campaigns.
But with big spenders David McCormick and Dr. Mehmet Oz off-stage, Tuesday’s “Spotlight on Pennsylvania” debate among the five other candidates on the Republican Party’s U.S. Senate primary ballot had a golden chance to do just that.
Here’s a look at how the five candidates — who have trailed Mr. McCormick and Mr. Oz in opinion polls since they established political air superiority through an advertising blitzkrieg this winter — on the stage distinguished themselves.
The 2020 election
Jeff Bartos, the Montgomery County real estate developer and 2018 GOP lieutenant governor nominee, and Philadelphia attorney George Bochetto both said they would have voted to certify Pennsylvania’s 2020 election results.
That’s not necessarily an easy position for Republicans to take in the wake of former President Donald Trump’s false charges of electoral fraud — here and in other swing states around the nation — that he and his allies have baselessly claimed cost him a second term.
Read More
Mr. Bartos called his hypothetical decision in part a technical one based on a close reading of the Electoral Count Act, which he said gives the Congress a pretty ministerial role in the process. But he also explained that, given his familiarity with the county officials across Pennsylvania after a full year of campaigning, he has faith that the counties by and large did their jobs accurately and fairly.
Mr. Bochetto, who during the campaign has often touted the fact that his law firm was asked to help frame the free speech defense for Mr. Trump during his second impeachment trial in February 2021, also adopted a pro-certification stance when asked for a clarification after the debate.
But Mr. Bochetto made plain during Tuesday’s debate that he believed the election was run under a law that he believes improperly permitted no-excuse, mail-in balloting in Pennsylvania, which he said he would try to end if elected to the Senate. But he clarified to PennLive that he would have had to have left the 2020 results stand because there wasn’t a demonstration of widespread fraud at that time.
Candidates Carla Sands and Sean Gale made clear they would not have voted to certify the vote in January 2021.
Ms. Sands, the Cumberland County native who made her fortune with her late husband in California and parlayed her support for Republican candidates including Mr. Trump into an appointment as U.S. ambassador to Denmark, she said she couldn’t have voted to certify based on the unresolved questions she had at that time.
Mr. Gale, like Mr. Bochetto, he believes the state law permitting the mail-in balloting — which was approved with bipartisan support before Pennsylvania Republicans turned on it after the 2020 election — was unconstitutional. He said he would vote not to certify on that basis.
Kathy Barnette, the conservative commentator and author from Montgomery County, didn’t directly answer the question on certification but claimed she did see irregularities in the 2020 election, in which she ran in an unsuccessful campaign for Congress against U.S. Rep. Madeleine Dean.
Ms. Sands, Mr. Gale and Mr. Bochetto also made clear that they would seek to end no-excuse mail-in balloting in the future.
“If France ... can have an election day — in-person, with paper ballots, affirming that they are a citizen, and they can count those votes in one day, and they can tell the citizens of France the outcome of that election — how the heck can we not do it in the greatest democracy in the world?” Ms. Sands asked, referring to France’s presidential election Sunday.
Unfriendly fire
While several of the candidates trained fire on the two candidates who weren’t in the room Tuesday night, Mr. Gale and Ms. Sands made several pointed attacks on Ms. Barnette, who has shown some improvement in some recent polling in the race.
Ms. Sands at one point veered from a question on universal background checks for gun sales into assailing Ms. Barnette for losing to Ms. Dean in the 2020 congressional race by nearly 20 percentage points. Ms. Sands argued that sort of result wouldn’t cut it against a Democrat like Lt. Gov. John Fetterman, the polling leader in the Democratic Senate primary.
Ms. Barnette countered that she gives the Republican Party a unique chance to broaden its tent.
“When I walk through that door [as a Black woman], my very presence neutralizes more than half of Democrats’ talking points,” Ms. Barnette said. “That is power in the hands of the Republican Party.”
Mr. Gale, an attorney from Montgomery County, then took his turn to lash out at Ms. Barnette.
“Her whole campaign is she’s going to be the first Republican Black woman in the Senate. ... That’s exactly what we’re seeing, and I’ll prove it this way: There’s seven candidates running for this race. There’s nine running for governor. There’s only one candidate that had to put her picture on the sign, and that’s Kathy Barnette.”
Ms. Barnette shrugged off the attacks.
“Listen, they’re punching up right now,” she said of Mr. Gale and Ms. Sands. “They’re losing, and so, they’re looking for a viral moment.”
Different shades of red
There was broad agreement on a lot of the polestars of 21st-century Republican ideology, like increasing border security, getting control over federal spending, undoing abortion rights and vowing to protect the right to own guns. But there were some nuances.
On immigration reform, for example:
Mr. Bochetto said he supports the creation of year-round, low-skill visas to help America’s farmers flesh out their labor forces.
“We can keep track of these people, we can register them, they can pay taxes, and we know who they are and where they’re coming from. That’s the kind of immigration reform we need,” Mr. Bochetto said. “It’s not enough just to say we’re going to plug the hole in the border.”
Ms. Barnette promised stronger oversight of the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services to try to address what she said is a 1.5 million person backlog in processing applications for green cards and citizenship.
Mr. Bartos said he would be a vote for withholding federal funds from so-called sanctuary cities — municipalities with a policy, written or unwritten, that discourages local police from reporting the immigration status of individuals unless it involves investigation of a serious crime. In Pennsylvania, Philadelphia has adopted that tack.
On abortion, all the candidates said they consider life to begin at conception and that they would look to abolish abortions from that point. But Mr. Bartos made clear he would permit exceptions in cases where the life of the expecting mother is at risk or in cases where a pregnancy resulted from a rape.
Ms. Barnette, who has said that she was the child of a rape, and Mr. Bochetto said they would support exceptions for the life of the mother.
Mr. Gale said he wants an abortion ban with no exceptions.
In a question designed purely for Republican voters, Mr. Gale, Mr. Bochetto and Ms. Barnette counted themselves as definite or likely “no” votes for Sen. Mitch McConnell, R-Kentucky, as the Republicans’ floor leader in the Senate.
Mr. Bochetto said he thinks the Republicans need new blood and believes Mr. McConnell was divisive in how he handled the 2021 impeachment of Mr. Trump. At the time, Mr. McConnell first signaled to his colleagues that he felt Mr. Trump bore responsibility for the Jan. 6 insurrection, but then he voted to acquit Mr. Trump at trial. Then he excoriated the former president in a post-vote floor speech.
Mr. Gale, once again, was far rougher: “You’ve been there for 36 years. 79 years old. If you haven’t got it done yet, you’re not going to get it done now. ... Mitch McConnell has been a failure, and on Day One when I get to Washington, I’m going to lead the effort to oust Mitch McConnell as the leader of our party. He has to go.”
Mr. Bartos said he would have to see who’s in the running to lead the party, though he allowed that his personal favorite for the position would be Sen. Tim Scott of South Carolina.
Ms. Sands sidestepped the question, saying her focus is on making sure that a Republican will be the majority leader instead of the current holder, Democrat Chuck Schumer of New York.
As for the missing candidates, McCormick spokeswoman Jess Szymanski said he was occupied with a campaign finance dinner in Philadelphia. Mr. Oz’s campaign told debate organizers that he too had a schedule conflict; they did not elaborate.
Both campaigns noted that their candidates did participate in a Senate debate broadcast on Pennsylvania’s Nexstar television stations Monday night.
In November, the winner of the Republican primary will face the winner of the Democratic primary between Mr. Fetterman, U.S. Rep. Conor Lamb, state Rep. Malcom Kenyatta and Jenkintown borough Councilwoman Alexandria Khalil.
The primary election is May 17.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.