HARRISBURG — Gov. Tom Wolf the day before Thanksgiving spent some of his day signing many of the bills sent to him by the General Assembly a week earlier, but he didn’t sign all of them.

Three bills, all of which Mr. Wolf claimed put public health at risk, were rejected by the governor.

Senate Bill 790, along with House Bills 1747 and 2440, didn’t pass muster with Mr. Wolf, which wasn’t too surprising, given that he clearly said in prior weeks and months that he would veto SB790 should it ever get to his desk, and he’s vetoed bills similar to HBs 1747 and 2440.

SB790 would have created a new Conventional Oil and Gas Wells Act, with provisions separate from those governing unconventional wells, such as those used to extract natural gas in the Marcellus shale.

Advertise with us

“While this legislation attempts to address the distinct challenges associated with the conventional oil and gas industry, it does so in a manner that does not adequately protect the environment and the public health and safety of the citizens of the Commonwealth, and would contribute to a legacy of environmental degradation,” wrote Mr. Wolf in his veto message, later calling the legislation unacceptable because he said the conventional industry is incurring violations at a rate three-to-four times that of the unconventional industry.

“The Department of Environmental Protection has repeatedly offered to engage collaboratively with the General Assembly and the regulated community to develop requirements specifically tailored to the conventional oil and gas industry's operations,” Mr. Wolf stated. “Unfortunately, instead of seeing that collaborative approach through, this legislation was pursued, which rolls back protections for safe drinking water, weakens protection of public resources, allows more spills to go unreported, and avoids erosion and sediment control permitting requirements. This legislation poses an unacceptable risk to the environment and the public health and safety of our citizens.”

SB790’s prime sponsor, Senate President Pro Tem Joe Scarnati, R-Jefferson, has argued that Act 13 of 2012 updated the state’s Oil and Gas Act to deal with the uniqueness of the much larger unconventional industry, but some of Act 13’s provisions placed additional burdens on the much smaller conventional producers tha has produced a significant negative impact on the conventional oil and gas industry over time, to the point that Mr. Scarnati says the industry has been brought to near-collapse.

Those sentiments were echoed by state Rep. Martin Causer, the chair of the House Republican Policy Committee, on Wednesday in reaction to the veto.

“There are major differences between unconventional deep-well drilling and conventional, shallow-well drilling…differences that this administration continues to ignore because it doesn’t fit their narrative,” Mr. Causer said. “The industry is struggling immensely, and a significant cause of that struggle is the lack of understanding and purposeful misrepresentation of how our conventional oil and gas operations work in a safe and environmentally conscious manner.”

Advertise with us

He noted SB790 was developed in large part by members of the Penn Grade Crude Development Advisory Council, on which the DEP is also represented, with the DEP participating in the legislation’s development. Mr. Causer said the council was created by Act 52 of 2016 to advise and assist DEP with regulatory changes impacting the conventional industry.

The legislation would be introduced again in the coming two-year legislative session that begins in January, said Mr. Causer.

And, as long as the governor continues to maintain a disaster emergency for COVID-19 in Pennsylvania — which he renewed again for as much as another 90 days on Wednesday — it’s likely lawmakers will continue to introduce bills like HBs 1747 and 2440, which sought to assert the rights of gun owners during disaster emergencies.

With regard to HB1747, supporters of the bill say it was introduced in response to early efforts during the COVID-19 outbreak by the governor to suspend gun sales as part of his larger shutdown of businesses deemed to be non-life sustaining. The closing of gun shops was later reversed by Mr. Wolf after the Pennsylvania Supreme Court suggested his closing of the shops constituted “an absolute and indefinite prohibition upon the acquisition of firearms by the citizens of this commonwealth — a result in clear tension with the Second Amendment” and the Pennsylvania Constitution.

HB1747 was passed by the General Assembly in an effort to both remove the current prohibition of carrying a firearm in public during an emergency proclamation from the state or a municipal government, as well as the gubernatorial authority to limit the sale, dispensing or transportation of firearms during a disaster emergency declaration.

Advertise with us

While Mr. Wolf did not acknowledge in his veto message that in March he had actually prevented gun sales at one point as part of his exercising of emergency powers and then adjusted his disaster emergency order in light of the state Supreme Court’s position, the governor — as he has with several other bills sent to him by the Legislature during the COVID-19 outbreak— bristled at any attempt to statutorily limit his authority during a public health or any other type of emergency.

“Tough choices must be made during a disaster emergency in order to protect the public safety and welfare of the people of Pennsylvania in accordance with the Emergency Management Services Code and our constitution,” wrote Mr. Wolf in his veto message. “Possessing the appropriate tools to protect Pennsylvanians from the various threats posed by disaster emergencies is critical.”

Also determined by the governor to be a limitation on his authority was HB2440, which sought to designate shooting ranges, sportsman clubs, hunting facilities and firearm and ammunition product manufacturers, retailers, importers and distributors as life-sustaining businesses. As such, the legislation provided that those businesses would never be closed  or limited in their ability to produce, provide, sell or otherwise offer firearms, ammunition, firearm accessories, component parts of firearms, ammunition and firearm accessories, services, training, safety and practice related to firearms and hunting.

“Outdoor sportsman clubs provide great joy and relief to the residents of our commonwealth,” said bill sponsor Rep. Bill Kortz, D-Allegheny, of the bill’s sportsman club provisions. “Therefore, in order to ensure the safety of the employees and patrons of these clubs, I am introducing legislation that would provide a uniform standard for of all outdoor sportsman clubs in Pennsylvania in response to the current situation, so that they are in accordance with the Pennsylvania Department of Health’s COVID-19 guidelines.”

“This bill represents another meaningless attempt to alter the necessary tools for fighting the pandemic, wrote Mr. Wolf in his veto message. “Instead of focusing on health and safety and mitigation efforts this bill distracts from the fight against the emergency in front of us.”

Wolf pointed to the daily growth in virus cases and suggested that a “carve out” for “shooting ranges, sportsman clubs, hunting facilities and the firearm industry from any mitigation efforts” would be detrimental to ongoing efforts to control the spread of the virus.