The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Friday denied a request by the leader of the state House GOP caucus to hold the 2022 legislative elections under current district boundaries, striking a blow to Republicans who argue that the new maps represent an unconstitutional gerrymander.

The court’s order means that candidates for the state House and Senate can reasonably expect they’ll be running on new maps — but whether it’s the Legislative Reapportionment Commission’s final plan is still to be determined.

That plan is in the midst of a 30-day period for court challenges, in which the state Supreme Court gets to hear arguments from those who raise legal issues about the commission’s once-a-decade redrawing.

House Majority Leader Kerry Benninghoff, R-Centre, is the most prominent figure so far to challenge the proposed legislative maps. He’s asking the court to deem the maps unconstitutional and give them back to the commission again — this time to pass a plan that doesn’t “eviscerate” the principle that voters choose their representatives, not the other way around, according to legal filings.

Advertise with us

But Mr. Benninghoff’s simultaneous request — that the court order that the 2022 elections occur under the current map — was denied.

The Supreme Court did not give a reason for denying his emergency relief request, but lawyers for the state and for the reapportionment commission argued that Mr. Benninghoff’s request was premature and that it misrepresented the timeline leading up to the May 17 primary.

Read More

Mr. Benninghoff had argued there was “a significant chance that not all complaints [would] be sufficiently resolved to give Pennsylvania voters and putative candidates certainty that the districts adopted in the final plan will be usable during the current election cycle.”

Lawyers for Leigh Chapman, acting secretary of the commonwealth, and state election officials countered that it would be unprecedented for the court to rule before it had adjudicated appeals that the election cannot proceed under the commission’s plan. They also accused Mr. Benninghoff of making “mistaken” factual assumptions about the feasibility of implementing the election calendar in time.

“In fact, not only has the Department of State already shown that it is not too late to conduct the primary election under the LRC’s Final Plan, but this Court has recently indicated that it may adopt final redistricting plans — for both congressional and state legislative elections — even sooner than the Department had proposed,” the state’s lawyers wrote.

Advertise with us

In a statement to the Post-Gazette after the emergency relief was denied, House GOP spokesman Jason Gottesman accused the Democrat-majority Supreme Court of playing politics.

“This decision and how it has been presented is certainly disappointing and something we strongly disagree with,” Mr. Gottesman said. “However, given that four liberal justices — a majority of the court — just took marching orders from national Democrats in selecting a partisan congressional map, it is not surprising they would be greasing the skids for their hand-picked partisan chairman.”

The Supreme Court has not yet ruled on Mr. Benninghoff’s full petition for relief, which asks the court to deem the maps unconstitutional.

Mr. Benninghoff was a member of the reapportionment commission, and was the only one to vote against the maps when they passed earlier this month.

University of Pittsburgh chancellor emeritus Mark Nordenberg, who chaired the commission, told the Post-Gazette recently that he thought the commission produced fair maps that would help reverse years of baked-in advantages, more accurately reflecting the reality of Pennsylvania’s intricate political landscape and changing population.

Julian Routh: jrouth@post-gazette.com; Twitter: @julianrouth